Homeland Security
Homeland Security: Assessing the First Five Years
Michael Chertoff
With a Foreword by Lee H. Hamilton
Copyright Date: 2009
Published by: University of Pennsylvania Press
Pages: 216
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt3fhgnj
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Homeland Security
Book Description:

In 2003, the President and the U.S. Congress established the Department of Homeland Security. From the beginning, its mission was clear: prevent terrorist attacks, protect against threats to America's safety and security, and prepare the nation to respond effectively to disasters, both natural and man-made. This monumental mission demands a comprehensive strategy. It also requires a crystal-clear explanation of that strategy to Americans and their allies worldwide. In a revealing new book, Homeland Security: Assessing the First Five Years, Michael Chertoff provides that explanation. In a refreshingly candid and engaging manner, America's former homeland security secretary depicts the department's long-term approach, what it has achieved, and what it has yet to do. The strategy begins with the threats America faces, from terrorist groups like al Qaeda to hurricanes like Ike or Gustav. "Once these threats are identified," Chertoff writes, "we can confront them, using every tool at our disposal. We can stop terrorists from entering the country, and discourage people from embracing terrorism by combating its lethal ideology. We can protect our critical assets and reduce our vulnerabilities to natural disasters. We can plan and prepare for emergencies and respond in a way that minimizes the consequences. And we can work closely with our allies abroad to reduce the risk of future disasters." In each of these areas, Chertoff informs the reader what the nation has done and what it still must do to secure its future. How well has this strategy fared in a post-9/11 world? Since that fateful day, there have been no global terror attacks on American soil. Yet in the face of continued dangers, Michael Chertoff warns repeatedly against complacency. He urges America and its leaders to strengthen their resolve, stay the course, and build creatively on past successes.

eISBN: 978-0-8122-0588-6
Subjects: Political Science
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. v-vi)
  3. Foreword
    Foreword (pp. vii-xii)
    Lee H. Hamilton

    Since the September 11 attacks, the United States government has undergone dramatic reforms. Both during and after my tenure as vice chairman of the 9/11 Commission, I witnessed striking changes, ranging from the restructuring of our intelligence agencies to the creation of the Department of Homeland Security.

    These changes, despite some missteps, have generated genuine progress toward better securing the United States. Still, making our homeland more secure is a work in progress. The FBI has made counterterrorism a top priority, fundamentally changing the law enforcement culture and directive of the bureau. An integrated terrorist watch is now complete. Under...

  4. Introduction
    Introduction (pp. 1-8)

    In March 2008, the United States commemorated the fifth anniversary of the creation of the Department of Homeland Security. The occasion was marked by a historic event in the nationʹs capital, at which I hosted President George W. Bush and my predecessor, Tom Ridge, along with thousands of dedicated men and women of the department.

    This volume highlights the achievements of the Department of Homeland Security since its founding, along with its continued challenges in relation to its mission. That mission is to pursue a unified, risk-managed strategy of preventing or reducing America’s vulnerability to terrorism and natural disasters, a...

  5. THREATS
    • 1 Assessing the Dangers
      1 Assessing the Dangers (pp. 11-21)

      Like other nations, the United States has always faced threats to its safety and security. In recent years, however, our media have breathlessly conveyed the impression that threats of nearly every kind are materializing with far greater frequency than in the past. This is partly an illusion triggered by a human tendency to magnify todayʹs problems compared with those of yesterday. What is hardly illusory is the outworking of a number of distinctly modern developments that give rise to emerging vulnerabilities.

      When it comes to natural threats, for example, we have built communities in areas susceptible to wildfires, earthquakes, and...

    • 2 The Ideological Roots of Terror
      2 The Ideological Roots of Terror (pp. 22-36)

      Since the September 11 attacks, the United States has continued to confront the threat posed by its terrorist foes. In the summer of 2006, for example, a major plot to hijack transatlantic airliners was disrupted in London. It served as a stark reminder of how our enemies continue to target this nation and its allies.

      In response to this threat, the United States and its friends must maintain their vigilance against terrorism. But they must also combat the ideas that drive the terrorists. As Jonathan Evans, director general of the British Security Service, has said, “Although the most visible manifestations...

  6. PREVENTION
    • 3 Securing the Border—and Reforming Immigration
      3 Securing the Border—and Reforming Immigration (pp. 39-49)

      Immigration is a source of tremendous strength for our country, but it can also be a source of great division and even confusion for Americans. Talk of immigration tends to stir powerful emotions, provoke strong responses, and generate equal amounts of heat and light in our political discourse.

      Most Americans do seem to agree on one thing: they want something done about illegal immigration. They are tired of decades of lip service, inaction, and broken promises. Not surprisingly, they have grown cynical about the federal governmentʹs willingness to act. Given the serious threat posed by terrorism in the post-9/11 world,...

    • 4 Using Every Tool
      4 Using Every Tool (pp. 50-58)

      In the battle against its terrorist foes, the United States continues to deploy a wide range of preventive tools and options, ranging from law enforcement to military action. Are they serving us well? If they are, we should continue to build on that success by improving their deployment. One way of assessing their effectiveness is to ask a simple question: are we safer today than we were on 9/11?

      When confronting this question, there are two opposite extremes that must be avoided: one, hysteria and fear, and the other, complacency and an almost blithe disregard of the threats we face....

    • 5 Why Soft Power Works
      5 Why Soft Power Works (pp. 59-67)

      It is imperative that over the next decade the United States, in concert with its friends and allies, retain every option at its disposal and apply every available tool or strategy where appropriate against the threat posed by Al Qaeda and like-minded organizations. Certainly that includes the effective use of military options when necessary as well as other tools that may reduce the ability of terrorists to carry out attacks. Most important, however, in order to prevent the growth of terrorist groups themselves, the United States must pursue strategies to win nations and peoples to its side. Use of such...

    • 6 Why Washington Won’t Work
      6 Why Washington Won’t Work (pp. 68-80)

      Long before the nationʹs current financial woes emerged, I was sometimes asked the kinds of questions that may be summed up by the query, ʺWhy doesnʹt Washington work?ʺ

      Even back then, this question revealed a widespread perception that the people who serve in government are either unable or unwilling to get important things done for the country. To the extent that this perception ignores the good that government routinely does each day, it is a distorted portrait of reality. Nonetheless, there are enough glaring examples of government not doing its job well to lend plausibility to this assertion. Consequently, the...

  7. PROTECTION:: REDUCING VULNERABILITIES
    • 7 Protecting and Preserving Infrastructure
      7 Protecting and Preserving Infrastructure (pp. 83-94)

      One of the most urgent tasks before the Department of Homeland Security is the continued protection of the nationʹs critical infrastructure. Since governmentʹs principal function is to protect the nation, it has a vital role to play. But what kind of role should this entail? Broadly speaking, there are two possible answers to this question. The first is what might be deemed the government-alone answer. This approach calls for businesses that operate infrastructure to be intensively managed by officials in Washington, D.C., or state capitals. Those who endorse this view hold that the best way to reduce vulnerabilities is by...

    • 8 Cybersecurity
      8 Cybersecurity (pp. 95-103)

      Of the many challenges facing the global economy in the twenty-first century, one of the most complex and potentially consequential is the threat of a large-scale cyber attack against shared information technology and cyber infrastructure, including the Internet. The exponential growth of the Internet over the past two decades has created manifold benefits for society and the economy, but with these benefits has come a commensurate increase in cyber threats and vulnerabilities, making it imperative to act with urgency and purpose to protect the cyber domain from crippling attacks and disruptions.

      Of course, the world of cyberspace is one in...

    • 9 Responding to IEDs at Home
      9 Responding to IEDs at Home (pp. 104-111)

      In the post-9/11 world, securing the homeland involves the unpleasant task of thinking the way the terrorists do. This entails surveying all the possible ways in which they can attack the United States again, and then deciding how best to defend against these various scenarios. And as we continue to plan accordingly, we face the further challenge of doing so in a way that respects our culture, commerce, and way of life.

      Although the nation can and must protect against the possibility of a terrorist strike through such weapons as biological infections or chemical sprays, the vast majority of attacks...

    • 10 Managing Identity
      10 Managing Identity (pp. 112-120)

      With the pervasive use of the Internet for business transactions, the issue of identity increasingly lies at the heart of the global financial and economic system. If sellers, for example, cannot rely on the information they are receiving about the identity of buyers, this can seriously inhibit global economic progress and growth.

      For the United States and other countries, the problem of identity fraud presents an especially urgent homeland security problem. A number of nations, including the United States, face the daily threat of people attempting to enter and work illegally—as well as the prospect of terrorists, and other...

  8. PREPARATION AND RESPONSE
    • 11 Managing Risk
      11 Managing Risk (pp. 123-132)

      What is the greatest risk that nations face today? Some would say it is the danger posed by global terrorism. Others would point to the prospect of continued financial or economic turmoil. Still others would stress natural disasters like earthquakes, tsunamis, or hurricanes.

      In fact, the principal risk we face is that we will fail to address adequately these and other serious threats to life, safety, and security. The world, including the United States, must manage risk properly: in a sustained, forward-looking fashion that seeks to mitigate risk without vainly attempting to eliminate it. In the United States, it is...

    • 12 Biological Threats and Biodefenses
      12 Biological Threats and Biodefenses (pp. 133-143)

      One of the most important priorities for any government is to protect society from lethal threats. Part of that mission necessarily involves guarding against the havoc that biological forces are capable of wreaking on any population.

      Such forces can come in the form of pandemics or very serious epidemics—deadly communicable diseases that can ravage communities and potentially threaten the fabric of society. While such diseases have surfaced throughout history in discrete areas of the world, the interdependent, global nature of todayʹs world can facilitate their rapid spread across oceans and continents. This naturally occurring peril is compounded by the...

    • 13 The Question of FEMA and Homeland Security
      13 The Question of FEMA and Homeland Security (pp. 144-150)

      While we have not had a successful terrorist attack launched against us since 9/11, we have experienced major natural disasters in recent years. From wildfires in California and tornados and unprecedented flooding in the Midwest to Hurricanes Gustav and Ike along the Gulf Coast, the nation has faced serious challenges from the unleashing of natureʹs fury. In each of these instances, the response of the U.S. government in support of stricken states and localities was led by the Federal Emergency Management Agency.

      By all accounts, FEMA acquitted itself well. This bears eloquent testimony to its dedicated members who put their...

  9. INTERNATIONAL DIMENSIONS
    • 14 Cooperation and Consensus Abroad
      14 Cooperation and Consensus Abroad (pp. 153-159)

      A curious notion has emerged about how the United States has tried to navigate the seas of global security since the September 11 terrorist attacks. It depicts Washington as charting a solitary course characterized by premises, principles, and policies that diverge dramatically from those of other nations—notably its European allies.

      This notion is false and also misleading about the trend of developments. I can attest to the realities based on my extensive interactions with my security counterparts in Europe and elsewhere. Differences in approach do exist, largely rooted in culture, geography and history. But their importance and weight have...

    • 15 The Responsibility to Contain
      15 The Responsibility to Contain (pp. 160-179)

      As economies, societies, and cultures have become increasingly interconnected, the traditional conception of threats to security as stemming from identifiable sources in individual countries has become antiquated. Today, many threats are stateless in origin and transnational in scope. Terrorist groups such as Hezbollah and Al Qaeda have cells in multiple countries, often operating without the active support of any government but still capable of committing attacks with global impact. Both 9/11 and the unsuccessful plot to blow up airliners over the Atlantic Ocean in 2006 were aimed at disrupting the global air transportation network. Potentially crippling attacks on the power...

  10. Conclusion: Before September 11—and Since
    Conclusion: Before September 11—and Since (pp. 180-183)

    Since its creation in 2003, the Department of Homeland Security has achieved much in its efforts to enhance the safety and security of the United States. In the short span of its existence, the department has built a critical set of capabilities that were not in place prior to September 11.

    Before September 11, the United States had no effective system for identifying dangerous individuals arriving at our ports of entry. Today we can validate identities in seconds.

    Before September 11, the country did not have a coherent strategy for securing our land borders. Today, by applying a combination of...

  11. Notes
    Notes (pp. 184-192)
  12. Index
    Index (pp. 193-200)
  13. Acknowledgments
    Acknowledgments (pp. 201-203)
University of Pennsylvania Press logo