No Cover Image
National-Level Spatial Planning in Democratic Countries: An International Comparison of City and Regional Policy-Making
Edited by RACHELLE ALTERMAN
Series: TPR Town Planning Review Special Studies
Volume: 4
Copyright Date: 2001
Edition: 1
Published by: Liverpool University Press
Pages: 302
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt5vjfcw
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
National-Level Spatial Planning in Democratic Countries
Book Description:

National-level spatial planning in democratic countries has been all but ignored by researchers in urban and regional planning since the reconstruction years following World War II. Being synonymous for many with repressive regimes and coercive government practices, national-level planning also fell into some disrepute. A set of specially commissioned papers from leading researchers has produced this challenging and comprehensive study of current national-level planning in ten countries of the developed world. Challenging common assumptions, this comparative international study finds that there seems to be a modest trend whereby, on the threshold of the 21st century, national-level planning has grown in importance in democratic, advanced-economy countries.

eISBN: 978-1-84631-363-9
Subjects: Political Science
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. vii-viii)
  3. LIST OF FIGURES
    LIST OF FIGURES (pp. ix-ix)
  4. LIST OF TABLES
    LIST OF TABLES (pp. x-x)
  5. PREFACE
    PREFACE (pp. xi-xii)
    Rachelle Alterman
  6. ABOUT THE CONTRIBUTORS
    ABOUT THE CONTRIBUTORS (pp. xiii-xiv)
  7. ONE NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING IN DEMOCRATIC COUNTRIES: A COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE
    ONE NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING IN DEMOCRATIC COUNTRIES: A COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE (pp. 1-42)
    Rachelle Alterman

    National-level planning in democratic countries has been almost all but ignored by researchers in urban and regional planning since the reconstruction years following the Second World War. Having become identified in many people’s eyes with communist regimes and coercive government practices, national-level planning fell into some disrepute. Yet, this book will show that planning is carried out on the national level to some degree in each and every one of the ten countries studied, even though the goals, degree of comprehensiveness, subjects, institutions, format, powers and effectiveness differ widely from country to country. There are even modest trends whereby, on...

  8. TWO NATIONAL LAND-USE PLANNING AND REGULATION IN THE UNITED STATES: UNDERSTANDING ITS FUNDAMENTAL IMPORTANCE
    TWO NATIONAL LAND-USE PLANNING AND REGULATION IN THE UNITED STATES: UNDERSTANDING ITS FUNDAMENTAL IMPORTANCE (pp. 43-64)
    Jerold S. Kayden

    Listed in order of importance, three levels of government in the United States exercise legal authority over land-use planning and regulation: the local level, the state level, and the national level. This article addresses the least important, the national level, concluding that the national government fundamentally does not practisede jureorde factonational land-use planning and regulation as that term would be specified and understood internationally. Instead, local governments and, increasingly, state governments play the dominant role in making and administering plans and regulations affecting the use of land.

    Although not the generator of an orchestrated comprehensive national...

  9. THREE STRUCTURES FOR POLICY-MAKING AND THE IMPLEMENTATION OF PLANNING IN THE REPUBLIC OF IRELAND
    THREE STRUCTURES FOR POLICY-MAKING AND THE IMPLEMENTATION OF PLANNING IN THE REPUBLIC OF IRELAND (pp. 65-84)
    Michael J. Bannon and Paula Russell

    With a land area of 70282 square kilometres and a population of 3.62 million people, the Republic of Ireland is both one of the smallest and one of the least densely populated member states of the European Union. In European terms the country has been relatively poor and it constitutes a single Objective I region for assistance under EU structural funding programmes (i.e. less than 75 per cent of EU average per capita gross domestic product [GDP] in 1993).

    Traditionally a predominantly rural society with a high dependence on agriculture, the country has undergone major economic and social transformations since...

  10. FOUR RETHINKING SWEDISH NATIONAL PLANNING
    FOUR RETHINKING SWEDISH NATIONAL PLANNING (pp. 85-104)
    Göran Cars and Bjorn Hårsman

    The Kingdom of Sweden is the fourth largest country in Europe in terms of land area. Ten per cent of the land is cultivated and 50 per cent is covered by forest. The population is close to nine million, with a density of slightly more than 20 inhabitants per square kilometre. This low population density and the abundance of timber resources may lead one to expect sprawling settlements and spacious wooden single-family houses. This is, however, not the case. The population is largely concentrated in the metropolitan areas of Stockholm on the east coast, Gothenburg in the west and Malmö...

  11. FIVE NATIONAL-LEVEL INSTITUTIONS AND DECISION-MAKING PROCESSES FOR SPATIAL PLANNING IN THE UNITED KINGDOM
    FIVE NATIONAL-LEVEL INSTITUTIONS AND DECISION-MAKING PROCESSES FOR SPATIAL PLANNING IN THE UNITED KINGDOM (pp. 105-126)
    Malcolm Grant

    The United Kingdom has no national spatial plan for its land use. In this respect at least, it resembles the USA, and its current practice is distinctly different from those countries—like Israel and Japan—which do prepare, adopt and attempt to implement national plans. But, as this paper will attempt to demonstrate, these are distinctions which are not as sharp as they might first appear. There are indeed national-level institutions, and a well-established set of decision-making processes for spatial planning, in the United Kingdom. What is different is the relationship between central government and local government in the conduct...

  12. SIX NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING INSTITUTIONS AND DECISIONS IN THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY
    SIX NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING INSTITUTIONS AND DECISIONS IN THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY (pp. 127-147)
    Gerd Schmidt-Eichstaedt

    The Federal Republic of Germany (FRG) is a federation with 16Länder(states) and over 16000 municipalities which have strong, constitutionally guaranteed powers of self-government. The German spatial planning system is typical of north European planning systems in which there is a hierarchy of authorities, each producing planning instruments, based on a system of participation and consensus. In the German spatial planning system, the laws embody the principles for planning, and some of the plans, particularly at the local level, can also be laws.

    An important feature of the German system is the constitution, theGrundgesetz, in which responsibilities are...

  13. SEVEN NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING IN THE DANISH SYSTEM
    SEVEN NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING IN THE DANISH SYSTEM (pp. 148-167)
    Stig Enemark and Ib Jorgensen

    Denmark covers a land area of 43000 square kilometres, not including the self-governing regions of Greenland and the Faroe Islands. The country’s population is 5.2 million, of which one-third lives in the capital region—Greater Copenhagen. Sixty-seven per cent of the country is devoted to agriculture, 12 per cent to forests, 11 per cent to semi-natural areas and 10 per cent to urban zones and transport installations.

    The first Danish town planning act was passed in 1925. It was, however, not widely applied because the planning regulations entailed an economic risk since the municipal councils were held responsible for paying...

  14. EIGHT NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING INSTITUTIONS AND DECISION-MAKING IN FRANCE
    EIGHT NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING INSTITUTIONS AND DECISION-MAKING IN FRANCE (pp. 168-196)
    Gérard Marcou

    After the Second World War, France developed an economic planning system based on a wide industrial public sector and financial and regulatory instruments targeted at private firms. This reflected the leading role of the state in the economy and in society. The policy ofaménagement du territoire(regional development planning) emerged in the early 1950s to support regional economic development, to balance the dominance of Paris and to develop backward regions. The economic planning system and the policy ofaménagement du territoireeach gave rise to specific government institutions which were responsible to the head of government—the Commissariat Général...

  15. NINE NATIONAL-LEVEL ECONOMIC AND SPATIAL PLANNING IN JAPAN
    NINE NATIONAL-LEVEL ECONOMIC AND SPATIAL PLANNING IN JAPAN (pp. 197-218)
    Paul H. Tanimura and David W. Edgington

    Japan comprises four main islands, Hokkaido, Honshu, Shikoku and Kyushu which, together with more than 6800 small islands, have a land area of 377800 square kilometres (Fig. 1). Japan’s population, at some 125 million, is ranked seventh in the world and second in the OECD (Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development), and it now has the highest standard of living as measured by its per capita GNP (Foreign Press Centre Japan, 1996). The density levels of population per habitable hectare and GDP per habitable hectare are the highest in the world. These indicators point to the scarcity of habitable land...

  16. TEN DUTCH NATIONAL PLANNING AT THE TURNING POINT: RETHINKING INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS
    TEN DUTCH NATIONAL PLANNING AT THE TURNING POINT: RETHINKING INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS (pp. 219-256)
    Hans (J. M.) Mastop

    The Dutch like the idea that foreigners visiting the Netherlands are more often than not impressed by the fact that the country looks tidy, clean and well organised. Needham (1989), speaks of a ‘manicured environment’. Dutch spatial planners like to think that they have contributed to that manicured environment and that they have ‘planned’ its development. But Needham warns the reader: ‘although there is massive public intervention with changing and maintaining the physical environment, and that massive public intervention indeed results in an overall good or even high quality, one would be wrong to include this under the planning system,...

  17. ELEVEN NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING IN ISRAEL: WALKING THE TIGHTROPE BETWEEN GOVERNMENT CONTROL AND PRIVATISATION
    ELEVEN NATIONAL-LEVEL PLANNING IN ISRAEL: WALKING THE TIGHTROPE BETWEEN GOVERNMENT CONTROL AND PRIVATISATION (pp. 257-290)
    Rachelle Alterman

    Compared with most other Western countries, Israel has maintained a very high dosage of national-level planning institutions and powers. This is not surprising. Given Israel’s unique constraints and national goals, it should be a ‘natural’ for national-level planning. Yet, as our story will show, these institutions have not always functioned to the same degree or held the same status.

    The exposition of national-level planning in Israel begins with an introduction to Israel’s ‘vital statistics’ and built-up form. Next comes a section that introduces the key national urban and regional policies in order to give the reader a feel for the...

Liverpool University Press logo