Who Gets a Childhood?

Who Gets a Childhood?: Race and Juvenile Justice in Twentieth-Century Texas

WILLIAM S. BUSH
Copyright Date: 2010
Pages: 276
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt46nm2g
  • Cite this Item
  • Book Info
    Who Gets a Childhood?
    Book Description:

    Using Texas as a case study for understanding change in the American juvenile justice system over the past century, William S. Bush tells the story of three cycles of scandal, reform, and retrenchment, each of which played out in ways that tended to extend the privileges of a protected childhood to white middle- and upper-class youth, while denying those protections to blacks, Latinos, and poor whites. On the forefront of both progressive and "get tough" reform campaigns, Texas has led national policy shifts in the treatment of delinquent youth to a surprising degree. Changes in the legal system have included the development of courts devoted exclusively to young offenders, the expanded legal application of psychological expertise, and the rise of the children's rights movement. At the same time, broader cultural ideas about adolescence have also changed. Yet Bush demonstrates that as the notion of the teenager gained currency after World War II, white, middle-class teen criminals were increasingly depicted as suffering from curable emotional disorders even as the rate of incarceration rose sharply for black, Latino, and poor teens. Bush argues that despite the struggles of reformers, child advocates, parents, and youths themselves to make juvenile justice live up to its ideal of offering young people a second chance, the story of twentieth-century juvenile justice in large part boils down to "the exclusion of poor and nonwhite youth from modern categories of childhood and adolescence."

    eISBN: 978-0-8203-3762-3
    Subjects: History, Law, Sociology

Table of Contents

  1. Front Matter
    (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    (pp. vii-viii)
  3. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
    (pp. ix-xi)
  4. [Map]
    (pp. xii-xii)
  5. Introduction. Race, Childhood, and Juvenile Justice History
    (pp. 1-6)

    On February 16, 2007, an article on the Texas Observer Web site exposed a gruesome sex abuse scandal at the West Texas State School, a juvenile corrections facility in the remote town of Pyote, near Odessa. Over the next several weeks, news reports revealed that the school’s assistant superintendent, Ray Brookins, and its principal, John Paul Hernandez, had coerced sexual favors from several juvenile inmates over a period of at least two years. Compounding the alleged crime was an inexplicably slow response from authorities. Between December 2003 and February 2005, staff complaints about Brookins’s and Hernandez’s suspicious behavior had fallen...

  6. ONE The Other Lost Generation: Reform and Resistance in the Juvenile Training Schools, 1907–1929
    (pp. 7-41)

    In February 1927, Jimmy Jones, a sixteen-year-old inmate at the Texas State Juvenile Training School in Gatesville, convinced two parolees to smuggle letters to his father out of the institution.¹ Jimmy’s odyssey into Texas juvenile justice had begun the previous October, when he was charged with “highway robbery with firearms.”² That day, after working on the family farm, Jimmy had gone on a drinking excursion into the nearest town, San Marcos, just south of Austin. Armed with his father’s revolver, an intoxicated Jimmy “went up the road a few miles, held up five Mexican men, got one dollar out of...

  7. TWO Socializing Delinquency: Child Welfare, Mental Health, and the Critique of Institutions, 1929–1949
    (pp. 42-70)

    On September 1, 1941, the Texas Board of Control simultaneously fired the superintendents of both the boys’ and the girls’ training schools. The move came in the aftermath of yet another round of abuse scandals, which had resulted in legislative investigations and bad publicity in the late 1930s. However, the immediate cause for the firings was the publication of two audit reports commissioned by the TBC, which portrayed both schools as little more than prisons. Observers with long memories surely would have found the reports’ descriptions depressingly familiar. The auditor summed up Gatesville’s “entire atmosphere” as “one of prison and...

  8. THREE Juvenile Rehabilitation and the Color Line: The Training School for Black Delinquent Girls, 1943–1950
    (pp. 71-92)

    At the very moment when the training schools were coming under attack in Texas, a decades-long push to open an institution for black delinquent girls finally achieved success with the opening of the Brady State School for Negro Girls in 1947. Located at a reconverted German prisoner-of-war camp in west central Texas, the Brady school appeared to respond in part to calls for equal treatment for delinquent black girls. Despite the publicized abuses of juvenile inmates over the years, civil rights groups had feared that for some female offenders, the alternative to institutionalization was much worse. Girls who committed violent...

  9. FOUR James Dean and Jim Crow: The Failure of Reform and the Racialization of Delinquency in the 1950s
    (pp. 93-125)

    On February 6, 1949, Texas Governor Beauford H. Jester and the seven members of the Texas Training School Code Commission held a much-anticipated press conference in Austin (see figure 8). After eighteen months of study, the commission had written a bill that proposed to go far beyond its original mandate to repair the state’s broken juvenile training schools. With great fanfare, it announced plans for “the most extensive youth program ever developed” in Texas, the South, the Southwest, and even the nation.¹ The legislation would create a new state agency, the Texas State Youth Development Council (TSYDC), tasked with overseeing...

  10. FIVE “Hard to Reach”: The Politics of Delinquency Prevention in Postwar Houston
    (pp. 126-149)

    On the afternoon of December 6, 1956, representatives from Houston’s juvenile court met with the TSYDC board in Austin. It was a moment of crisis for the TSYDC. Several of its key administrative personnel had resigned in recent months, while the Gatesville superintendent, Herman Sapier, had asked to be relieved of his duties. Much of the discussion that morning had revolved around a proposal in the legislature to shutter the agency permanently. The board had voted to make James Turman the new executive director of the TSYDC to better represent the agency before the legislature. Turman had accepted the board’s...

  11. SIX Circling the Wagons: The Struggle over the Texas Youth Council, 1965–1971
    (pp. 150-172)

    On March 22, 1961, Bert Kruger Smith, a consultant with the Hogg Foundation for Mental Health at the University of Texas, took a guided tour of the Gatesville State Schools for Boys training school complex.¹ To her own surprise, Smith was generally impressed with what she saw. Although overcrowding remained a problem, seven distinct units housed and schooled boy inmates according to age, behavior, and intelligence. Modern-looking buildings with sparkling clean interiors outnumbered the (still in use) crumbling wood and brick structures built in the previous century. Teachers, guards, and administrators appeared more patient and competent than Gatesville’s prior reputation...

  12. SEVEN Creating a Right to Treatment: Morales v. Turman, 1971–1988
    (pp. 173-202)

    In July 1971, each of the TYC’S roughly 2,500 training school inmates received a sealed envelope. In it were a questionnaire and a cover letter from Judge William Wayne Justice, of the Eastern District of Texas, presiding in the case of Morales v. Turman. The letter explained that the TYC was standing trial and requested that inmates complete the enclosed survey. Inmates were assured that their responses would be kept confidential, in keeping with the court’s interest in protecting their “legal rights.”¹ The questions focused on whether inmates had received a court hearing or counsel before being committed to TYC...

  13. Epilogue. The New American Dilemma
    (pp. 203-208)

    The summer of 2002 found the state of Texas far removed from the reforms envisioned in Morales v. Turman. Instead, the state had attracted bitter condemnations from national and international critics for its administration of the death penalty to juvenile offenders. That summer, the state executed three African American men—Napoleon Beazley, T.J. Jones, and Toronto Patterson—for crimes they had committed at the age of seventeen. Of the three, Beazley’s case provoked the deepest soul-searching, largely because his case defied practically every stereotype about “super-predators” who kill without conscience. Beazley hailed from a two-parent, middle-class household in Grapeland, an...

  14. NOTES
    (pp. 209-254)
  15. INDEX
    (pp. 255-258)
  16. Back Matter
    (pp. 259-259)