Having Epilepsy
Having Epilepsy: The Experience and Control of Illness
Joseph W. Schneider
Peter Conrad
Copyright Date: 1983
Published by: Temple University Press
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt14bt765
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Having Epilepsy
Book Description:

"Well written and fascinating to read. This fine book takes a large step in...contributing to the only slowly dawning awareness of the general public, and the health workers too, of the significance of chronic illness." --Anselm Strauss, University of California, San Francisco Based on in-depth interviews with eighty people who have epilepsy, this book gives a first-hand account of what it is like to cope with a chronic illness, while working, playing, and building relationships. The authors recount how people discover they have epilepsy and what it means; how families respond to someone labeled "epileptic"; how seizures affect a person's sense of self and self-control. Epilepsy patients explain what they want from their doctors and why the medication practices they develop may not coincide with "doctor's orders." The variety of experiences of epilepsy is suggested both by the interviews and by the range of terms for seizures--Petit Mal, Grand Mal, auras, fits, absences. The principal difficulty for many people with epilepsy is not the medical condition but the social stigma. A person with epilepsy has to cope with discrimination in obtaining a job, insurance, or a driver's license, and he or she may be cautious about revealing this "disabling" condition to an employer or even a spouse. People with epilepsy may manage information about themselves and their "lapses" and look for "safe places" like restrooms where they can be alone should a seizure begin. Many of those interviewed complained of overreactions to seizures by colleagues or bystanders: epilepsy patients were embarrassed at having provoked a public crisis or were annoyed at waking up in a hospital emergency room. This is a book for people who have epilepsy, for their families and friends; for health care professionals who deal with chronic illnesses; and for students of medical sociology and the sociology of deviance. "For anyone who would like to 'get inside' the experience of having epilepsy, this book is probably as close as one can come." --Epilepsia "In dispelling the notion that 'the person is the illness,' these interviews with 80 individuals reveal that those suffering from epilepsy have learned to accept it as merely another facet of their lives. A valuable contribution for those with epilepsy, for their family and friends, for medical personnel, and for the general public." --Booklist "...carefully outlined and clearly written.... Those affected by chronic conditions may find the book most helpful.... Family and helping professionals may discover new insights.... Social scientists, especially those interested in chronic illnesses, will benefit from the research conclusions and suggestions for further research." --Medical Anthropology Quarterly "It represents an important advance in the medical sociology literature as well as a contribution to qualitative sociology. I think that the book should become a contemporary classic in medical sociology." --Qualitative Sociology "...an important contribution.... In focusing on what it is like to have epilepsy in this society, Schneider and Conrad have reversed an earlier concern for the medicalization of deviance, opting in this work for an understanding of the stigmatization of illness." --Contemporary Sociology

eISBN: 978-1-4399-0099-4
Subjects: Sociology
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. vii-x)
  3. Preface
    Preface (pp. xi-2)
  4. ONE The Sociology of Illness
    ONE The Sociology of Illness (pp. 3-20)

    Illness has been studied primarily as something to be explained, eradicated, and controlled, usually by doctors. Medical culture and personnel aretheauthority on what illness is and what are the important questions to ask about it. One consequence of this has been that distinctions between illness and disease have been blurred. While illness and disease are related, they are not the same. Disease is understood best as an undesirable physiological process or state. Illness, in contrast, has less to do with problems of body per se than with the social and psychological phenomena that accompany these putative physiological problems...

  5. TWO The Historical and Social Realities of Epilepsy
    TWO The Historical and Social Realities of Epilepsy (pp. 21-52)

    Illnesses have historical and social realities that may be studied independently of how people experience them. In fact, to understand the experience of illlness, we need to know more about what diseases and illnesses are as social objects, meaning as things on which people base their thought and action. What a disease or illness is in this social sense is not determined by any biophysiological process, nor is it obvious. The definition, meaning, treatment of, and response to an illness vary by social, cultural and historical context. The social reality affects how people experience illness as well as how others...

  6. THREE Discovery
    THREE Discovery (pp. 53-76)

    In one sense, the story of what it is like to have epilepsy, or cancer, or diabetes, or any other illness begins with medical diagnosis. People come under scrutiny of a physician and are told that they “have” this or that disease or disorder. But medical diagnosis is not usually the origin of illness experience and sometimes does not come at the beginning of people’s involvemlent with doctors. Our own experiences with illness tell us that often long before going to the doctor, we “know something is wrong.” We ache, “feel bad,” are unable to do things we usually do,...

  7. FOUR The Other Side of Care: Parents and Family Life
    FOUR The Other Side of Care: Parents and Family Life (pp. 77-102)

    One place outside the hospital where illness has been studied is in the family. Over the past two decades, social scientists and others have turned their attention more and more to illness and the family (Davis, 1963; Litman, 1974; Voysey, 1975; Burton, 1975; Featherstone, 1980; Locker, 1981; Speedling, 1982). With few exceptions, however, this research has asked various forms of the following question: What is the impact of illness on the family? This subsumes a number of more specific questions, such as: How do parents manage their child’s illness? What does a child’s illness do to relationships between spouses and...

  8. FIVE Seizures and Self
    FIVE Seizures and Self (pp. 103-124)

    Illness is a humbling experience, a great leveler. It reminds us that despite social position and personal accomplishment, talent or charm, we rely on the trouble-free operation of our bodies as a taken-for-granted medium through which we create and express our selves.

    Although we continue to learn new things about the connections between body and mind, the operation of our bodies is defined in general to be quite beyond our willful control. Hearts continue or fail to continue pumping blood, neurons transmit electrochemical impulses, tissues grow, develop, and die quite independent of our intentions.* This becomes only too apparent to...

  9. SIX Controlling Seizures, Protecting Face
    SIX Controlling Seizures, Protecting Face (pp. 125-146)

    Seizures, like illness more generally, are things to be minimized, controlled, and if possible, eliminated altogether. They are fraught with negative potentially discrediting meanings about the self. When others witness their seizures, people feel embarrassed, humiliated, and anxious about others’ subsequent treatment and definitions of them. As a result, those who have had public seizures try hard to minimize their impact.

    People who have seizures must contend with an unknown yet constant degree of uncertainty in their lives. This uncertainty most respondents incorporated into the planning and pursuit of their daily activities. They could never be sure that a seizure...

  10. SEVEN The Problem of Stigma: Managing Information
    SEVEN The Problem of Stigma: Managing Information (pp. 147-164)

    Illness describes a moral condition. To be sick or to have a disorder is to go through something unfortunate, “bad,” or undesirable. But the metaphor of illness (cf. Sontag, 1978) further conveys irregularity, victimization, pity, and even revulsion. This moral component of illness is most apparent in the chronic conditions in which distinctions between disease or disorder and self become blurred. A passing cold, flu, or even a more serious acute condition or malfunction do not have the implications for self or identity that chronic conditions do.

    Epilepsy, of course, is just such a disorder. As such, it describes an...

  11. EIGHT Ties That Bind and Free: The Paradox of Medical Care
    EIGHT Ties That Bind and Free: The Paradox of Medical Care (pp. 165-180)

    Doctors help people who have an illness maintain conventional lives. People with epilepsy rely on doctors to make proper diagnoses, provide information, give support and direction in managing epilepsy, and to prescribe and monitor medications that help control seizures. Theyneedphysicians to help them control epilepsy. At the same time, our respondents had distinctly mixed feelings about their relationships with doctors. Some respondents characterized their doctors as “conscientious,” “gentle and caring,” “supportive,” and said they were “satisfied” and “treated well.” Others complained about doctors who “didn’t care,” or who were “brusque,” “always in a hurry,” and “very little help.”...

  12. NINE The Meaning of Medications
    NINE The Meaning of Medications (pp. 181-204)

    Drugs have become the technique of choice in much modern medical practice. Moreover, patients themselvesexpectto be given one or another kind of medication as part of effective medical treatment. Studies of placebo effects demonstrate that having these expectations met, even by chemically inert pills, can contribute to a patient’s sense of well-being and reduced symptoms. The existence, prescription, and use of medications, then, constitute an integral part of the typical relationships between doctors and patients.

    Medication is a particularly important element in the treatment and experience of chronic illnesses such as diabetes, heart disease, and, of course, epilepsy....

  13. TEN Having Epilepsy: The Experience and Control of Illness
    TEN Having Epilepsy: The Experience and Control of Illness (pp. 205-232)

    We cannot understand illness experience by studying disease alone, for disease refers merely to undesirable changes in the body. Illness, however, is primarily about social meanings, experiences, relationships, and conduct that exist around putative disease. People may have diseases without being ill, and vice versa.* Physicians and medical science are the official managers of disease (on balance, for our own good fortune). We have tried to examine having epilepsy as a social experience and process that occurs, for the most part, outside the scrutiny of professional medicine. This nonprofessional/ noninstitutional context is particularly important to people living with chronic illnesses,...

  14. Appendix
    Appendix (pp. 233-252)
  15. References
    References (pp. 253-268)
  16. Index
    Index (pp. 269-280)
  17. Back Matter
    Back Matter (pp. 281-281)