The Conversion of Herman the Jew
The Conversion of Herman the Jew: Autobiography, History, and Fiction in the Twelfth Century
Jean-Claude Schmitt
Translated by Alex J. Novikoff
Series: The Middle Ages Series
Copyright Date: 2010
Published by: University of Pennsylvania Press
Pages: 320
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt3fhkjf
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
The Conversion of Herman the Jew
Book Description:

Sometime toward the middle of the twelfth century, it is supposed, an otherwise obscure figure, born a Jew in Cologne and later ordained as a priest in Cappenberg in Westphalia, wrote a Latin account of his conversion to Christianity. Known as the Opusculum, this book purportedly by "Herman, the former Jew" may well be the first autobiography to be written in the West after the Confessions of Saint Augustine. It may also be something else entirely. In The Conversion of Herman the Jew the eminent French historian Jean-Claude Schmitt examines this singular text and the ways in which it has divided its readers. Where some have seen it as an authentic conversion narrative, others have asked whether it is not a complete fabrication forged by Christian clerics. For Schmitt the question is poorly posed. The work is at once true and fictional, and the search for its lone author-whether converted Jew or not-fruitless. Herman may well have existed and contributed to the writing of his life, but the Opusculum is a collective work, perhaps framed to meet a specific institutional agenda. With agility and erudition, Schmitt examines the text to explore its meaning within the society and culture of its period and its participation in both a Christian and Jewish imaginary. What can it tell us about autobiography and subjectivity, about the function of dreams and the legitimacy of religious images, about individual and collective conversion, and about names and identities? In The Conversion of Herman the Jew Schmitt masterfully seizes upon the debates surrounding the Opusculum (the text of which is newly translated for this volume) to ponder more fundamentally the ways in which historians think and write.

eISBN: 978-0-8122-0875-7
Subjects: History
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. [i]-[vi])
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. [vii]-[vii])
  3. [Map]
    [Map] (pp. [viii]-[viii])
  4. Introduction
    Introduction (pp. 1-11)

    This book invites a double displacement; one in time, by rolling back the centuries to the beginning of the twelfth century, the other in space, by focusing the reader on what is probably an unfamiliar region—the northwest of Germany, and more precisely the present-day region of Rhine-Westphalia, between Cologne and Munster, further to the east (see map). The occasion for this journey backward through time and across space is a text—the Opusculum de conversione sua attributed to Hermannus quondam Judaeus, ‘‘Herman the former Jew’’—written in Latin in the twelfth century. This text has been transmitted to us...

  5. Chapter 1 Fiction and Truth
    Chapter 1 Fiction and Truth (pp. 12-43)

    The first printed edition of the Opusculum appeared during the formative period of Christian anti-Jewish apologetics: in Leipzig in 1687 Johann Benedikt Carpzov took to reediting the famous Pugio fidei (or Dagger of Faith), a treatise composed in 1278 by the Dominican Raymond Martini, a lecturer on the studium in Barcelona. Born there around 1210–1215, Raymond Martini joined the Dominican order in around 1237–1240, and in 1250 was sent to Tunis by Raymond of Peñaforte as part of the new studium arabicum dedicated to evangelizing Muslims. Upon his return Raymond Martini wrote the Dagger of Faith, which marks...

  6. Chapter 2 Medieval Autobiography
    Chapter 2 Medieval Autobiography (pp. 44-66)

    The Opusculum de conversione sua presents itself as an autobiography, and more precisely an autobiography about conversion. It is its form that should concern us, independent of the questions that have already been raised regarding the “authenticity” of the testimony and the Jewish identity of the supposed “author.” I insist all the more on this point since the scholarship of the past fifteen years that has been devoted to this text, most of which concerns whether Judas/Herman existed or not and whether he indeed wrote the text, has for the most part neglected the question of its autobiographical form, thus...

  7. Chapter 3 The Dream and Its Interpretation
    Chapter 3 The Dream and Its Interpretation (pp. 67-113)

    Herman’s conversion account displays at least two exceptional formal characteristics. The first is its autobiographical form, of which we have just spoken. The second lies in the fact that the main part of the autobiography (chapters 2 through 20) is framed between the narration of a dream at the beginning (chapter 1) and its interpretation at the end (chapter 21). The manner in which the last chapter responds to, and illuminates, the first invites us to recognize in the Opusculum, if not a literary ‘‘fiction,’’ at least the concern for elegant writing and a carefully thought-out plan. The fact that...

  8. Chapter 4 Conversion to Images
    Chapter 4 Conversion to Images (pp. 114-144)

    When Herman takes up the account of his conversion in chapter 2 of the Opusculum, seven years have passed since his boyhood dream. Now about twenty years old, he is sent by his father to get from Bishop Eckbert of Munster (1127–1132) repayment of a loan that the young man had thoughtlessly made to the prelate without security. The bishop had needed the money in order to cover expenses for a stay in Mainz where Emperor Lothar’s court was temporarily residing. This motive appears to be entirely made up for the purpose of the account, since neither Lothar nor...

  9. [Illustrations]
    [Illustrations] (pp. None)
  10. Chapter 5 Baptism and Name
    Chapter 5 Baptism and Name (pp. 145-169)

    The baptism of young Judas in chapter 19 marks the culminating moment in the account of his conversion. It is also the most dramatic event. In this respect, the Opusculum is no different from the many other accounts from late antiquity onward that deal principally, but not exclusively, with Jewish converts. Baptism is the public act of renouncing “Jewish superstition,” or, for pagans, of renouncing “idolatry.” Later, it concerns more generally the children of Christians who are thereby integrated into the community of those who are baptized and cleansed of original sin. If the meaning of the rite is that...

  11. Chapter 6 “A New Era of Conversion”
    Chapter 6 “A New Era of Conversion” (pp. 170-192)

    The moment of baptism marks not only the pinnacle of Herman’s conversion account; during the course of the twelfth century it is situated more generally at the heart of liturgical practice, imagination, and imagery, all of which emphasize its importance. Herman’s account echoes a number of other conversion accounts that share the same framework and many recurrent themes. Conversion is no more of a purely individual experience than is a dream. It signifies adherence to a broader paradigm that, during this period of reformatio and renovatio of the church and Christian society, commands people’s destiny and indeed the destiny of...

  12. Conclusion
    Conclusion (pp. 193-198)

    The point of departure for this book was a question starkly put in 1988 by an excellent historian of Judaism regarding the supposed autobiography of a medieval Jew who converted to Christianity: ‘‘Truth or Fiction?’’ Is this text, the Opusculum de conversione sua by a certain Hermannus quondam Judaeus, the autobiography of a conversion to Christianity by a person who really existed, or is it a pure ‘‘romance’’ devoid of any real basis, written in the twelfth century by Premonstratensian canons in Westphalia?

    Throughout this book I have tried to show that this question is, in my mind, badly put....

  13. Extract from the Vita of Godfried, Count of Cappenberg (c. 1150–1155) [Ed. P. Jaffé, MGH, Scriptores, XII, ¶ 3, p. 517, line 12 to p. 518, line 23]
    Extract from the Vita of Godfried, Count of Cappenberg (c. 1150–1155) [Ed. P. Jaffé, MGH, Scriptores, XII, ¶ 3, p. 517, line 12 to p. 518, line 23] (pp. 199-201)

    […] The aforementioned father Norbert [of Xanten] loved the monastery of Cappenberg tenderly and more than any other place. I shall not leave unmentioned what he said regarding this place when he was staying with the brothers: “Dearest brothers,” he said, “once when I was near here I saw for certain the Holy Spirit descend upon this place. Another time I was contemplating a great and luminous light that was emanating from this place and shining all around. This is why, dearly beloved, you must glorify our God, for this place is truly ‘the mount of his sanctification’ [cf. Psalms...

  14. Herman the Former Jew: Short Work on the Subject of His Conversion [Ed: Hermannus Quondam Judaeus, Opusculum de conversione sua, PL, vol. 170, cols. 803–836]
    Herman the Former Jew: Short Work on the Subject of His Conversion [Ed: Hermannus Quondam Judaeus, Opusculum de conversione sua, PL, vol. 170, cols. 803–836] (pp. 202-240)

    Herman’s Letter

    To his dearest son Henry, Herman, who by the grace of God, sends his heartfelt love in Christ. Many religious men and women persist in trying to find out from me how I converted from Judaism to the grace of Christ and whether, in the early stages of my conversion, I endured temptations from the clever Enemy. Indeed, it was in your presence recently that I was made by some devout women, in the course of a holy conversation, to recount the whole sequence of events. For I did not convert with the ease with which we see...

  15. Notes
    Notes (pp. 241-276)
  16. Bibliography
    Bibliography (pp. 277-296)
  17. Index
    Index (pp. 297-302)
  18. Acknowledgments
    Acknowledgments (pp. 303-303)
University of Pennsylvania Press logo