Job Queues, Gender Queues
Job Queues, Gender Queues: Explaining Women's Inroads into Male Occupations
Barbara F. Reskin
Patricia A. Roos
Katharine M. Donato
Polly A. Phipps
Barbara J. Thomas
Chloe E. Bird
Linda A. Detman
Thomas Steiger
Series: Women in the Political Economy
Copyright Date: 1990
Published by: Temple University Press
Pages: 400
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt14btcj8
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Job Queues, Gender Queues
Book Description:

Since 1970, women have made widely publicized gains in several customarily male occupations. Many commentators have understood this apparent integration as an important step to sexual equality in the workplace. Barbara F. Reskin and Patricia A. Roos read a different lesson in the changing gender composition of occupations that were traditionally reserved for men. With persuasive evidence,Job Queues, Gender Queuesoffers a controversial interpretation of women's dramatic inroads into several male occupations based on case studies of "feminizing" male occupation.

The authors propose and develop a queuing theory of occupations' sex composition. This theory contends that the labor market comprises a "gender queue" with employers preferring male to female workers for most jobs. Workers also rank jobs into a "job queue." As a result, the highest-ranked workers monopolize the most desirable jobs. Reskin and Roos use this queuing perspective to explain why several male occupations opened their doors to women after 1970. The second part of the book provides evidence for this queuing analysis by presenting case studies of the feminization of specific occupations. These include book editor, pharmacist, public relations specialist, bank manager, systems analyst, insurance adjuster, insurance salesperson, real estate salesperson, bartender, baker, and typesetter/compositor.In the seriesWomen in the Political Economy, edited by Ronnie J. Steinberg.

eISBN: 978-1-4399-0159-5
Subjects: Sociology
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. vii-viii)
  3. Preface
    Preface (pp. ix-xii)
    Barbara F. Reskin and Patricia A. Roos
  4. Part I Explaining the Changing Sex Composition of Occupations
    • 1 Occupational Sex Segregation: Persistence and Change
      1 Occupational Sex Segregation: Persistence and Change (pp. 3-28)

      Early in the 1980s the media took notice of a new phenomenon: women’s marked progress into occupations traditionally reserved for men. Commenting on newly published data from the Department of Labor and the Bureau of the Census, media accounts such as Frank Prial’s were quick to portray women’s gains in “men’s” occupations as dramatic:

      An increasing number of women in the United States are working at what used to be men’s jobs. Despite the unemployment rate, the number of women working [for wages] in the United States has risen 21 million, or 95 percent, over the last two decades, according...

    • 2 Queueing and Changing Occupational Composition
      2 Queueing and Changing Occupational Composition (pp. 29-68)

      What led to the feminization of the customarily male occupations our research team studied? In answering that question, this chapter develops a theoretical model of occupational feminization. We begin our task by outlining a model of occupational composition that accounts for the uneven distribution of groups across occupations and hence, specifically, how occupations’ sex compositions change. The most fruitful model sees occupational composition as the result of adual-queueingprocess:labor queuesorder groups of workers in terms of their attractiveness to employers, andjob queuesrank jobs in terms of their attractiveness to workers.¹ Identifying how and why employers...

    • 3 Consequences of Desegregation: Occupational Integration and Economic Equity?
      3 Consequences of Desegregation: Occupational Integration and Economic Equity? (pp. 69-90)

      To what extent has desegregation yielded occupational and economic opportunities for women? This chapter focuses on the two parts of that question. First, did women benefit occupationally from moving into the desegregating occupations we studied? In other words, did occupational-level desegregation translate into sex integration at the level of jobs, or did sex segregation persist within these nominally desegregated occupations?¹ Second, did occupational-level desegregation reduce the earnings gap between men and women within these occupations? Obviously, the answer to the second question depends on the first: if women experienced genuine occupational integration, their progress toward economic equity would be greatly...

  5. Part II Case Studies of Occupational Change
    • 4 Culture, Commerce, and Gender: The Feminization of Book Editing
      4 Culture, Commerce, and Gender: The Feminization of Book Editing (pp. 93-110)
      Barbara F. Reskin

      For centuries book editing was a “gentlemen’s profession” (Tebbel, 1972: 207), yet in the 1970s women made such large gains in the occupation that some have speculated that editing is becoming a women’s ghetto (Geracimos, 1974:25). How can we explain women’s gains? This chapter examines the changes in the publishing industry and the editorial role that have led to women’s increasing representation among editors.

      Culture and commerce, art and business—these disparate concerns shaped the book publishing industry (Coser et al., 1982). Its origins in medieval monasteries and universities (Dessauer, 1974:2) bestowed on publishing a special status. As literature and...

    • 5 Industrial and Occupational Change in Pharmacy: Prescription for Feminization
      5 Industrial and Occupational Change in Pharmacy: Prescription for Feminization (pp. 111-128)
      Polly A. Phipps

      Women’s representation in pharmacy has increased dramatically over the past few decades. In 1950 and 1960 women accounted for approximately 8 percent of all pharmacists (see Table 5.1). Between 1970 and 1980 their representation rose from 12 to 24 percent. Overall, the occupation itself grew 31 percent, from about 1l0,000 pharmacists in 1970 to more than 143,000 in 1980. This represented a net growth of some 21,000 women pharmacists compared with men’s increase of more than 12,000. Thus, by 1980 there were about 34,000 women and 109,000 men practicing pharmacy. By 1988, women constituted 32 percent of all pharmacists (U.S....

    • 6 Keepers of the Corporate Image: Women in Public Relations
      6 Keepers of the Corporate Image: Women in Public Relations (pp. 129-144)
      Katharine M. Donato

      The tasks of public relations specialists are many. To manage public opinion, practitioners may write newsletters and speeches, lobby for organizational interests, collect news items about corporations, organize media and fund-raising events, and inform the public about corporate activities. Interestingly, many women have become the visible actors who convey their employers’ image. For example, when theChallengerspace shuttle disaster occurred in 1986, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) turned to a woman to handle the subsequent media pandemonium. The Long Island Lighting Company hired a woman as its major spokesperson to respond to politicians, activists, and residents who...

    • 7 High Finance, Small Change: Women’s Increased Representation In Bank Management
      7 High Finance, Small Change: Women’s Increased Representation In Bank Management (pp. 145-166)
      Chloe E. Bird

      Women have worked in banking since early in the century, but their numbers did not become large until the 1940s, when banking began relying on women to fill clerical positions (Shulsky, 1951). By 1970 women constituted two-thirds of the workforce in banking, but most of them held clerical positions: for example, 86 percent of the tellers were women (Strober and Arnold, 1987a). The few women managers were concentrated in retail banking, which emphasized consumer relations; male managers dominated higher-status positions as officers and executives. In the 1970s, an increase of 738, 107 nearly doubled the number of women working in...

    • 8 Programming for Change? The Growing Demand for Women Systems Analysts
      8 Programming for Change? The Growing Demand for Women Systems Analysts (pp. 167-182)
      Katharine M. Donato

      Since 1960 the use of computers has increased tremendously, and computer occupations have grown apace. Because of advances in computer technology, the expanding use of electronic data-processing systems, and the proliferation of computer centers that serve individual clients (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1970, 1974b, 1984b), the number of systems analysts increased by 88 percent between 1970 and 1980 (U.S. Bureau of the Census, 1984a). Operations and systems researchers and analysts increased by a more modest 24 percent.

      Because computer occupations do not have a legacy of sex segregation and because they are experiencing rapid growth, one might expect women...

    • 9 Women’s Gains in Insurance Sales: Increased Supply, Uncertain Demand
      9 Women’s Gains in Insurance Sales: Increased Supply, Uncertain Demand (pp. 183-204)
      Barbara J. Thomas

      Throughout this century women’s representation among insurance agents and brokers has varied with the socioeconomic conditions of the nation. Between 1910 and 1930, when women were struggling for suffrage and economic opportunity, the proportion of women selling life insurance increased more than fivefold (see Table 9.1). Indeed, before 1920 an insurance executive recruited high school girls to insurance sales, assuring them that it offered the “surest as well as the most convenient means of providing for an old age” (Kessler-Harris, 1982:227). However, the Depression of the 1930s reduced women’s opportunities, and the proportion of women in the occupation increased only...

    • 10 A Woman’s Place Is Selling Homes: Occupational Change and the Feminization of Real Estate Sales
      10 A Woman’s Place Is Selling Homes: Occupational Change and the Feminization of Real Estate Sales (pp. 205-224)
      Barbara J. Thomas and Barbara F. Reskin

      Between 1960 and 1980 the real estate industry experienced nearly continuous growth. As Table 10.1 shows, the number of jobs increased steadily after 1960 until employment peaked in 1980 with 1,384,000 jobs. In the recession years of 1981 and 1982, the industry lost jobs (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1984a).

      A similar pattern of growth occurred among real estate sales occupations, those of real estate salespersons and brokers, appraisers, sales superintendents, building consultants, and leasing agents (U. S. Department of Commerce, Office of Federal Statistical Policy and Standards, 1980). Between 1972 and 1979 the employment of real estate salespersons and...

    • 11 Occupational Resegregation among Insurance Adjusters and Examiners
      11 Occupational Resegregation among Insurance Adjusters and Examiners (pp. 225-240)
      Polly A. Phipps

      Women’s participation in the insurance industry increased during the 1970s. However, women’s headway in such male-dominated specialties as under-writing and sales was far outstripped by their gains in the historically male-dominated clerical occupation of adjusters, examiners, and investigators. When the census first classified adjusters, examiners, and investigators as a detailed occupational category in 1960, 6,845 women made up 12 percent of the more than 55,000 occupational incumbents (see Table 11.1). By 1970 the occupation had added some 40,000 new jobs, almost half of which were filled by women. As a result, the number of women quadrupled, and they constituted almost...

    • 12 Women behind Bars: The Feminization of Bartending
      12 Women behind Bars: The Feminization of Bartending (pp. 241-256)
      Linda A. Detman

      Historically, men have dominated bartending. Ethnographic accounts from as recently as 1975 characterized bartenders as authoritarian, tough, strong, and male. Bartenders were thought to “represent a stronghold of masculinity and authority” (Spradley and Mann, 1975:71). Novels and motion pictures have long depicted bars as dark, smoky rooms that are loud and dangerous, sometimes fronts for drug dealing, prostitution, and other illicit activities. “Bars in America are not as much deviant settings as they are places of potential deviant activity” (Cavan, 1966:37)—in short, not the kind of place a “self-respecting lady” would seek employment. Nonetheless, women have long worked in...

    • 13 Baking and Baking Off: Deskilling and the Changing Sex Makeup of Bakers
      13 Baking and Baking Off: Deskilling and the Changing Sex Makeup of Bakers (pp. 257-274)
      Thomas Steiger and Barbara F. Reskin

      Picture a baker. Do you see the nursery-rhyme baker—a portly man in a chef’s hat, crowded in a tub with his cronies the butcher and the candlestick maker—or the media cliché of the apron-clad wife and mother, pulling home-baked cookies and bread from the oven? When by “baker” we mean people whoearntheir bread by baking it, Mother Goose is closer to the mark than Madison Avenue. Over the centuries in which baking has been an occupation, men have dominated it (Laslett, 1965). Indeed, as in most guild-organized crafts, women were often formally barred (Thrupp, 1933; Clark,...

    • 14 Hot-Metal to Electronic Composition: Gender, Technology, and Social Change
      14 Hot-Metal to Electronic Composition: Gender, Technology, and Social Change (pp. 275-298)
      Patricia A. Roos

      Printers were once the quintessential craft workers, the aristocracy of the blue-collar workforce, according to Lipset et at. (1956). They were better educated than the average production worker, and the International Typographical Union (ITV) assured them high income, job autonomy, and occupational community. These printers were also invariably men. Women were singularly unsuccessful in integrating the hot-metal composing room, where the operators typeset and composed the final printed layout, or the apprenticeship programs leading to these well-paid jobs.

      Since 1970, however, the print production process and its workforce have changed dramatically. Extraordinary technological advances revolutionized typesetting, and as a consequence...

  6. Part III Conclusion
    • 15 Summary, Implications, and Prospects
      15 Summary, Implications, and Prospects (pp. 301-322)

      Although researchers disagree over the causes of sex segregation in the workplace, they agree on its pervasiveness and persistence. Between 1900 and 1970 the extent of occupational-level sex segregation fluctuated only slightly (Gross, 1968; Jacobs, 1989b). Of course, aggregate-level stability in the extent of segregation can conceal infrequent shifts in the sex makeup of particular occupations, but as Chapter 1 showed, such changes have been rare. Indeed, it was the historical stability in occupations’ sex composition that drew our attention to women’s marked inroads during the 1970s into such diverse male occupations as pharmacist, typesetter, and bus driver.

      The statistical...

  7. Appendix: Guidelines Used for Occupational Case Studies
    Appendix: Guidelines Used for Occupational Case Studies (pp. 325-330)
  8. References
    References (pp. 331-370)
  9. Name Index
    Name Index (pp. 371-373)
  10. Subject Index
    Subject Index (pp. 374-386)
  11. About the Authors
    About the Authors (pp. 387-388)
  12. Back Matter
    Back Matter (pp. 389-389)