Understanding Marriage
Understanding Marriage: A Hong Kong Case Study
Katherine P. H. Young
Copyright Date: 1995
Published by: Hong Kong University Press
Pages: 224
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt2jc1r9
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Understanding Marriage
Book Description:

Based on a marital study in Hong Kong, this book examines changes that occur in the marital relationship today. The author concludes that as 'affective individualism' is used to characterize modern marriages in the West, 'affective familism' is a more appropriate character of marriages among the Chinese in Hong Kong.

eISBN: 978-988-220-298-6
Subjects: Sociology
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. v-viii)
  3. Preface
    Preface (pp. ix-x)
  4. Acknowledgements
    Acknowledgements (pp. xi-xii)
    Katherine Young
  5. Prologue: Mr and Mrs Lee
    Prologue: Mr and Mrs Lee (pp. 1-4)

    In the short hour that we spent in our first meeting I was made privy to a vast amount of information regarding the Lees’ life and marriage. They described in some detail their respective views on various events and issues, and what each considered to be the other’s caring or noncaring responses. With a great deal of feeling, each repeatedly expressed the wish to make things work, interjected with expressions of anger and disappointment. ‘Why are you doing this to me?’ ‘Why won’t you do this for me?’ ‘Why must you always have things on your terms?’ ‘If you do...

  6. Introduction
    Introduction (pp. 5-10)

    It has long been assumed that Asian marriages enjoy an intrinsic stability not to be found elsewhere and that an enduring quality is to be found in the relationship, based on tradition and family ties. This may once have been true. But to an increasing extent it is an assumption that cannot be supported by the evidence around us. Marital problems and dissolution are on the increase in Hong Kong, and this increase is exponential compared to the situation a generation ago.

    This is not surprising. If it is true that the marital relationship can break down when inexorable external...

  7. PART I: THE HONG KONG MARITAL STUDY
    • Chapter One Studying Marriages in Hong Kong
      Chapter One Studying Marriages in Hong Kong (pp. 13-28)

      In the study and conceptualization of marriage three major approaches have been used to address and analyse the many dimensions of this dyadic relationship.

      The psychodynamic tradition views marriage as a relationship most similar in nature to the early caring experience of the parent child bond. The spouse is expected to be a caring person who meets affectional and dependency needs, offers comfort and reaffirms the partner’s sense of worth. The partners choose each other to complement and supplement themselves as they mutually support each other in the next phase of their development as adults. Marriage creates a safe setting...

    • Chapter Two The Hong Kong Marital Study
      Chapter Two The Hong Kong Marital Study (pp. 29-44)

      The main focus of the Hong Kong Marital Study is to identify and describe patterns of marital transactions in Hong Kong marriages. These patterns are drawn from the accounts provided by the husbands and wives through the use of self report measures and in their responses during interviews. This material has been organized and analysed to reflect the couple’s evaluation of the relationship. The study presents the couple’s own definition of what constitutes a happy mei mun marriage.

      The study tests the discriminant capacity, reliability and validity of the DAS, ENRICH and MCLI Packages, the three assessment measures selected for...

    • Chapter Three The Couple’s Descriptions of Their Relationship
      Chapter Three The Couple’s Descriptions of Their Relationship (pp. 45-58)

      The couples interviews commenced with compliments to the spouses for investing time and effort in a review of their relationship, and with an introduction to self report questionaires as providing the structure to enable a comprehensive overview of the multiple facets of married living. After completing ENRICH, the spouses then participated in their first joint session to review various aspects of their relationship. This information was recorded in schedules which had been drawn up as an integral part of the research process.

      After the computer analysis of the ENRICH package had been returned from ENRICH-Canada by post the couple were...

  8. PART II: VARIATIONS IN MARRIAGE
    • Chapter Four Classification of Types of Marriage
      Chapter Four Classification of Types of Marriage (pp. 61-84)

      The ENRICH marital inventory is one of the scales associated with the Circumplex model which proposes a typology of 16 types of marriage. The ENRICH computer report includes a map showing the spouses’ type of marriage according to their responses on the cohesion and adaptability subscales. Scores on cohesion reflects the balance of separate-togetherness in the marriage which can range from being enmeshed, connected, separated, disengaged. Scores on adaptability reflects the stability-change balance and can range from being rigid, structured, flexible, to chaotic.

      The mid-range levels, connected and separated for cohesion and flexible and structured for adaptability, are considered to...

    • Chapter Five Variations in the Marital Experience According to the Life Cycle
      Chapter Five Variations in the Marital Experience According to the Life Cycle (pp. 85-98)

      The classification of marriages into patterns is a useful way of grouping together marriages with common characteristics. However, a group which shares some similarities may also have interesting variations in other aspects. Thus an analysis of the marriage of either adjusted and non-adjusted spouses at different points of the marital life cycle is likely to show that their experience at formation could differ substantially from their experience at a later stage. These variations need to be identified, as they indicate the points of stress and satisfaction during the various stages of spousal and family living.

      The life cycle framework, which...

    • Chapter Six Variations in the Marital Experience According to Gender and Generational Issues
      Chapter Six Variations in the Marital Experience According to Gender and Generational Issues (pp. 99-116)

      Bernard (1982) observed that there are two marriages in every marriage, his and hers. This is also discernible in some aspects of the Hong Kong study, where husbands generally considered their spousal relationship to be more adjusted and more satisfactory than did the wives. The husbands mean score of 106.3 on the DAS was significantly higher than the wives mean DAS at 99.9 (F=3.80, p=.05). Their sense of global satisfaction also differed significantly (F=4.61, p< 05). This trend is also noted in other research studies (Casas and Ortiz, 1985).

      From their responses, it would seem that the husbands generally considered...

  9. PART III: MARITAL INTERDEPENDENCE
    • Chapter Seven The Transition From Traditional to Companionship Marriages
      Chapter Seven The Transition From Traditional to Companionship Marriages (pp. 119-132)

      Within the last generation, Hong Kong has undergone a series of social changes which have had a direct impact on marriage. In 1971, the Marriage Reform Ordinance restricted marriage to one husband and one wife, and formally abolished the traditional concubine, or tsip sze, status. In 1972, the no fault divorce was instituted. In 1990/1, the Law Reform Commission proposed the waiting period for divorce between two consenting parties to be reduced to separation after one year. Other social changes have also indirectly affected marriages. In 1978, compulsory education was instituted for all children up to the age of 15...

    • Chapter Eight Interdependence in Marital Relationships
      Chapter Eight Interdependence in Marital Relationships (pp. 133-146)

      Social relations among the Chinese are governed by expectations of interdependence. Except for the parent-child relationship, which is one of commitment regardless of the nature of their transactions, interdependence in other relationships is based on various levels of reciprocity. This includes the relationship of marriage, in which husbands and wives contribute to and receive rights and obligations in complementary exchange. A conjugal relationship becomes increasing committed with the development of emotional interdependence, as with Leung Hung (梁鴻) and Mung Kwong (孟光), characters in a frequently retold Chinese tale illustrative of conjugal love.

      Spouses build on their marriage through sharing more...

    • Chapter Nine Tuning Into Spousal Negotiations
      Chapter Nine Tuning Into Spousal Negotiations (pp. 147-160)

      In their daily life, spouses regularly negotiate with each other over various issues of mutual concern. These exchanges may be overt or covert, active or passive, verbal or behavioral. They may be over small matters, or issues of serious concern. Communication is the life blood of any marriage, and in healthy marriages couples generally manage to establish channels satisfactory to both.

      The process can break down in marriages where the confidence of the partners in each other is low, or when extraordinary situations occur within the marriage to threaten the marital balance. This is when the communicative strength of the...

  10. APPENDICES
    • Appendix 1 The Measuring Instruments
      Appendix 1 The Measuring Instruments (pp. 163-173)
    • Appendix 2 Determining Criterion Groups
      Appendix 2 Determining Criterion Groups (pp. 174-183)
    • Appendix 3 Statistical Tests Applied in the Study
      Appendix 3 Statistical Tests Applied in the Study (pp. 184-185)
    • Appendix 4 The Marital Relationship Index — MRI
      Appendix 4 The Marital Relationship Index — MRI (pp. 186-190)
  11. Bibliography
    Bibliography (pp. 191-200)
  12. Author Index
    Author Index (pp. 201-204)
  13. Subject Index
    Subject Index (pp. 205-210)
Hong Kong University Press logo