How Think Tanks Shape Social Development Policies
How Think Tanks Shape Social Development Policies
James G. McGann
Anna Viden
Jillian Rafferty
Copyright Date: 2014
Published by: University of Pennsylvania Press
Pages: 416
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt6wr8nq
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
How Think Tanks Shape Social Development Policies
Book Description:

Across the globe, there are more than four thousand policy institutes, or think tanks, that research or advocate for economic and social development. Yet the relationship between these organizations and the policies they influence is not well understood.How Think Tanks Shape Social Development Policiesexamines case studies drawn from a range of political and economic systems worldwide to provide a detailed understanding of how think tanks can have an impact on issues such as education policy, infrastructure, environment and sustainable development, economic reform, poverty alleviation, agricultural and land development, and social policy.Each chapter provides an overview of the approaches and organizational structures of specific think tanks, as well as the political, economic, and social opportunities and the challenges of the environments in which they operate. The contributors study the stages of innovative think-tank-aided strategies implemented in highly industrialized world powers like the United States and Russia, emerging countries such as China, India, Brazil, and South Korea, and developing nations that include Ethiopia, Kenya, and Tanzania. Accompanied by an extensive introduction to contextualize the history and theory of policy institutes, this comprehensive comparison of policy success stories will be instructive and transferable to other think tanks around the globe.Contributors:Assefa Admassie, Celso Castro, Kristina Costa, Francisco Cravioto, Marek Dabrowski, Matt Dann, He Fan, Rajeev Gowda, Oh-Seok Hyun, Christian Koch, Jitinder Kohli, R. Andreas Kraemer, Elena Lazarou, William Lyakurwa, Ashwin Mahesh, Florencia Mezzadra, Partha Mukhopadhyay, Mcebisi Ndletyana, Sridhar Pabbisetty, Miguel Pulido, Marco Aurelio Ruediger, María Belén Sánchez, Dmitri Trenin, Samuel Wangwe, Vanesa Weyrauch, Maria Monica Wihardja, Rebecca Winthrop, Wang Xiaoyi.

eISBN: 978-0-8122-0962-4
Subjects: Political Science
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. v-viii)
  3. Preface
    Preface (pp. ix-xii)
  4. Introduction: Social Development, Think Tanks, and Policy Advice
    Introduction: Social Development, Think Tanks, and Policy Advice (pp. 1-62)

    Governments, developmental organizations, and individuals are closer than ever before to a consensus about the appropriate strategy to development. This is attributable to the recent and ongoing crises that have exposed the depth of human insecurity and the inadequacy of reforms put in place over the past three decades to create sustainable and equitable growth, or to move poor countries and populations on to a stable development trajectory.¹

    The path leading to today’s consensus began in the years after World War II with a development strategy focused purely on economic growth. Increased output and growth maximization were thought to be...

  5. Part I. Education
    • Chapter 1 Brookings Institution: The Case for Global Education
      Chapter 1 Brookings Institution: The Case for Global Education (pp. 65-75)
      Rebecca Winthrop

      The case for education, as expressed in the quotation above from a Sudanese refugee, is simple. First and foremost, education is a fundamental human right and the birthright of every child. It is also the springboard for human development, creating the conditions for progress in health and gender equity; it plays a key role in helping to tackle some of the world’s pressing challenges such as climate change, food security, and peace building. Economic growth and poverty reduction depend on an educated and skilled workforce. In developing countries, one additional year of education adds about 10 percent to a person’s...

    • Chapter 2 CIPPEC: The Monitoring Project for the Law on Educational Funding
      Chapter 2 CIPPEC: The Monitoring Project for the Law on Educational Funding (pp. 76-94)
      Florencia Mazzadra, Vanesa Weyrauch and María Belén Sánchez

      After almost a decade of authoritarian rule, Argentina’s return to democracy in 1983 coincided with a new discourse on the protection of human rights and economic development based on the importance of education as a means of economic progress. During the 1980s, the Radical Party organized a National Congress of Education in order to democratically plan the educational policy. However, the congress failed to translate the discourse into concrete actions. In 1993, under a Peronist government, deep educational reform was finally implemented through the Federal Law of Education. Among other provisions, the law established that the investment in education should...

  6. Part II. Infrastructure
    • Chapter 3 Centre for Public Policy (CPP): Indian Institute of Management Bangalore
      Chapter 3 Centre for Public Policy (CPP): Indian Institute of Management Bangalore (pp. 97-108)
      Rajeev Gowda, Ashwin Mahesh and Sridhar Pabbisetty

      This chapter examines the impact of the Centre for Public Policy (CPP) on public policy in India through a specific case study. CPP is part of the Indian Institute of Management Bangalore, one of India’s leading business schools. CPP is a think tank engaged in research, consultancy, teaching, training, and outreach. CPP was established in 2000 to address the gap between research and public policymaking in India through a collaborative effort between the Department of Personnel and Training, the government of India, the United Nations Development Programme, and the institute. The CPP also received an endowment grant from the government...

    • Chapter 4 Centre for Policy Research (CPR): Reforming the Urban Transit System in Delhi
      Chapter 4 Centre for Policy Research (CPR): Reforming the Urban Transit System in Delhi (pp. 109-126)
      Partha Mukhopadhyay

      This chapter looks at the reform of the urban transit system in Delhi, the capital of India, specifically the manner in which bus services are provided. Buses, in 2006, when this intervention occurred, accounted for 60 percent of all vehicular trips in Delhi. The chapter emphasizes the role of civil society, working through the media and the courts in highlighting the issue. It also details the various political balances that had to be struck in crafting a solution. The chapter begins with a short reiteration of the importance of urban transport within a broader agenda of sustainable growth. The impact...

  7. Part III. Environment and Sustainable Development
    • Chapter 5 The Ecologic Institute and Its Influence on Policies in Germany and the EU
      Chapter 5 The Ecologic Institute and Its Influence on Policies in Germany and the EU (pp. 129-147)
      R. Andreas Kraemer

      The Ecologic Institute, founded in 1995, is an internationally minded, private-initiative, nongovernmental, and nonprofit organization. Based in Berlin, Germany, and with a policy office in Brussels, Ecologic is very active at the European Union (EU) level. In 2008, the institute was also formally established in the United States as an IRC 501c3 public charity, with its main office in Washington, D.C., and a project office in San Mateo, California.

      The Ecologic Institute covers the full range of policy challenges on environment and the movement toward sustainability, in developed and developing countries alike. It provides policy responses to the environmental and...

    • Chapter 6 MISTRA: Configuring Research Teams to Realize Policy Influence
      Chapter 6 MISTRA: Configuring Research Teams to Realize Policy Influence (pp. 148-161)
      Mcebisi Ndletyana

      The extent to which think tanks are able to exert policy influence is a function of their access, credibility, and timing. Each variable is critical in its own right, but may be insufficient alone. A think tank may have access to policymakers, for instance, but lack credibility because of an apparent ideological bias on the part of the institution (or on account of the poor quality of the products). In such instances, policymakers may doubt the relevance or sincerity of the policy advice or simply ignore it. The timing may also render what might in fact be sound and credible...

    • Chapter 7 Gulf Research Center (GRC): Promoting Social Development in the Arab Gulf Region
      Chapter 7 Gulf Research Center (GRC): Promoting Social Development in the Arab Gulf Region (pp. 162-172)
      Christian Koch

      The emergence and role of think tanks and research institutes located in the Arab Gulf states (this refers to the member states of the Gulf Cooperation Council, or GCC, states and includes Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates) is relatively new and as such is underdeveloped. A closely related point is that the overall status of civil society in these countries is weak as virtually all aspects of political decision making reside within the ruling monarchies and a handful of other political and economic elites. Civil society organizations do exist but their function is limited...

  8. Part IV. Economic Reform, Debt Crisis Management, and Economic Coordination
    • Chapter 8 Bruegel: Creating Your Own Luck
      Chapter 8 Bruegel: Creating Your Own Luck (pp. 175-184)
      Matt Dann

      “It’s the economy, stupid.” This phrase, which was repeated like a mantra during the presidential elections in 1992, helped Bill Clinton defeat his Republican rival, George H. W. Bush.¹ The message still holds true in the context of the European financial crisis, which has ravaged Europe since 2009. Economics and politics are intrinsically linked in the sense that the electorate has expectations for the future including public services and welfare. Such services are often taken for granted in Western democracies. However, in the European Union (EU), politics is standing in the way of viable economic solutions. This is detrimental to...

    • Chapter 9 Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS): Shaping Development Policy in a Globalized World
      Chapter 9 Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS): Shaping Development Policy in a Globalized World (pp. 185-199)
      Maria Monica Wihardja

      Indonesia’s economy has been growing at a relatively rapid rate—in December 2011, amid the economic turbulence in the United States and Europe, Indonesia grew at 6.5 percent. In 2012, it was projected to grow at a rate between 6. 2 and 6.8 percent. Strong investment growth and domestic consumption offset weak export demand. This sound growth rate is needed for a developing country such as Indonesia. Sound economic growth and other macroeconomic indicators, including robust growth of credit, a low fiscal deficit, and the debt-to-GDP ratio, and sound banking indicators are not ends in themselves but also, and most...

    • Chapter 10 Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS): Reshaping China’s Development Strategy
      Chapter 10 Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS): Reshaping China’s Development Strategy (pp. 200-212)
      He Fan

      The past two decades witnessed the rapid expansion of the Chinese economy. But China’s economic development is unbalanced and unsustainable in the long run. Rebalancing the Chinese economy has gradually become one of the priorities on the agenda of Chinese policymakers. Many think tanks in China have been involved in this policy change. The Institute of World Economics and Politics (IWEP) within the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) plays a unique and important role in this process.

      This chapter documents IWEP’s involvement in three stages to reshape China’s development strategy. In the stage of policy discussion, IWEP led the...

    • Chapter 11 Center for Social and Economic Research (CASE): Think Tanks in the Era of Globalization
      Chapter 11 Center for Social and Economic Research (CASE): Think Tanks in the Era of Globalization (pp. 213-230)
      Marek Dabrowski

      This chapter analyzes new challenges and opportunities faced by think tanks in the face of globalization, particularly in the economic and social policy spheres. Globalization has made the entire world more integrated, with an increasing number of economic, social, and political issues becoming of international importance. As result, economic and social research, analyses, policy advice, and policy advocacy increasingly must address supranational challenges. This supposes that a transformation has to take place among think tanks, which traditionally have focused on national policymaking agendas and competition in the national markets of ideas. This transformation affects various aspects of think tank business:...

    • Chapter 12 Korea Development Institute (KDI): Korean Service Sector Advancement
      Chapter 12 Korea Development Institute (KDI): Korean Service Sector Advancement (pp. 231-246)
      Oh-Seok Hyun

      In March 1971, the Korea Development Institute (KDI) was established as a government-funded research center under a strong commitment by then President Park Chung Hee. Its aim was to develop and propose plans for Korea’s economic and social progress, hence contributing to the prosperity of the national economy. As the first Korean research institute in the social sciences, KID actively used experts in each area, thus contributing to the development of the nation’s Five-Year Plan for Economic and Social Development. KDI then took part directly and indirectly in the development of economic policies. By proposing leading alternatives to existing national...

  9. Part V. Agriculture and Land Development
    • Chapter 13 Fundar and Subsidios al Campo: Farm Subsidy Policy in Mexico
      Chapter 13 Fundar and Subsidios al Campo: Farm Subsidy Policy in Mexico (pp. 249-261)
      Miguel Pulido and Francisco Cravioto

      Fundar’s Subsidios al Campo project makes extensive use of the Federal Transparency and Access to Government Public Information Law to provide evidence about how federal monies allotted to farm subsidies are distributed among rural producers. This chapter draws most of its information from the report published by Fundar’s main researcher involved in the Subsidios al Campo project, Ana Joaquina Ruiz Guerra, as well as Guillermo M. Cejudo’s account of this experience. Among the project’s findings, the concentration of these subsidies among the country’s biggest rural producers stands out prominently. This finding raises important concerns, since poverty affects a large percentage...

    • Chapter 14 Ethiopian Economics Association: Stories of Social and Economic Policy Influence
      Chapter 14 Ethiopian Economics Association: Stories of Social and Economic Policy Influence (pp. 262-270)
      Assefa Admassie

      Ethiopia is relatively rich in natural resources, with reasonably diverse agroclimatic regimes, good resource potential for development including agricultural resources, huge biodiversity, abundant water resources, minerals, and others. However, in spite of this potential, Ethiopia is a very poor country. Nearly one-third of the population lives in severe poverty. Constraints ranging from internal wars and conflicts, inappropriate policies, and structural conditions to external factors have contributed to the dismal performance of the Ethiopian economy during the various regimes. The wars and conflicts that took place in Ethiopia have consumed significant resources and have destroyed the economic base of the country....

    • Chapter 15 CRESS: The Grassroots Perspective and Policymaking
      Chapter 15 CRESS: The Grassroots Perspective and Policymaking (pp. 271-286)
      Wang Xiaoyi

      As the ecosystem that occupies the largest land area of China, grassland accounts for 40 percent of the territory. It is found mainly in two ecologically sensitive areas—the Tibetan Plateau and the arid-semiarid area of northern China, both of which have a significant impact on China’s ecosystem. Since the 1990s, the majority of China’s grasslands has significantly degraded. Research carried out at the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences Planning Institute shows that the degradation rate of grassland in northern China was 51 percent in the early 1990s, and had reached 62 percent by the late 1990s.¹ According to statistics...

  10. Part VI. Poverty Alleviation
    • Chapter 16 African Economic Research Consortium (AERC): Shaping the Policy Making Process and Its Outcomes
      Chapter 16 African Economic Research Consortium (AERC): Shaping the Policy Making Process and Its Outcomes (pp. 289-298)
      William Lyakurwa

      The African Economic Research Consortium (AERC) model is not a result of a preconceived design; rather, its structure has evolved over the past quarter century in light of operational experience. The AERC was established in 1988 with the aim of strengthening African capacity to conduct rigorous, independent research bearing on economic policy. Its mission is to strengthen local capacity for conducting such inquiries into problems facing the management of economies and to facilitate evidence-based policymaking in sub-Saharan Africa. It also promotes the maintenance of such capacity and encourages its application in the policy context. AERC was established under the Delaware...

    • Chapter 17 Research on Poverty Alleviation (REPOA): Think Tanks and Social Development Policy in Tanzania
      Chapter 17 Research on Poverty Alleviation (REPOA): Think Tanks and Social Development Policy in Tanzania (pp. 299-306)
      Samuel Wangwe

      Research on Poverty Alleviation (REPOA) is a nongovernmental organization in Tanzania, which was formed in 1994 and commenced operations in 1995. REPOA seeks to deepen the understanding of and inform future policy on the causes, extent, and nature of poverty, and to establish strategies to combat its spread throughout the country. Tanzania being one of the poorest countries in the world, REPOA considers research to be central to understanding the poverty challenge as a development challenge. In addition, research is a vehicle for developing broad-based knowledge that can be used to make decisions and design realistic and effective evidence-based interventions....

  11. Part VII. Social Policy
    • Chapter 18 Center for American Progress: Importing Social Impact Bonds
      Chapter 18 Center for American Progress: Importing Social Impact Bonds (pp. 309-321)
      Jitinder Kohli and Kristina Costa

      The Center for American Progress (CAP) was founded in 2003 to be a different kind of think tank—one dedicated to developing and promoting a progressive policy agenda across a wide range of issues. Like that of all think tanks, the primary goal of CAP is to produce original research on pressing policy issues. Half of the center’s resources are dedicated to providing leadership in analysis of progressive ideas, with the other half devoted to ensuring that those ideas gain traction in the public sphere. Beyond producing written materials, hosting public and private events, and providing expert speakers at conferences...

    • Chapter 19 Carnegie Moscow Center: Russia’s Social Development—A Continuing Story
      Chapter 19 Carnegie Moscow Center: Russia’s Social Development—A Continuing Story (pp. 322-332)
      Dmitri Trenin

      Work at the Carnegie Moscow Center (CMC) has been and remains an adventure. The organization’s story is one of a notable contribution to Russian social development in a key area of policy research and intellectual debate. The CMC was founded under a decree signed by President Boris Yeltsin in 1992. To prepare ground for the CMC founding, the field office began its work in Moscow in 1993, and the first scholars were recruited in 1994, when the center became operational. Since the early to mid- 1990s, the CMC has witnessed an uneven evolution of Russian politics, from Yeltsin to Vladimir...

    • Chapter 20 Fundação Getúlio Vargas and PRONASCI: A Study of Brazilian Think Tanks
      Chapter 20 Fundação Getúlio Vargas and PRONASCI: A Study of Brazilian Think Tanks (pp. 333-342)
      Celso Castro, Elena Lazarou and Marco Aurelio Ruediger

      This chapter demonstrates how the Fundação Getulio Vargas (FGV) has influenced an important policy issue fundamental to the social development of contemporary Brazil—the national Public Security with Citizenship (PRONASCI) program launched in 2008 by the Ministry of Justice. It also explains how FGV’s strategy, structure, and resources contributed to its ability to successfully address this issue.

      FGV is a private, independent, and nonprofit institution created in 1944 to foster Brazilian development. To accomplish this goal the institution trains qualified personnel for the administration of Brazil’s public and private sectors and produces and advances scientific and technological knowledge for public...

  12. Conclusion: Recommendations for Think Tanks and Policymakers
    Conclusion: Recommendations for Think Tanks and Policymakers (pp. 343-350)

    What can we learn from these chapters? Along what lines can we draw meaningful comparisons among the various case studies, and to what end? Most fundamentally, what structural and contextual conditions make a think tank effective—both generally and in social policy more specifically? How do think tanks respond to the challenges posed by the processes of globalization?

    First and foremost, the case studies in this volume provide a meaningful demonstration of the incredible potential of think tanks to inform and influence policymakers and policy outcomes. In each instance, the hard work of the institution’s dedicated scholars, in combination with...

  13. Contributors
    Contributors (pp. 351-352)
  14. Index
    Index (pp. 353-370)
  15. Acknowledgments
    Acknowledgments (pp. 371-371)
University of Pennsylvania Press logo