Sanctifying the Name of God
Sanctifying the Name of God: Jewish Martyrs and Jewish Memories of the First Crusade
Jeremy Cohen
Series: Jewish Culture and Contexts
Copyright Date: 2004
Published by: University of Pennsylvania Press
Pages: 224
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt3fj00h
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Sanctifying the Name of God
Book Description:

How are martyrs made, and how do the memories of martyrs express, nourish, and mold the ideals of the community? Sanctifying the Name of God wrestles with these questions against the background of the massacres of Jews in the Rhineland during the outbreak of the First Crusade. Marking the first extensive wave of anti-Jewish violence in medieval Christian Europe, these "Persecutions of 1096" exerted a profound influence on the course of European Jewish history. When the crusaders demanded that Jews choose between Christianity and death, many opted for baptism. Many others, however, chose to die as Jews rather than to live as Christians, and of these, many actually inflicted death upon themselves and their loved ones. Stories of their self-sacrifice ushered the Jewish ideal of martyrdom-kiddush ha-Shem, the sanctification of God's holy name-into a new phase, conditioning the collective memory and mindset of Ashkenazic Jewry for centuries to come, during the Holocaust, and even today. The Jewish survivors of 1096 memorialized the victims as martyrs as they rebuilt their communities during the decades following the Crusade. Three twelfth-century Hebrew chronicles of the persecutions preserve their memories of martyrdom and self-sacrifice, tales fraught with symbolic meaning that constitute one of the earliest Jewish attempts at local, contemporary historiography. Reading and analyzing these stories through the prism of Jewish and Christian religious and literary traditions, Jeremy Cohen shows how these persecution chronicles reveal much more about the storytellers, the martyrologists, than about the martyrs themselves. While they extol the glorious heroism of the martyrs, they also air the doubts, guilt, and conflicts of those who, by submitting temporarily to the Christian crusaders, survived.

eISBN: 978-0-8122-0163-5
Subjects: Religion
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. v-vi)
  3. Preface
    Preface (pp. vii-x)
  4. List of Abbreviations for Primary Sources
    List of Abbreviations for Primary Sources (pp. xi-xv)
  5. [Map]
    [Map] (pp. xvi-xvi)
  6. Introduction: The Persecutions of 1096
    Introduction: The Persecutions of 1096 (pp. 1-10)

    Thus the payyetan, the Jewish liturgical poet of the Middle Ages, recalled the massacres of the spring and summer of 1096, when, during the earliest months of the First Crusade, bands of armed crusaders attacked Jewish communities in western and central Germany. The crusaders converted those Jews whom they could, while others who fell in their path they killed. Jewish settlements of the Rhine valley—in Speyer, Worms, Mainz, Cologne and its suburbs, Metz, and Trier—and others including Regensburg and Prague to the east suffered serious losses in life and property. This marked the first major outbreak of anti-Jewish...

  7. PART I PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS
    • Chapter 1 To Sanctify the Name of God
      Chapter 1 To Sanctify the Name of God (pp. 13-30)

      Unquestionably the most striking aspect of the 1096 persecutions and their Hebrew chronicles is the slaughter of Ashkenazic Jews by their own hands.

      Not wishing to deny their beliefs and to give up the fear of our king …, they held out their necks to be slaughtered and offered their untainted souls to their father in heaven…. Each one in turn sacrificed and was sacrificed, until the blood of one touched the blood of another: The blood of husbands mixed with that of their wives, the blood of fathers and their children, the blood of brothers and their sisters, the...

    • Chapter 2 The First Crusade and Its Historians
      Chapter 2 The First Crusade and Its Historians (pp. 31-54)

      The anti-Jewish violence of 1096 has received little attention in general works on the history of the Crusades. Most such histories make do with passing mention of the persecutions; several offer brief reviews of the major events; but, apart from occasional consideration of the attackers’ motives, few undertake any extensive investigation or analysis.¹

      All this is understandable. The attacks on Jewish communities were a diversion for the crusaders rather than a primary objective; in relation to other anti-Jewish hostilities of the Christian Middle Ages, they inflicted relatively little physical damage of lasting consequence, despite the tragic loss of life that...

    • Chapter 3 Points of Departure
      Chapter 3 Points of Departure (pp. 55-70)

      One ought not to conclude too hastily that the Jewish martyrs of 1096 subscribed to—and acted upon—the very ideas of kiddush ha-Shem expressed in the Hebrew chronicles that took shape only after the persecutions. At the very least, such a conclusion is insufficient unto itself. On the one hand, it proceeds from a questionable assumption: that medieval historical narratives should accurately explain behaviors that they record with a minimum of distortion, such that the skilled reader can distinguish between the motivations of those involved in a prior event and those who remembered that event after the fact. On...

  8. PART II MARTYRS OF 1096
    • Chapter 4 Last Supper at Xanten
      Chapter 4 Last Supper at Xanten (pp. 73-90)

      The wave of attacks on German Jews highlighted in the Hebrew chronicles of the First Crusade progressed down the Rhine in a northerly direction—from Speyer, Worms, and Mainz in May of 1096, to Cologne and its environs from the last days of May and into July. We read that several hundred Jews fled Cologne and sought refuge in a number of smaller villages in the area, but that the violence caught up with them there as well. On Friday evening, June 27, the crusaders reportedly fell upon a band of Jews hiding out in the town of Xanten, where...

    • Chapter 5 Master Isaac the Parnas
      Chapter 5 Master Isaac the Parnas (pp. 91-105)

      From Xanten and the suburbs of Cologne we retrace our steps back up the Rhine to Mainz, and one month back in time. Reports of martyrdom in the Mainz Jewish community dominate each of the three surviving Hebrew chronicles of 1096, and we shall accordingly devote this chapter and the following two to several exemplary Jewish martyrs who perished in Mainz and to the nameless survivors who told their stories.

      The chronicles relate that the crusaders massacred the Jews of Mainz on the third of Sivan, 4856, that is, May 27, 1096, when hundreds of Jews, perhaps over a thousand,...

    • Chapter 6 Mistress Rachel of Mainz
      Chapter 6 Mistress Rachel of Mainz (pp. 106-129)

      My critics have accused me of transforming acts of Jewish martyrdom into tales of events that never occurred; instead of treating the Hebrew Crusade chronicles as works of history, so they claim, I have mistreated them as literature, mining them for symbols and codes while overlooking the facts. While I have no doubt that the acts of the martyrs directly inspired those who told their stories and those who collected these stories in the chronicles, this hardly proves that in their specific episodes the chronicles preserve an accurate, play-by-play account of what in fact happened in the Rhineland in 1096....

    • Chapter 7 Kalonymos in Limbo
      Chapter 7 Kalonymos in Limbo (pp. 130-141)

      The chronicles describe the death and suffering of the martyrs in graphic detail. As we have seen, they also make room for those who opted for survival over death, referring to them at times explicitly and at times implicitly, in the “play,” the symbols, and the allusions of the tales of the martyrs.

      How did the Jews of the Rhineland make their fateful decision when the crusaders attacked them in l096? Some historians have used our Hebrew chronicles to argue that their ideals of kiddush ha-Shem, of Jewish martyrdom, must have already been ingrained in Ashkenazic Jewish communities by the...

    • Chapter 8 The Rape of Sarit
      Chapter 8 The Rape of Sarit (pp. 142-158)

      As the Jews of Germany looked back on the persecutions of 1096 and celebrated the heroism of their martyrs, they also recoiled in horror at the violence inflicted upon Jew by non-Jew and that inflicted upon Jew by Jew. Understandably, they could not rise up and clamor in protest against those Jewish heroes who had killed their loved ones before submitting to martyrdom themselves. That would have defeated one of the two primary purposes of their storytelling, to establish the grandeur and superiority of Jewish martyrdom in the face of the hostile challenge of crusading. But the other purpose of...

  9. Afterword
    Afterword (pp. 159-164)

    Memories of the martyrs of 1096 persist, among religious and secular Jews alike. Four times each year, Jews gather in synagogue to remember their loved ones in the memorial service of Yizkor Elohim, “May God Remember.” Synagogue attendance for these prayers is generally high, as many who might not otherwise participate in community worship turn out on these days for remembering the dead. After individuals recite the Yizkor prayer for those in their own immediate families, they typically join in communal prayers on behalf of souls with whom all feel some connection: deceased leaders of the congregation, Jews who perished...

  10. Notes
    Notes (pp. 165-180)
  11. Bibliography of Secondary Sources
    Bibliography of Secondary Sources (pp. 181-200)
  12. Index
    Index (pp. 201-208)
University of Pennsylvania Press logo