Rendering Nature
Rendering Nature: Animals, Bodies, Places, Politics
Marguerite S. Shaffer
Phoebe S. K. Young
Series: Nature and Culture in America
Copyright Date: 2015
Published by: University of Pennsylvania Press
Pages: 400
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt15zc566
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Rendering Nature
Book Description:

We exist at a moment during which the entangled challenges facing the human and natural worlds confront us at every turn, whether at the most basic level of survival-health, sustenance, shelter-or in relation to our comfort-driven desires. As demand for resources both necessary and unnecessary increases, understanding how nature and culture are interconnected matters more than ever.

Bridging the fields of environmental history and American studies,Rendering Natureexamines the surprising interconnections between nature and culture in distinct places, times, and contexts over the course of American history. Divided into four themes-animals, bodies, places, and politics-the essays span a diverse array of locations and periods: from antebellum slave society to atomic testing sites, from gorillas in Central Africa to river runners in the Grand Canyon, from white sun-tanning enthusiasts to Japanese American incarcerees, from taxidermists at the 1893 World's Fair to tents on Wall Street in 2011. Together they offer new perspectives and conceptual tools that can help us better understand the historical realities and current paradoxes of our environmental predicament.

Contributors:Thomas G. Andrews, Connie Y. Chiang, Catherine Cocks, Annie Gilbert Coleman, Finis Dunaway, John Herron, Andrew Kirk, Frieda Knobloch, Susan A. Miller, Brett Mizelle, Marguerite S. Shaffer, Phoebe S. K. Young

eISBN: 978-0-8122-9145-2
Subjects: History
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. v-vi)
  3. Chapter 1 The Nature-Culture Paradox
    Chapter 1 The Nature-Culture Paradox (pp. 1-18)
    Marguerite S. Shaffer and Phoebe S. K. Young

    In 2000 the Nobel laureate and atmospheric chemist Paul Crutzen coined the term “Anthropocene” to mark the emergence of a new geologic epoch in which humans have become the most “globally potent biogeophysical force” on the planet.¹ As Crutzen and his fellow authors Will Steffen, a climate scientist, and John R. McNeill, an environmental historian, have explained it, “The termAnthropocenesuggests that the Earth has now left its natural geological epoch, the present interglacial state called the Holocene. Human activities have become so pervasive and profound that they rival the great forces of Nature and are pushing the Earth...

  4. PART I. ANIMALS
    • Chapter 2 Beasts of the Southern Wild: Slaveholders, Slaves, and Other Animals in Charles Ball’s Slavery in the United States
      Chapter 2 Beasts of the Southern Wild: Slaveholders, Slaves, and Other Animals in Charles Ball’s Slavery in the United States (pp. 21-47)
      Thomas G. Andrews

      On a Mary land road in 1785, a slave family was torn apart. We might be tempted to tell the story of its sudden dissolution simply as a human drama acted out by a Mary land planter, a “Georgia trader,” an enslaved woman, and her four-year-old son. Even half a century later the boy, who published his life story in 1836 under the pseudonym Charles Ball, winced at how “the terrors of the scene return[ed]” to him “with painful vividness.”¹ Yet Ball could recollect neither the scene nor its terrors without introducing a fifth and more surprising player: a horse.²...

    • Chapter 3 Stuffed: Nature and Science on Display
      Chapter 3 Stuffed: Nature and Science on Display (pp. 48-69)
      John Herron

      If you wish to see the lone survivor of the 1876 Battle of Little Bighorn, visit the Natural History Museum at the University of Kansas. Tucked into a dark corner on the fourth floor is a humidity-controlled glass case containing the stuffed remains of a twenty-nine-year-old decorated veteran from Custer’s Last Stand. Nicknamed “Comanche” because of his bravery in past Indian engagements, he was found two days after the battle by a military recovery and burial team; he was still bleeding from a severe shoulder wound. A steamer rushed him to North Dakota’s Fort Abraham Lincoln, where army surgeons removed...

    • Chapter 4 Digit’s Legacy: Reconsidering the Human-Nature Encounter in a Global World
      Chapter 4 Digit’s Legacy: Reconsidering the Human-Nature Encounter in a Global World (pp. 70-96)
      Marguerite S. Shaffer

      On the evening of February 3, 1978, Walter Cronkite ledCBS Evening Newswith the story of a brutal murder in Africa. A gang of six men in the remote mountains of Rwanda had repeatedly stabbed their victim; the body was found decapitated and with both hands amputated. Despite the violent spectacle of this crime, it was rare, given the larger political and economic issues that had continually plagued Africa in the post-colonial era, for a single murder in tiny Rwanda to make national news in the United States, but this was no ordinary victim. He was a silverback mountain...

  5. PART II. BODIES
    • Chapter 5 The Gulick Family and the Nature of Adolescence
      Chapter 5 The Gulick Family and the Nature of Adolescence (pp. 99-121)
      Susan A. Miller

      Jane Addams set the tone forThe Spirit of Youthin the book’s first sentence with the charming double meaning she invested in “the youth of the earth.” Initially she uses the phrase to build her argument that humans have always yearned for a sense of authenticity; we must have faith that each and every dawn is the harbinger of a world, and a life, that can be made fresh. Humans inherently crave a young earth, she writes, a natural world that is receptive to their ministrations, pliant and impressionable, ready to receive an overlay of the culture we create....

    • Chapter 6 Children of Light: The Nature and Culture of Suntanning
      Chapter 6 Children of Light: The Nature and Culture of Suntanning (pp. 122-137)
      Catherine Cocks

      “Race denotes what manis,” the economist William Z. Ripley declared in 1899, whereas “all these other details of social life”—environment, ethnicity, nationality, and language—“represent what mandoes.”¹ This distinction between what humans are and what they do, which gained influence over the course of the first half of the twentieth century, summarized a major shift in the understanding of human variation. Ripley’s remark underscores the binary thinking that underlay the new understanding: opposing nature to nurture, bodily inheritance to environmental influences, and perhaps most contentiously, race against culture. This final opposition proposed that on the one hand,...

    • Chapter 7 Dr. Spock Is Worried: Visual Media and the Emotional History of American Environmentalism
      Chapter 7 Dr. Spock Is Worried: Visual Media and the Emotional History of American Environmentalism (pp. 138-162)
      Finis Dunaway

      Everything about him seems so serious: his stiff posture, his stern expression, and his three-piece suit, taut necktie, and collar pin (see Figure 7.1). With hands in pockets, his lips tightly pursed, he looks down at the child, who seems completely unaware of his presence. Below the photograph a brief sentence printed in bold letters summarizes the scene: “Dr. Spock is worried.”¹

      Published as a full-page advertisement in theNew York Timesin 1962, reprinted in seven hundred newspapers and numerous magazines, and then appearing as a poster “in store windows, nurseries, doctors’ offices, and even on baby carriages,” the...

  6. PART III. PLACES
    • Chapter 8 Prototyping Natures: Technology, Labor, and Art on Atomic Frontiers
      Chapter 8 Prototyping Natures: Technology, Labor, and Art on Atomic Frontiers (pp. 165-188)
      Andrew Kirk

      The year 2011 marked the sixtieth anniversary of continental nuclear testing. In the year leading up to this milestone interest in the subject surged, journalists rediscovered atomic history, and scholars from a variety of backgrounds took a second look at the science, technology, cultural artifacts, and landscapes of the atomic Cold War.¹ Artists and photographers have long gravitated toward things atomic and the tainted landscapes of testing in particular. Those creative folks who spent their careers working on representations of atomic events and environments found new interest in and audiences for their work during the year of remembrance.² The Fukushima...

    • Chapter 9 River Rats in the Archive: The Colorado River and the Nature of Texts
      Chapter 9 River Rats in the Archive: The Colorado River and the Nature of Texts (pp. 189-217)
      Annie Gilbert Coleman

      A tall, athletic young businessman showed up in Green River, Utah, at dinnertime on July 9, 1940. He was looking for a small group of strangers and the river. Starting in Wyoming, the Green flows through Utah on its way to meet the Colorado River and the Grand Canyon. There the river runs a mile below the Colorado Plateau and drops two thousand feet in less than three hundred miles. The man was joining the second ever commercial river trip through the Grand Canyon and was ready to go. He wrote in his journal that night, “Here I was starting...

    • Chapter 10 Rocks of Ages: The Decadent Desert and Sepulchral Time
      Chapter 10 Rocks of Ages: The Decadent Desert and Sepulchral Time (pp. 218-234)
      Frieda Knobloch

      Some geographical spaces have been visibly, many have said legibly,engraved by time, specifically deserts and canyons of the arid American West. These landscapes, including large areas such as the Mojave, Sonoran, Chihuahuan, and Great Basin Deserts (and smaller dry basins throughout the intermountain West), as well as canyons carved by rivers such as the Colorado and the Green, have always presented acute and life-threatening difficulties to travelers and produced ingenious approaches to habitation among ancient and contemporary indigenous communities. However the concern here is not the ecology or cultural or geological histories of arid landscapes, but something maybe harder...

  7. PART IV. POLITICS
    • Chapter 11 Winning the War at Manzanar: Environmental Patriotism and the Japanese American Incarceration
      Chapter 11 Winning the War at Manzanar: Environmental Patriotism and the Japanese American Incarceration (pp. 237-262)
      Connie Y. Chiang

      World War II has been remembered as a popular conflict that rallied millions of Americans behind the United States’ effort to defeat the Axis powers and defend President Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s “Four Freedoms”: freedom of speech, freedom of worship, freedom from want, and freedom from fear. To win popular support, the federal government, in cooperation with private industry, developed a savvy propaganda campaign of posters, films, and advertisements that encouraged Americans to do their part to win the war. When they opened their newspapers, went to movie theaters, or walked down streets, they were bombarded with these government appeals. Many...

    • Chapter 12 Unthinkable Visibility: Pigs, Pork, and the Spectacle of Killing and Meat
      Chapter 12 Unthinkable Visibility: Pigs, Pork, and the Spectacle of Killing and Meat (pp. 263-286)
      Brett Mizelle

      Back in 2007 I attended the Pork Industry Forum in Anaheim, California. I had told the organizers at the National Pork Board that I was writing a book¹ on the relationship between humans and pigs and wanted to make sure I was getting the industry’s perspective on the major relationship Americans have with pigs: eating them. I attended two days of talks and seminars, a highlight of which was the announcement by Dennis Treacy, the vice president for environmental and corporate affairs at Smithfield Foods, that his company was going to require its producers to phase out the use of...

    • Chapter 13 “Bring Tent”: The Occupy Movement and the Politics of Public Nature
      Chapter 13 “Bring Tent”: The Occupy Movement and the Politics of Public Nature (pp. 287-318)
      Phoebe S. K. Young

      In the initial poster campaign that served as a catalyst for the Occupy Wall Street movement (OWS) in 2011, the central objective remained an open question: What is our one demand? Those drawn to participate shared a sense of outrage with economic inequality and alienation from the political process but generated little initial consensus on a list of specific reforms for which to agitate. The form of protest, however, was precise; instructions indicated a date, a place, and a single instruction: “Bring Tent.” The tactic took off in ways that surprised both organizers and observers. At the height of its...

  8. Notes
    Notes (pp. 319-380)
  9. List of Contributors
    List of Contributors (pp. 381-384)
  10. Index
    Index (pp. 385-404)
  11. Acknowledgments
    Acknowledgments (pp. 405-406)
University of Pennsylvania Press logo