Global Downtowns
Global Downtowns
Marina Peterson
Gary W. McDonogh
Series: The City in the Twenty-First Century
Copyright Date: 2012
Published by: University of Pennsylvania Press
Pages: 368
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt3fj4rx
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Global Downtowns
Book Description:

Global Downtowns reconsiders one of the defining features of urban life-the energy and exuberance that characterize downtown areas-within a framework of contemporary globalization and change. It analyzes the iconic centers of global cities through individual case studies from Europe, Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the United States, considering issues of function, population, imagery, and growth. Contributors to the volume use ethnographic and cultural analysis to identify downtowns as products of the activities of planners, power elites, and consumers and as zones of conflict and competition. Whether claiming space on a world stage through architecture, media events, or historical tourism or facing the claims of different social groups for a place at the center, downtowns embody the heritage of the modern city and its future. Essays draw on extensive fieldwork and archival study in Beijing, Barcelona, New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Dar es Salaam, Dubai, Nashville, Lima, Philadelphia, Mumbai, Havana, Beirut, and Paris, among other cities. They examine the visions of planners and developers, cultural producers, governments, theoreticians, immigrants, and outcasts. Through these perspectives, the book explores questions of space and place, consumption, mediation, and images as well as the processes by which urban elites learn from each other as well as contest local hegemony. Global Downtowns raises important questions for those who work with issues of urban centrality in governance, planning, investment, preservation, and social reform. The volume insists that however important the narratives of individual spaces-theories of American downtowns, images of global souks, or diasporic formations of ethnic enclaves as interconnected nodes-they also must be situated within a larger, dynamic framework of downtowns as centers of modern urban imagination.

eISBN: 978-0-8122-0805-4
Subjects: Sociology
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. v-viii)
  3. Introduction: Globalizing Downtown
    Introduction: Globalizing Downtown (pp. 1-26)
    Gary W. McDonogh and Marina Peterson

    “DOWNTOWN!” The word itself, like its myriad global cognates including el centro, wasat al-madina, centre ville, and zhongwan, evokes intensities at the core of urban life, space, and capital: “Bright lights, surging crowds, tall buildings, big money, power politics.” To speak of global downtowns demands careful analysis of the particularities of place and people as well as examination of shared processes connecting and transforming cities worldwide as dense, active sites of encounter, competition, celebration, and conflict. In this volume, we look at widespread processes, knowledge, and mediations underpinning the formations of such central spaces. We consider the global elements of...

  4. Part I. Imagination
    • 1 Toward a Genealogy of Downtowns
      1 Toward a Genealogy of Downtowns (pp. 29-47)
      Robert Rotenberg

      How do we sense a city? Is it a matter of directing our gaze from building to street to traffic to neon signs and back to the building again, accumulating impressions of line, scale, enclosure, mass, and spectacle, just as we do when viewing a painting of a landscape? No, the immediacy of our body’s movement through the city requires a different kind of gaze, one that filters and edits our impressions according to preestablished systems of knowledge. For those cities where we consider ourselves at home, the knowledge is different from what it is for cities where we are...

    • 2 From Peking to Beijing: Production of Centrality in the Global Age
      2 From Peking to Beijing: Production of Centrality in the Global Age (pp. 48-64)
      Xuefei Ren

      On August 7, 2008, one day before the opening ceremony of the Beijing Olympics, Qianmen Avenue reopened to the public and tourists after several months of extensive renovation. Qianmen (meaning “front gate” in Chinese) is adjacent to Tiananmen Square, the geographic and symbolic center of Beijing, and it was once the major marketplace in the late Qing period. The area declined after the demise of the Qing dynasty in 1911 and was replaced by newer marketplaces that emerged in other parts of the city. By the early 2000s, it had become a dilapidated inner-city neighborhood crowded with lower-income households, migrants,...

    • 3 Simulations of Barcelona: Urban Projects in Port Spaces (1981–2002)
      3 Simulations of Barcelona: Urban Projects in Port Spaces (1981–2002) (pp. 65-89)
      Francesc Magrinyà and Gaspar Maza

      The large port zone close to central Barcelona has witnessed, in a brief period of time, an important series of urban reforms. This area has been transformed into a new civic space without losing its older condition of zona franca (a distinct port authority). The space also now houses new commercial buildings, offices, and cultural centers in the form of museums, an aquarium, and a 3-D IMAX cinema. Thus, it has been labeled by the city as a new area of centrality, in a sense, a new “downtown” near but not connected to either the ritual and political center of...

    • 4 Urbanist Ideology and the Production of Space in the United Arab Emirates: An Anthropological Critique
      4 Urbanist Ideology and the Production of Space in the United Arab Emirates: An Anthropological Critique (pp. 90-110)
      Ahmed Kanna

      Along with China, the contemporary Arabian Gulf is undergoing an urbanization of massive proportions. Possessing 40 percent of the world’s proven oil reserves and flush with profits from recent spikes in global oil prices, the six countries of the Gulf Cooperation Council were devoting trillions of dollars to construction projects before the 2008 economic crisis (Brown 2008).¹ Architects view the Gulf, whose member states are run by tiny elites disposing of immense wealth and nearly nonexistent labor and environmental regulation, as a liberating place in which to work. (There are parallels here to architects’ views of China). No Gulf country...

  5. Part II. Consumption
    • 5 Reaching for Dubai: Nashville Dreams of a Twenty-First-Century Skyline
      5 Reaching for Dubai: Nashville Dreams of a Twenty-First-Century Skyline (pp. 113-135)
      Richard Lloyd and Brian D. Christens

      So Nashville developer Tony Giarratana told the New York Times in 2006 (Chamberlain 2006), referring to the proposed Signature Tower, a residential high-rise projected to radically transform Nashville’s skyline. Given that Giarratana had opted to eschew public subsidy on the project and was still seeking the necessary private financing to realize his grandiose ambitions, the claim that the building was not “about making money” is a stunning and perhaps ill-considered admission. Nevertheless, “build it and they will come” had become a mantra for globally financed, impossibly extravagant architectural projects colonizing unlikely locales, with spectacular if short-lived models of success in...

    • 6 From National Utopia to Elite Enclave: “Economic Realities” and Resistance in the Reconstruction of Beirut
      6 From National Utopia to Elite Enclave: “Economic Realities” and Resistance in the Reconstruction of Beirut (pp. 136-159)
      Najib Hourani

      On October 1, 2009, officials of the Lebanese Company for the Development and Reconstruction of the Beirut Central District (BCD), or Solidere, as it is popularly known, offered journalists a guided tour of the company’s flagship development: the new Beirut Souks.¹ Slated to open to the public the following day, the new Souks embody what the company and its supporters argue is the primary virtue of private sector-led urban redevelopment: the ability to reconcile the imperatives of market-driven globalization with respect for and preservation of historically generated urban form and memory.

      The product of an international design competition, developed with...

    • 7 When the Film Festival Comes to (Down)Town: Transnational Circuits, Tourism, and the Urban Economy of Images
      7 When the Film Festival Comes to (Down)Town: Transnational Circuits, Tourism, and the Urban Economy of Images (pp. 160-185)
      William Cunningham Bissell

      Urban sites have long served as concentrated nodes where cultural life, communications, capital, and communities all come together to attain a certain density and power, exercising influence far beyond city limits. The image of downtown certainly testifies to the iconic reach and centralizing force that cities possess, attracting people to the core even as images of downtown radiate outward, broadcasting its allure into a far-flung sphere. Over a century ago, Georg Simmel (1950 [1903]: 419) argued, “It is in the decisive nature of the metropolis that its inner life overflows by waves into a far-flung national or international arena,” and...

    • 8 The Future of the Past: World Heritage, National Identity, and Urban Centrality in Late Socialist Cuba
      8 The Future of the Past: World Heritage, National Identity, and Urban Centrality in Late Socialist Cuba (pp. 186-206)
      Matthew J. Hill

      In the summer of 1996, demolition crews arrived in the Plaza Vieja—a 500-year-old plaza in Havana’s historic center, Habana Vieja—equipped with explosive charges. Carrying out orders issued by the city historian, they planned to eliminate every trace of a republican-era park and an underground parking structure, which was built to accommodate the “bulky American autos” that blocked the sidewalks of Habana Vieja’s narrow streets and entrances to residential courtyards (Scarpaci 2000: 733). In addition to the parking structure, which raised the original height of the square a meter off the ground, the “modernist” Havana Park (constructed in 1952)...

  6. Part III. Conflict
    • 9 Utopia/Dystopia: Art and Downtown Development in Los Angeles
      9 Utopia/Dystopia: Art and Downtown Development in Los Angeles (pp. 209-233)
      Marina Peterson

      The day began and ended with the LAPD. A morning interview with the captain of the Central City Division of the Los Angeles Police Department extended into the afternoon as I was introduced to one and then another police officer, the last the head of the beat patrol for the Skid Row area, on a mission to defend policing tactics against what he described as attacks by “activists.” An interview moved into a walk around Skid Row during which, he assured me, I could ask people anything I wanted. On the street, however, he would approach homeless people he knew...

    • 10 “Slum-Free Mumbai” and Other Entrepreneurial Strategies in the Making of Mumbai’s Global Downtown
      10 “Slum-Free Mumbai” and Other Entrepreneurial Strategies in the Making of Mumbai’s Global Downtown (pp. 234-252)
      Liza Weinstein

      In late 2004, the municipal government of Mumbai,¹ carrying out orders from the state’s chief minister, undertook a massive demolition campaign to clear the city’s unregulated slums and squatter settlements. During the four-month campaign, government bulldozers dismantled hutments built along roads and railways and on “open” plots of land throughout the city. In the process, they demolished an estimated 90,000 homes and displaced upward of 400,000 people (Mahadevia and Narayanan 2008b; Weinstein and Ren 2009). Responding to criticism, state officials defended the campaign as necessary to improve the city’s quality of life and bolster its competitive position. “The proliferation of...

    • 11 Downtown as Brand, Downtown as Land: Urban Elites and Neoliberal Development in Contemporary New York City
      11 Downtown as Brand, Downtown as Land: Urban Elites and Neoliberal Development in Contemporary New York City (pp. 253-272)
      Julian Brash

      On Monday, July 6, 2005, the New York Public Authority Control Board (PACB) took a fateful vote. This obscure governmental body, its members appointed by the governor and the leaders of the two houses of the state legislature, held the power to approve—or deny—the public borrowing necessary to fund the New York Sports and Convention Center, or as it was better known in the city, the west side stadium. The stadium, to be built over rail yards owned by a public authority, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), would occupy three large blocks on Manhattan’s Hudson River waterfront. It...

    • 12 Beside Downtown: Global Chinatowns
      12 Beside Downtown: Global Chinatowns (pp. 273-296)
      Gary W. McDonogh and Cindy Hing-Yuk Wong

      For much of the nineteenth and twentieth century, in Barcelona’s barrio chino/barri xino, decaying tenements and crowded streets housed thousands of immigrant workers slaving in aging factories or seeking day-to-day opportunities at the nearby port. Only the broad, tree-lined Rambles, a promenade beloved of flâneurs, separated the middling classes and elites of the historic city center from this “Chinatown” (this boulevard, in fact, had replaced an earlier urban wall). After dark, however, exotic nocturnal amusements including prostitution, drugs, and gambling lured adventurous bourgeois men, bohemian artists, journalists, and even transnational revolutionaries into the barrio chino. In the twenty-first century, nonetheless,...

  7. NOTES
    NOTES (pp. 297-310)
  8. BIBLIOGRAPHY
    BIBLIOGRAPHY (pp. 311-344)
  9. List of Contributors
    List of Contributors (pp. 345-348)
  10. INDEX
    INDEX (pp. 349-358)
  11. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
    ACKNOWLEDGMENTS (pp. 359-360)
University of Pennsylvania Press logo