From Human Trafficking to Human Rights
From Human Trafficking to Human Rights: Reframing Contemporary Slavery
Alison Brysk
Austin Choi-Fitzpatrick
Series: Pennsylvania Studies in Human Rights
Copyright Date: 2012
Published by: University of Pennsylvania Press
Pages: 280
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt3fj0z1
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
From Human Trafficking to Human Rights
Book Description:

Over the last decade, public, political, and scholarly attention has focused on human trafficking and contemporary forms of slavery. Yet as human rights scholars Alison Brysk and Austin Choi-Fitzpatrick argue, most current work tends to be more descriptive and focused on trafficking for sexual exploitation. In From Human Trafficking to Human Rights, Brysk, Choi-Fitzpatrick, and a cast of experts demonstrate that it is time to recognize human trafficking as more a matter of human rights and social justice, rooted in larger structural issues relating to the global economy, human security, U.S. foreign policy, and labor and gender relations. Such reframing involves overcoming several of the most difficult barriers to the development of human rights discourse: women's rights as human rights, labor rights as a confluence of structure and agency, the interdependence of migration and discrimination, the ideological and policy hegemony of the United States in setting the terms of debate, and a politics of global justice and governance. Throughout this volume, the argument is clear: a deep human rights approach can improve analysis and response by recovering human rights principles that match protection with empowerment and recognize the interdependence of social rights and personal freedoms. Together, contributors to the volume conclude that rethinking trafficking requires moving our orientation from sex to slavery, from prostitution to power relations, and from rescue to rights. On the basis of this argument, From Human Trafficking to Human Rights offers concrete policy approaches to improve the global response necessary to end slavery responsibly.

eISBN: 978-0-8122-0573-2
Subjects: Sociology
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. v-viii)
  3. Introduction: Rethinking Trafficking
    Introduction: Rethinking Trafficking (pp. 1-10)
    Alison Brysk and Austin Choi-Fitzpatrick

    Over the last decade, the problem of modern slavery has moved from being a marginal concern to a mainstream issue, with significant advances in levels of public awareness, official engagement, and specialized research. Trafficking in persons for the purposes of forced prostitution has been the primary focal point of this renewed interest in questions of human bondage. From 1865 through 1990 slavery suffered from issue depletion, only to be rediscovered as human trafficking and successfully adopted as a cause célèbre. Scholars, activists, policy makers, and the general public have found the plight of millions to be a departure point for...

  4. PART I. FROM SEX TO SLAVERY
    • Chapter 1 Rethinking Trafficking: Contemporary Slavery
      Chapter 1 Rethinking Trafficking: Contemporary Slavery (pp. 13-24)
      Austin Choi-Fitzpatrick

      Over the last fifteen years, ever-increasing public, political, and scholarly attention has focused on human trafficking and modern slavery. This attention has been converted into action as pressure from international advocates has generated new international norms and policies. Advocacy within the United States has resulted in new domestic legislation. Subsequent pressure from the U.S. government has resulted in new legislation abroad, as well as extensive funding of projects intended to prevent trafficking, protect trafficked individuals, and prosecute perpetrators.

      Action on the part of the United States has also generated a range of criticism, from both human rights advocates and scholars...

    • Chapter 2 Uncomfortable Silences: Contemporary Slavery and the “Lessons” of History
      Chapter 2 Uncomfortable Silences: Contemporary Slavery and the “Lessons” of History (pp. 25-43)
      Joel Quirk

      Over the last decade, the various practices that fall under the rubric of contemporary slavery have generated a level of public interest that has not been matched since early twentieth-century campaigns against both “white slavery” and forced labor in the Congo Free State. Numerous governments have recently drafted new anti-slavery (mostly anti-trafficking) laws. Some legislatures have even established specialized anti-slavery agencies and taskforces. Various reports have been drafted, additional protocols and procedures have been established, and a range of rehabilitation schemes and training programs have been introduced. These official activities have followed in the wake of a remarkable change in...

    • Chapter 3 Representing Trafficking: Media in the United States, Great Britain, and Canada
      Chapter 3 Representing Trafficking: Media in the United States, Great Britain, and Canada (pp. 44-70)
      Girish J. “Jeff” Gulati

      The trafficking of persons across borders for sexual, labor, and other forms of exploitation is a subject that has captured the attention of international organizations, activists, and policy makers that range the ideological spectrum. A 2000 United Nations Protocol established guidelines on how nations should combat trafficking and assist victims. In the same year, the Trafficking Victims Protection Act became law in the United States with near unanimous support, establishing the first and most aggressive effort to date in the punishment of traffickers, protection for victims, and prevention programs (Stolz 2007; Wyler, Siskin, and Seelke 2009). Since then, new anti-trafficking...

  5. PART II. FROM PROSTITUTION TO POWER
    • Chapter 4 Rethinking Trafficking: Human Rights and Private Wrongs
      Chapter 4 Rethinking Trafficking: Human Rights and Private Wrongs (pp. 73-85)
      Alison Brysk

      Over the last decade, international humanitarian campaigns and policy have begun to address the horrific and increasing transnational sexual exploitation of women and children. While this is a welcome development, it is too often based on a distorted understanding of trafficking, violence, and globalization. Sexualized, individualistic myths regarding trafficking limit appropriate attention and response to victims of a wide range of globalized exploitation and coercion—including the intended beneficiaries of anti-trafficking efforts.

      The fight against slavery is seen as the first international human rights movement, but the persistence and revival of this ancient evil shows that in an era of...

    • Chapter 5 The Sexual Politics of U.S. Inter/National Security
      Chapter 5 The Sexual Politics of U.S. Inter/National Security (pp. 86-106)
      Laura Hebert

      Once an invisible issue, the problem of human trafficking has captured public and political attention over the past decade, as evidenced by the many books, films, and college courses that today speak to the subject, as well as the myriad anti-trafficking laws and policies that are now in place at the national and international levels. This is a development welcomed by activists around the world who have struggled to bring international visibility to exploitative labor conditions associated with globalization. But, as Alison Brysk observes, the implementation of anti-trafficking efforts has also become a “relatively easy way [for states] to enact...

    • Chapter 6 Rethinking Gender Violence: Battered and Trafficked Women in Greece and the United States
      Chapter 6 Rethinking Gender Violence: Battered and Trafficked Women in Greece and the United States (pp. 107-120)
      Gabriela Wasileski and Mark J. Miller

      Both domestic violence and trafficking in humans pose serious problems worldwide. However, there are differences in the ways in which similarly abused battered immigrant women and trafficked immigrant women are treated by governmental agencies in Greece and in the United States. Trafficking in humans has been securitized worldwide, rather than treated as a human rights violation—that is, framed as an issue linked to international security risk. As a result, countries that do not take legal action to stop human trafficking could face U.S. sanctions such as loss of U.S. military and economic assistance. Under significant international pressure, in 2002...

    • Chapter 7 Peacekeepers and Human Trafficking: The New Security Dilemma
      Chapter 7 Peacekeepers and Human Trafficking: The New Security Dilemma (pp. 121-136)
      Charles Anthony Smith

      In July 1999, the United Nations deployed the Kosovo Protection Force (KFOR) to protect ethnic Albanians in the war-torn province of Serbia. With the adoption of Security Council Resolution 1244, approximately 20,000 UN troops were deployed to Kosovo to protect the civilian population from daily skirmishes between the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) and the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (FRY). Within months, several international human rights organizations began reporting precipitous increases in trafficking for sexual exploitation in the region. An Amnesty International report released in August 2004 reported that human trafficking rings were abducting women from Eastern Europe to be sold...

    • Chapter 8 The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly: Assessing the Impact of the OAS and the UN on Human Trafficking in Haiti
      Chapter 8 The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly: Assessing the Impact of the OAS and the UN on Human Trafficking in Haiti (pp. 137-154)
      Heather T. Smith

      How can global governance contribute to a human rights approach to human trafficking? As the number of international organizations (IOs) has expanded in the post–World War II period, so, too, has their role in global governance. The World Health Organization plays a key role in arresting the spread of infectious disease around the globe. The International Monetary Fund rescues states with loans when they are in danger of economic collapse, and the United Nations (UN) deploys troops to conflict zones to maintain international peace and security. Yet, for all of their positive contributions, we lack an understanding of all...

  6. PART III. FROM RESCUE TO RIGHTS
    • Chapter 9 Making Human Rights Accessible: The Role of Governments in Trafficking and Migrant Labor Exploitation
      Chapter 9 Making Human Rights Accessible: The Role of Governments in Trafficking and Migrant Labor Exploitation (pp. 157-171)
      Christien van den Anker

      There is a strong basis for the argument that freedom from slavery is a universal right, as it is protected in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948 as well as numerous subsequent treaties that have been ratified widely. Yet in practice, contemporary forms of slavery are widespread, and despite international and state-based action, NGO pressure, and increasing criminal proceedings against employers, the consistent violation of freedom from slavery raises the question: What makes governments reluctant or incapable to protect this right effectively within and across their own borders?

      Human rights discourse is traditionally divided over the role of nation-states...

    • Chapter 10 Human Rights and Human Trafficking: A Reflection on the Influence and Evolution of the U.S. Trafficking in Persons Reports
      Chapter 10 Human Rights and Human Trafficking: A Reflection on the Influence and Evolution of the U.S. Trafficking in Persons Reports (pp. 172-194)
      Anne Gallagher

      Until the turn of the present century, the phenomenon of trafficking was of only vague and incidental interest to states and the international community. The traditional concept of trafficking was, by today’s standards, extremely narrow: it was generally accepted that only women and children could be trafficked and then only for commercial sexual exploitation. Few states considered themselves directly affected, and at the international level, discussions on trafficking were confined to the margins of the UN human rights system. The changes that have taken place over the last decade are truly astonishing. Trafficking is now the subject of a strong...

    • Chapter 11 The Anti-slavery Movement: Making Rights Reality
      Chapter 11 The Anti-slavery Movement: Making Rights Reality (pp. 195-216)
      Kevin Bales and Austin Choi-Fitzpatrick

      How we end slavery is the 27-million-person question. What does the rethinking of this volume tell us about how to end slavery and trafficking—and how can we integrate this with the knowledge and practice of the anti-slavery movement in the field? In this volume, the contributions rethinking the roots of trafficking suggest we must address interlocking dynamics of domination: gender, consciousness, political economy, and international relations.

      When we look at what supports slavery around the world, things seem a little discouraging. Apparently all we have to do is end world poverty, stop all corruption, keep people from being greedy,...

  7. Notes
    Notes (pp. 217-224)
  8. Bibliography
    Bibliography (pp. 225-258)
  9. List of Contributors
    List of Contributors (pp. 259-260)
  10. Index
    Index (pp. 261-266)
  11. Acknowledgments
    Acknowledgments (pp. 267-268)
University of Pennsylvania Press logo