Feeding the City
Feeding the City: From Street Market to Liberal Reform in Salvador, Brazil, 1780–1860
RICHARD GRAHAM
Copyright Date: 2010
Published by: University of Texas Press
https://doi.org/10.7560/722996
https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7560/722996
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Feeding the City
Book Description:

On the eastern coast of Brazil, facing westward across a wide magnificent bay, lies Salvador, a major city in the Americas at the end of the eighteenth century. Those who distributed and sold food, from the poorest street vendors to the most prosperous traders-black and white, male and female, slave and free, Brazilian, Portuguese, and African-were connected in tangled ways to each other and to practically everyone else in the city, and are the subjects of this book. Food traders formed the city's most dynamic social component during the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, constantly negotiating their social place. The boatmen who brought food to the city from across the bay decisively influenced the outcome of the war for Brazilian independence from Portugal by supplying the insurgents and not the colonial army. Richard Graham here shows for the first time that, far from being a city sharply and principally divided into two groups-the rich and powerful or the hapless poor or enslaved-Salvador had a population that included a great many who lived in between and moved up and down.

The day-to-day behavior of those engaged in food marketing leads to questions about the government's role in regulating the economy and thus to notions of justice and equity, questions that directly affected both food traders and the wider consuming public. Their voices significantly shaped the debate still going on between those who support economic liberalization and those who resist it.

eISBN: 978-0-292-78468-0
Subjects: History, Sociology
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. vii-viii)
  3. LIST OF TABLES
    LIST OF TABLES (pp. ix-ix)
  4. LIST OF MAPS AND ILLUSTRATIONS
    LIST OF MAPS AND ILLUSTRATIONS (pp. x-x)
  5. A NOTE ON CURRENCY, MEASURES, AND SPELLING
    A NOTE ON CURRENCY, MEASURES, AND SPELLING (pp. xi-xii)
  6. PREFACE
    PREFACE (pp. xiii-xviii)
  7. INTRODUCTION
    INTRODUCTION (pp. 1-8)

    No city feeds itself. Unlike a village or small town, a city depends on a vast array of outsiders to grow or raise food, and most essentially, on people to transport it, and on middlemen and -women to buy and resell it to consumers. Salvador, Brazil—often called Bahia—was a major city in the Americas at the end of the eighteenth century. It invites inquiry not only into such a commercial network, but also into what its workings reveal about the city’s social makeup. Street sellers, boatmen, grocers, butchers, cattle dealers, importers; men and women; blacks, mulattos, and whites;...

  8. CHAPTER 1 THE CITY ON A BAY
    CHAPTER 1 THE CITY ON A BAY (pp. 9-30)

    On the eastern coast of brazil and facing westward across a magnificent bay lies the city of Salvador or, to give it its full name, São Salvador da Bahia de Todos os Santos (Holy Savior of the Bay of All Saints). The city’s name eloquently recalls the bay as it is its most defining feature. Its shimmering waters could be seen to the west from almost any vantage point in the city, and in 1780 its inhabitants received most of their foodstuffs, except meat, by boat. This enormous bay reaches inland for some 27 miles. It measures 22 miles at...

  9. PART I. Getting and Selling Food
    • CHAPTER 2 FROM STREETS AND DOORWAYS
      CHAPTER 2 FROM STREETS AND DOORWAYS (pp. 33-53)

      Ana de são josé da trindade took out a license in 1807 for herself and three of her slaves to sell foodstuffs door-to-door in Salvador or to set up a stall at a corner or square. She died in 1823, and when her will was opened, readers discovered many things that may not have surprised them, but surprise us. That she was illiterate is only to be expected, for she was born in West Africa and brought to Brazil on a slaving ship at an early but unspecified age. Upon arrival in Salvador she was sold as part of a...

    • CHAPTER 3 CONNECTIONS
      CHAPTER 3 CONNECTIONS (pp. 54-73)

      As street vendors and store owners constructed a citywide community, horizontal ties criss-crossed vertical ones, multiplying their contacts with a broad segment of the population. Business itself meant constructing networks, but those engaged in the food trade were not merely economic creatures. They had a variety of ties to others, pointing in many directions. From these connections they naturally built up solidarity with some and hostility toward others while deining themselves. Families, friendships, neighborhoods, and venues where they frequently gathered provided occasions for sociability and the sharing of cultural backgrounds as well as tense moments that could lead to negotiating...

    • CHAPTER 4 “PEOPLE OF THE SEA”
      CHAPTER 4 “PEOPLE OF THE SEA” (pp. 74-91)

      Salvador’s port formed the hub of the food trade, with some spokes radiating into the city, and others linking it to points of supply in the hinterland. Sailors, captains, and boat owners connected farmers to the city’s grocers and street vendors, making Salvador’s inhabitants utterly dependent on them. The bay served as a path for cultural interchange because people on shore daily interacted with those who brought food across the water, with taken-for-granted urban understandings penetrating the interior and vice versa. To a degree, the ranks of those who sailed relected the shape of society at large, and for these...

    • CHAPTER 5 THE GRAINS MARKET
      CHAPTER 5 THE GRAINS MARKET (pp. 92-106)

      Sailors, captains, and boat owners met stevedores and porters, petty traders and large merchants at Salvador’s bay-side grains market (see Map 1.3). Unlike the street vendors who had to jostle each other to purchase the vegetables, fruits, fish, and chickens arriving on boats at every beach and quay, men and women at the publicly administered grains market bent to specific institutional rules enforced by a small bureaucracy at a single location. Unlike grocery stores, the grains market centered on just four staples: rice, beans, corn, and, especially, manioc meal. Various kinds of people rubbed shoulders here and, by crossing paths...

    • CHAPTER 6 THE CATTLE AND MEAT TRADE
      CHAPTER 6 THE CATTLE AND MEAT TRADE (pp. 107-120)

      Beef was the major source of animal protein for residents of Salvador. Not that they shunned pork, fish, whale meat, chicken, or eggs, but they hoped to eat red meat daily. The city consumed 350 to 600 head of cattle per week in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries.¹ Although this number is moderate on a per capita basis, the symbolic importance of beef in this society must not be underestimated. A dearth of meat stood for danger and insecurity. City authorities took seriously their responsibility to ensure its supply at an affordable price, and the subject occupied a...

    • CHAPTER 7 CONTENTION
      CHAPTER 7 CONTENTION (pp. 121-134)

      The work of supplying meat to Salvador reveals some of the cross-hatched tensions that permeated this society, as well as the way social distinctions could blur and alliances form. By and large, cattle merchants, butchers, and those who transported beef within the city shared a roughly equivalent social position. Some middlemen in the cattle and meat trade were mulattos, summoned along with their white counterparts to enforce its rules and yet, like them, sometimes described as mere creatures of the tanners and hide exporters. In contrast, free black workers at the slaughterhouse were badly paid and perceived as dangerous to...

  10. PART II. Changed Rules:: Reform and Resistance
    • CHAPTER 8 “THE TRUE ENEMY IS HUNGER”: THE SIEGE OF SALVADOR
      CHAPTER 8 “THE TRUE ENEMY IS HUNGER”: THE SIEGE OF SALVADOR (pp. 137-155)

      For more than twelve months in 1822–1823, those struggling to free Brazil from Portuguese control laid siege to Salvador, where a Portuguese army was ensconced. The effort to cut off Salvador’s supply of food finally succeeded, and the Portuguese army, along with many merchants, set sail for Europe. Before examining the alternatives that local people faced, and the crucial political role they played in the high drama of bringing about this major political transformation, it is important to understand the war’s course. That task hinges on a close examination of the siege itself—never studied in detail before.

      The...

    • CHAPTER 9 A TREMOR IN THE SOCIAL ORDER
      CHAPTER 9 A TREMOR IN THE SOCIAL ORDER (pp. 156-171)

      The independence war in bahia sent shocks along the fault lines of Salvador’s society, causing undeniable upheaval. Had it continued for years, the result might well have been a radically reshaped socail order but it laset long enough for underyling tensions to surface. No one could fail to notice the precarious position of those at the top. Authority no longer remained openly unquestioned, and those with wealth and political power proved unable to fulfill their paternalistic role. Working people took on unprecedented roles. Slaves glimpsed possible freedom, and certainly gained leverage. The war ended before the old ways collapsed, but...

    • CHAPTER 10 MEAT, MANIOC, AND ADAM SMITH
      CHAPTER 10 MEAT, MANIOC, AND ADAM SMITH (pp. 172-190)

      Beyond the day-to-day behavior of those engaged in the food trade, and beyond the devastating and speciic impact on them of a many-months-long war, there are questions about the government’s role in regulating the economy, about ideology, and about notions of justice and equity that directly affected those traders and the wider consuming public. As merchants and political leaders argued about rules for supplying essential provisions, their debates, both before and after the war, exposed differing views on the nature of a good society, on ethical behavior, and on the appropriate role of government. Having begun this book by concentrating...

    • CHAPTER 11 “THE PEOPLE DO NOT LIVE BY THEORIES”
      CHAPTER 11 “THE PEOPLE DO NOT LIVE BY THEORIES” (pp. 191-208)

      Putting economic liberalism into practice after independence proved more difficult than the theoreticians could have imagined. As Salvador authorities dealt with the trade in foodstuffs from the 1820s to the 1860s, they veered back and forth from laissez faire policies to those on behalf of protecting consumers, changing direction more than once. Food traders and reformers argued that unfettered individual initiative would lead to competition, abundance, and lower prices, while many Salvadoreans saw the removal of price controls on food and the end of restrictions on traders as opening the way for profiteering by a few and hunger for the...

  11. CONCLUSION
    CONCLUSION (pp. 209-212)

    It’s easy to say salvador’s was a society of orders, but what does that mean in terms of people’s experience? What are the exceptions—in this case multitudinous—that stretch and bend the categories that are meant to contain them? Wealth and inherited status certainly played a large role in building an invisible tracery to keep people in place. Yet the vertical ordering of society was confounded by interpersonal contacts, status reversals, physical movement, and individual social mobility. This was true even metaphorically in regard to the city’s physical arrangement. True, the upper city of government offices, baroque churches, and...

  12. APPENDIX A. PURCHASING POWER OVER TIME IN SALVADOR
    APPENDIX A. PURCHASING POWER OVER TIME IN SALVADOR (pp. 213-220)
  13. Appendix B. Volume of Foodstuff Handled at the Grains Market, 1785–1849 (in alqueires)
    Appendix B. Volume of Foodstuff Handled at the Grains Market, 1785–1849 (in alqueires) (pp. 221-224)
  14. NOTES
    NOTES (pp. 225-294)
  15. SOURCES
    SOURCES (pp. 295-316)
  16. CREDITS FOR MAPS AND ILLUSTRATIONS
    CREDITS FOR MAPS AND ILLUSTRATIONS (pp. 317-318)
  17. INDEX
    INDEX (pp. 319-334)
University of Texas Press logo