Making Animal Meaning

Making Animal Meaning

Linda Kalof
Georgina M. Montgomery
Series: The Animal Turn
Copyright Date: 2011
Pages: 312
https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.14321/j.ctt7zt85w
  • Cite this Item
  • Book Info
    Making Animal Meaning
    Book Description:

    An elucidating collection of ten original essays,Making Animal Meaningreconceptualizes methods for researching animal histories and rethinks the contingency of the human-animal relationship. The vibrant and diverse field of animal studies is detailed in these interdisciplinary discussions, which include voices from a broad range of scholars and have an extensive chronological and geographical reach. These exciting discourses capture the most compelling theoretical underpinnings of animal significance while exploring meaning-making through the study of specific spaces, species, and human-animal relations. A deeply thoughtful collection - vital to understanding central questions of agency, kinship, and animal consumption - these essays tackle the history and philosophy of constructing animal meaning.

    eISBN: 978-1-60917-234-3
    Subjects: Sociology, Anthropology, Zoology

Table of Contents

  1. Front Matter
    (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    (pp. vii-viii)
  3. Introduction
    (pp. ix-xiv)

    Making Animal Meaningexplores how humans construct, configure, and constantly negotiate the meaning of other animals in the social world. This meaning-making is not a new human pastime. We have been struggling with the essence of animals for at least 33,000 years—our earliest known surviving artistic endeavours are drawings of lions and rhinoceroses on cave walls in southern France and carvings of birds and horses from mammoth ivory in southwestern Germany. With the onset of writing, the construction of animal meaning took center stage in the first epic poem,Gilgamesh, which tells the story of a friendship between a...

  4. PART 1. MAKING NEW ANIMAL MEANINGS
    • Animal Writes: Historiography, Disciplinarity, and the Animal Trace
      (pp. 3-16)
      ETIENNE BENSON

      Those of us who attempt to write about nonhuman animals are all implicated by the pun that appears in the title and throughout the text of Jacques Derrida’sL’Animal que donc je suis.¹ I follow or track (suis, from the infinitivesuivre) the animals about whom or about which I write, and I also am (suis, fromêtre) an animal—specifically, a writing animal. This doubleness of animal writing—its way of situating us simultaneously as subject and object, autobiographer and biographer, pursued and pursuer—is evocatively captured in the opening line of Philip Armstrong’s study,What Animals Mean in...

    • Mobility and the Making of Animal Meaning: The Kinetics of “Vermin” and “Wildlife” in Southern Africa
      (pp. 17-44)
      CLAPPERTON CHAKANETSA MAVHUNGA

      Microbes, insects, birds, and wild animals (hereafter “the animal”) have played a key role in influencing humans to make contingent environmental decisions in the Limpopo basin of southern Africa from the mid-eighteenth to the late-twentieth centuries. This exploration is part of a larger project examining human deployment of weapons of war—principally guns and poisons—in ways that level different bodies big and small into one ontology of pesthood. The status of being a pest (an organism whose characteristics humans regard as injurious or unwanted) is the ultimate designation of living things, including humans, as animals. Because some humans assign...

    • Cannibalism, Consumption, and Kinship in Animal Studies
      (pp. 45-56)
      ANALÍA VILLAGRA

      His powerful body is eerily inert. Burly arms, barrel-chest flecked with the silvery gray of age and leadership, the strong face completely still as the villagers soberly carry his body out of the forest and through the sunlit field. His was no accidental death, but a murder, a political killing at the center of civil strife in a national park in the Democratic Republic of Congo. The victim described here is the silverback male of the Virunga gorilla troop, one of seven gorillas killed “in cold blood” in July 2007.¹ The Virunga forest has been in the news before, famous...

  5. PART 2. APPLYING NEW ANIMAL MEANINGS
    • The Renaissance Transformation of Animal Meaning: From Petrarch to Montaigne
      (pp. 59-80)
      BENJAMIN ARBEL

      In his influential bookAnimal Liberation(first edition, 1975), the philosopher Peter Singer raised the idea that the emphasis given in humanistic culture to the dignity of Man, his freedom and his unbound capacities, forcibly led to the decrease of the status of other creatures in Renaissance thought. Singer qualified this generalization by singling out Leonardo da Vinci, Giordano Bruno, and Michel de Montaigne as pioneers in offering an alternative approach to animals.¹ But other scholars who later referred to the historical development of attitudes to animals tended to ignore the evidence of a developing concern for animals in the...

    • On the Trail of the Devil Cat: Hunting for the Jaguar in the United States and Mexico
      (pp. 81-98)
      SHARON WILCOX ADAMS

      Few animals capture the human imagination like large mammalian predators. Charismatic megafauna such as bears, wolves, and big cats are frequently present in cultural discourse, working as symbols and proxies for a vast range of beliefs, values, taboos, and anxieties. The largest feline species in the Western Hemisphere, the jaguar (Panthera onca) has long evoked complex and often conflicting emotions of awe, reverence, anger, and fear in neighboring human communities.¹ In areas now identified as the southwestern United States and Mexico, the jaguar was represented as a symbol of hunting prowess, spirituality, divine might, political power, and/or military strength among...

    • Animal Deaths and the Written Record of History: The Politics of Pet Obituaries
      (pp. 99-112)
      JANE DESMOND

      A black Labrador dog named Bear broke the species barrier and made it into the obituary pages of my local paper a few years ago (see figure 1). He was the first animal ever so commemorated in that newspaper (theIowa City [Iowa] Press-Citizen). Bear died quietly in his sleep on the morning of April 14, 2003, at thirteen years of age. But if his passing was peaceable, the period after his death was not. His obituary became the cause of bitter debate in our community. Why would a simple publication in a local newspaper generate such a firestorm of...

    • Golden Retrievers Are White, Pit Bulls Are Black, and Chihuahuas Are Hispanic: Representations of Breeds of Dog and Issues of Race in Popular Culture
      (pp. 113-126)
      MEISHA ROSENBERG

      As the buzz surrounding the Obamas’ recently acquired Portuguese water dog shows, choices about dog breed carry political implications having to do with identity and race. Initially, President Obama expressed interest in adopting a shelter or rescue dog—“Obviously, a lot of shelter dogs are mutts like me,” he said, using a little anthropomorphic humor to make reference to his own mixed-race heritage.¹ But partly because the family’s other major concern was daughter Malia’s allergies, he ultimately accepted a pedigreed Portuguese water dog, Bo. Bo had been originally bred in Texas; when he did not work out with his first...

    • Interspecies Families, Freelance Dogs, and Personhood: Saved Lives and Being One at an Assistance Dog Agency
      (pp. 127-144)
      AVIGDOR EDMINSTER

      My ethnographic informants at a North American assistance dog agency say they can read each other’s minds, have saved each other’s lives, hear for one another, are members of the same family, and are business partners. The clients, assistance dogs, and volunteers at the agency have uniquely intimate and interdependent interspecies relationships, which they cultivate and cherish despite the pervasive assumption of absolute differences between humans and all other species. My research examines the intricacies of these relationships, which my informants feel are so critical to their well-being. I concentrate on the ways my informants understand and create that which...

    • Animal Meaning in T. S. Eliot’s Old Possum’s Book of Practical Cats
      (pp. 145-158)
      STACY RULE

      While there are many studies of animals in children’s narrative fiction, there has been relatively little serious treatment of children’s poetry—something individuals in both the children’s literary and educational communities have expressed disappointment over. Agnes Perkins regrets that “compared with articles on fiction of all sorts, or even on nonfiction, and biographical articles on authors, and pieces on pedagogical methods, the number of critical works concerned with poetry for children is minuscule.”¹ More recently, Anita Tarr has observed, “Even within the field of children’s literature, poetry for children has suffered unaccountably.”² Indeed, when readings do address poetry about animals,...

    • Animals at the End of the World: Notes toward a Transspecies Eschatology
      (pp. 159-172)
      CASEY R. RIFFEL

      From the initial scene of Philip K. Dick’s dystopian science fiction novelDo Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?(1968), issues of empathy, commodity fetishism, and ontological authenticity frame how questions of human and animal being play out in a postapocalyptic world. Deckard, one of few humans remaining on Earth after an apocalypse—ambiguous in its cause if not in its effects—emerges onto the roof of his apartment building to attend to the electric sheep he keeps as a pet. Attending to its small patch of grass, the sheep literally embodies humanity’s anxiety about its uncertain relationship to the past;...

  6. Bibliography
    (pp. 173-192)
  7. Contributors
    (pp. 193-194)
  8. Index
    (pp. 195-197)
  9. Back Matter
    (pp. 198-198)