History and Silence
History and Silence
Charles W. Hedrick
Copyright Date: 2000
Published by: University of Texas Press
https://doi.org/10.7560/731219
https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7560/731219
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
History and Silence
Book Description:

"It is so rare and refreshing to read a Roman history book which recognizes and celebrates the sheer difficulty of writing history, and the vulnerability of each solution." -Times Literary Supplement "This is one of the most interesting and original books about the Later Roman Empire that I have ever read." -T. D. Barnes, Professor of Classics, University of Toronto

The ruling elite in ancient Rome sought to eradicate even the memory of their deceased opponents through a process now known as damnatio memoriae. These formal and traditional practices included removing the person's name and image from public monuments and inscriptions, making it illegal to speak of him, and forbidding funeral observances and mourning. Paradoxically, however, while these practices dishonored the person's memory, they did not destroy it. Indeed, a later turn of events could restore the offender not only to public favor but also to re-inclusion in the public record.

This book examines the process of purge and rehabilitation of memory in the person of Virius Nicomachus Flavianus(?-394). Charles Hedrick describes how Flavian was condemned for participating in the rebellion against the Christian emperor Theodosius the Great-and then restored to the public record a generation later as members of the newly Christianized senatorial class sought to reconcile their pagan past and Christian present. By selectively remembering and forgetting the actions of Flavian, Hedrick asserts, the Roman elite honored their ancestors while participating in profound social, cultural, and religious change.

eISBN: 978-0-292-79915-8
Subjects: History
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. vii-viii)
  3. LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
    LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS (pp. ix-x)
  4. PREFACE
    PREFACE (pp. xi-xxiv)
  5. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
    ACKNOWLEDGMENTS (pp. xxv-xxvii)
  6. CHAPTER 1 A PALIMPSEST
    CHAPTER 1 A PALIMPSEST (pp. 1-5)

    In a.d. 431 a statue was erected in the Forum of Trajan in honor of an eminent Roman of the past, Virius Nicomachus Flavianus. The base of the statue has survived: it is about a meter and a half tall and three-quarters of a meter wide, and although the back of the base has been cut away, more than half a meter of its depth is preserved. An inscription is carved on the front of the base, recessed within a frame. (For the history of the inscription, with detailed description and comments on the text, known as CIL 6.1783, see...

  7. CHAPTER 2 CURSUS AND CAREER
    CHAPTER 2 CURSUS AND CAREER (pp. 6-36)

    The inscription of rehabilitation begins, as almost all Roman honorific inscriptions do, with a formulaic prescript which provides a dedicatory statement, reasons for the dedication, and an account of the career of the person honored, in Latin a cursus honorum. In this chapter I will use the word cursus (pl. cursus) to describe such a specific, selective account. I will use the English word “career” to refer to the general sum of honors and offices actually held, so far as they can be known. The cursus is a selective statement in a particular historical context. The “career” is compiled by...

  8. CHAPTER 3 UNSPEAKABLE PAGANISM?
    CHAPTER 3 UNSPEAKABLE PAGANISM? (pp. 37-88)

    Modern scholars know Flavian best for his religious activities. If the generalist knows of him at all, it is as the intransigent (or reactionary) champion of Roman paganism against the new religion of the empire, Christianity. From De Rossi’s initial publication on, it has always been remarked that there is no apparent reference to paganism in the rehabilitation. There is no mention of his pagan priesthood in the cursus at the head of the inscription, nor can any allusion to paganism be deciphered in the text of the imperial letter. Certainly there is some “religious” vocabulary. The letter speaks of...

  9. CHAPTER 4 REMEMBERING TO FORGET The Damnatio Memoriae
    CHAPTER 4 REMEMBERING TO FORGET The Damnatio Memoriae (pp. 89-130)

    The inscription does not speak of certain of the positions held by Flavian and his son, nor does it allude to Flavian’s religious attitudes. What these omissions mean, or if they mean anything, must be a matter for discussion: there are silences in any text, and the significance of what is not said is always a matter for interpretation, or rather the essential precondition of interpretation. As suggestive as these specific silences may be, they are only manifestations of a more general and far-reaching problem, one that is central to any understanding of the inscription.

    Arguably, the crucial fact about...

  10. CHAPTER 5 SILENCE, TRUTH, AND DEATH The Commemorative Function of History
    CHAPTER 5 SILENCE, TRUTH, AND DEATH The Commemorative Function of History (pp. 131-170)

    The first line of the imperial letter rehabilitating Flavian is remarkable in a variety of ways. It appears to invoke the authority of the Roman tradition of historiography and biography. It also alludes to the commemorative function of writing, which the rehabilitation has in common with the writing of history. The avowed purpose of the rehabilitation is to speak, to give voice to something that is kept in the silence of memory and thus bring it to appearance. Likewise, one of the chief and traditional functions of history is to give voice to that which has been but which has...

  11. CHAPTER 6 REHABILITATING THE TEXT Proofreading and the Past
    CHAPTER 6 REHABILITATING THE TEXT Proofreading and the Past (pp. 171-213)

    A metaphor running through the imperial letter suggests an equivalence between the rehabilitation of Flavian and the correction (emendatio) of texts. Most immediately the metaphor alludes to the comparability of a political rehabilitation and the practice of history, but there is more to the allusion. The elder Flavian himself wrote a history—the imperial letter mentions his Annales—and his two descendants who are involved in the rehabilitation, Flavian the younger and Dexter, are known to have corrected manuscripts of portions of Livy’s history. This correction of manuscripts is an activity they shared with other members of the elite, and...

  12. CHAPTER 7 SILENCE AND AUTHORITY Politics and Rehabilitation
    CHAPTER 7 SILENCE AND AUTHORITY Politics and Rehabilitation (pp. 214-246)

    Many of the problems addressed in this book are traditional, if controversial. The activities of the Roman senatorial class have long been regarded as having played an important part in the transition from the later Roman world to the medieval period, the shift from paganism to Christianity. The production of literature, the writing of history (Chapter 5), and even the routine correction of texts, or emendatio (Chapter 6), in this period all contributed to the preservation of what was, from a Christian perspective, the pagan Roman tradition and the reconciliation of a Christian consciousness with that heritage (Chapters 3–5)....

  13. APPENDIX Concerning the Text of CIL 6.1783
    APPENDIX Concerning the Text of CIL 6.1783 (pp. 247-258)
  14. NOTES
    NOTES (pp. 259-296)
  15. LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
    LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS (pp. 297-300)
  16. SECONDARY WORKS CITED
    SECONDARY WORKS CITED (pp. 301-320)
  17. GENERAL INDEX
    GENERAL INDEX (pp. 321-330)
  18. INDEX LOCORUM
    INDEX LOCORUM (pp. 331-338)
University of Texas Press logo