Irish nationalism and European integration
Irish nationalism and European integration: The official redefinition of the island of Ireland
KATY HAYWARD
Copyright Date: 2009
Published by: Manchester University Press
Pages: 320
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt155jgph
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Irish nationalism and European integration
Book Description:

How has it been possible for Irish political leaders to actively promote two of the largest challenges to Irish nation-statehood: the concession of sovereignty to the European Union and the retraction of the constitutional claim over Northern Ireland? The author of this book argues that such discourses are integrally connected and, what is more, embody the enduring relevance of nationalism in modern Ireland. As the most comprehensive study to date of official discourse in twentieth-century Ireland, this book traces the ways in which nationalism can be simultaneously redefined and revitalised through European integration. The text begins with an overview of the origins and development of Irish official nationalism. It then analyses the redefinition of this nationalism in meeting the challenges to Irish nation-statehood posed by the conflict in Northern Ireland and membership of the EU. New interpretations of the symbolic and practical importance of the island of Ireland have been central to this process. Indeed, the genius of the Irish was to employ innovative EU-inspired concepts in finding agreement with and within Northern Ireland on the one hand whilst, on the other, legitimising further European integration through the notion that it furthers traditional nationalist ideals such as Irish unity. Thus, Irish political leaders were remarkably successful in not only accommodating potent nationalist and pro-European discourses but in making them appear complementary. An over-reliance on this discourse, however, plus a critical failure to adjust it to the conditions it helped to fashion, contributed to the failure of the ‘Yes’ campaigns in the Irish referendums on the EU Treaties of Nice and Lisbon. The book concludes with an assessment of the reasons for these results and argues that the symbiotic relationship between Irish nationalism and European integration can be redeemed for a new era in EU–member-state relations. This book will appeal to any reader with an interest in the changing dynamics of Ireland’s relationship with the European Union and with Northern Ireland, as well as scholars of discourses on identity, territory and governance in Europe.

eISBN: 978-1-84779-306-5
Subjects: Political Science
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. vii-viii)
  3. List of figures and tables
    List of figures and tables (pp. ix-x)
  4. Preface
    Preface (pp. xi-xi)
  5. Acknowledgements
    Acknowledgements (pp. xii-xii)
  6. Biographical notes
    Biographical notes (pp. xiii-xxiv)
  7. Intergovernmental agreements on Northern Ireland, 1973–2002
    Intergovernmental agreements on Northern Ireland, 1973–2002 (pp. xxv-xxvi)
  8. List of abbreviations
    List of abbreviations (pp. xxvii-xxviii)
  9. 1 Introduction
    1 Introduction (pp. 1-17)

    The ‘Birth of a New Ireland’ was announced just in time for the new millennium, on 2 December 1999, by theIrish Times. The spur for this declaration was the signing of commencement orders in Dublin, giving effect to the 1998 multi-party and 1999 British–Irish Agreements and devolving power to the new north–south and British–Irish bodies. That same day in Belfast, the Northern Ireland Executive met for the first time, whilst President Mary McAleese lunched with the Queen in London and made promises to return the favour soon. But it was the formal amendment by Taoiseach Bertie...

  10. 2 Nation-state and European Union
    2 Nation-state and European Union (pp. 18-41)

    The purpose of this chapter is to elaborate in detail the theoretical basis for the application of the triform model – identity, borders and governance – to the nation-state and the European Union. Theories of nationalism and European integration are examined in three sections. The first section sets out a constructivist/modernist conception of official nationalism and nation-statehood, which traditionally frames a political system in a triform model of ‘nation’, ‘territory’ and ‘state’. Section two considers the significance of national governmental elites and their official discourse in the process of European integration. It also shows how the identity, borders and governance...

  11. 3 Official discourse and political change in Ireland
    3 Official discourse and political change in Ireland (pp. 42-63)

    The purpose of this chapter is to elaborate the theoretical and methodological framework for this research, both in relation to the key tenets of discourse theory and to the empirical content of the analysis. It begins by considering the meaning of ‘discourse’ as language, practice and context. Its multidimensional meaning and function means that discourse analysis has particular value in the study of nationalism and political change. The articulation of discourse in texts, written or spoken, offers a means by which the processes at work in a particular context can be analysed. Given the model of the observer/object relationship that...

  12. 4 The origins of official Irish nationalism
    4 The origins of official Irish nationalism (pp. 64-91)

    The establishment of an independent Irish state was severely complicated by the fact that there was notanIrish nationalism seekinganIrish nation-state as such but rather a range of nationalisms competing for political space and influence in Ireland. The three core versions of nationalism – unionist, constitutional and republican – fostered different conceptions of the meaning and implications of Ireland’s identity, borders and governance and consequently occupied conflicting positions regarding the ideal notion of Irish nation-statehood. In relation to their opposing views on Britain’s role in Ireland, these competing nationalisms also fostered different opinions regarding the relevance of...

  13. 5 Building the Irish nation-state, 1922–72
    5 Building the Irish nation-state, 1922–72 (pp. 92-115)

    The initial focus of official nationalism in the Irish Free State was on the activity ofnation-building. ‘Nation-building’ refers here to the process by which the governmental elite seek to construct a sense of popular affinity and collective identification with the state as the representation of the identity of the historical and cultural nation. The core purpose of this process was to unite the nation behind the new state. This necessarily involved the establishment of common ground between the republican and constitutional nationalisms that competed for political space long before and after 1922. Consequently, the Irish official nationalism that developed...

  14. 6 Identity, nation and community
    6 Identity, nation and community (pp. 116-151)

    This chapter examines the conceptualisation of identity in Irish official discourse in relation to the definition of the Irish ‘nation’ and the European ‘community’. As discussed in the first part of this book, ‘nation’ and ‘community’ constitute the broad conceptual frameworks for identity in nation-statehood and European Union respectively. These frameworks are legitimated and strengthened through the use of narratives, including story-lines regarding significant historical events and normative judgements as to their contemporary relevance. The traditional narrative of the nation is of a singular culture preserved and respected throughout the ages. The new narrative of the European community is of...

  15. 7 Borders, territory and space
    7 Borders, territory and space (pp. 152-188)

    This chapter examines the meaning and significance given to ‘borders’ by official Irish discourse when defining Irish ‘territory’ and European ‘space’.¹ The model of national territory is of a physical, bordered polity made live by the narrative of a common homeland. The framework of European space is also constructed with the aid of an ideal model and narrative in which cross-border co-operation meets shared needs. This chapter explores the way in which the traditional and new frameworks, narratives and models of the territory and European space have been brought together in Irish official discourse since the 1970s. It is structured...

  16. 8 Governance, state and polity
    8 Governance, state and polity (pp. 189-225)

    This chapter examines the conceptualisation of ‘governance’ in Irish official discourse in relation to both the Irish ‘state’ and the European ‘polity’. ‘State’ and ‘polity’ constitute the broad conceptual and institutional supporting frameworks for the meaning and significance of governance in nation-statehood and European Union respectively. The traditional narrative of the state is national self-determination, i.e. quest of the nation to decide and direct its own forms of governance. The new narrative of the European polity is of co-operation between states for mutual prosperity. The traditional model of the state is sovereignty, which brings with it the right and ability...

  17. 9 Conclusion
    9 Conclusion (pp. 226-239)

    The case of Ireland epitomises the enduring power and potential of official nationalism even (perhaps especially) in a context of immense upheaval. Official nationalism both responds to and shapes popular perception; it draws together past, present and future; it affects and it is an effect; it builds support for whatisby asserting whatoughtto be; it is a pillar of continuity and a force for change. Official discourse plays a crucial role in giving voice to this process. The contradictory nature of nationalism is made manifest in the complexity of official discourse. Politicians’ redefinition of key words, their...

  18. Afterword
    Afterword (pp. 240-244)

    The ‘Irish problem’ has long been a euphemism in EU circles for the contested status of Northern Ireland. The term took on a new meaning overnight on 12 June 2008, after which the ‘Irish problem’ debated across Europe was Ireland’s second rejection of an EU treaty (Lisbon) and the consequent stalling of European integration.¹

    The breakdown of results for the referendum on the Treaty of Lisbon (46.6 per cent ‘Yes’ to 53.4 per cent ‘No’) was almost identical to that of the first referendum on the Treaty of Nice in 2001. The difference this time, and a crucial one, was...

  19. References
    References (pp. 245-274)
  20. Index
    Index (pp. 275-284)
Manchester University Press logo