The Post-Secular in Question
The Post-Secular in Question: Religion in Contemporary Society
Philip S. Gorski
David Kyuman Kim
John Torpey
Jonathan VanAntwerpen
Copyright Date: 2012
Published by: NYU Press
Pages: 375
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt9qfmzz
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
The Post-Secular in Question
Book Description:

A diverse but very stimulating collection. -- Robert Bellah, author of Religion in Human Evolution: From the Paleolithic to the Axial Age. The Post-Secular in Question considers whether there has in fact been a religious resurgence of global dimensions in recent decades. This collection of original essays by leading academics represents an interdisciplinary intervention in the continuing and ever-transforming discussion of the role of religion and secularism in today's world. Foregrounding the most urgent and compelling questions raised by the place of religion in the social sciences, past and present, The Post-Secular in Question restores religion to a more central place in social scientific thinking about the world, helping to move scholarship beyond unbelief. Contributors: Courtney Bender, Craig Calhoun, Michele Dillon, Philip S. Gorski, Richard Madsen, Kathleen Mahoney, Tomoko Masuzawa, Eduardo Mendieta, John Schmalzbauer, James K. A. Smith, John Torpey, Bryan S. Turner, Hent de Vries.

eISBN: 978-0-8147-3873-3
Subjects: Sociology
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. [i]-[iv])
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. [v]-[vi])
  3. CHAPTER ONE Post-Secular in Question
    CHAPTER ONE Post-Secular in Question (pp. 1-22)
    Philip S. Gorski, David Kyuman Kim, John Torpey and Jonathan VanAntwerpen

    Are we living in a post-secular world? That question has surged onto the academic agenda, marked by the increasing scholarly use of the notion of the “post-secular.” From the writings of Jürgen Habermas on the role of religion in public life to a host of more theoretical reflections on religion in contemporary society, the idea of the post-secular has acquired increasing currency in contemporary academic discussions.¹ The outpouring of books and journal articles on the topic signals an important shift in scholarly thinking about religion and secularism. Yet it should also give us pause; the term has at times been...

  4. 2 What Is Religion? Categorical Reconfigurations in a Global Horizon
    2 What Is Religion? Categorical Reconfigurations in a Global Horizon (pp. 23-42)
    Richard Madsen

    When Matteo Ricci and his Jesuit confreres arrived in China in the late sixteenth century, they encountered an intellectual culture full of sophisticated “teachings” (jiao), elaborated through centuries of scholarly discourse, and a life structured according to meticulously elaborated “rituals” (li). None this fit neatly into the categories these European priests used for articulating the beliefs and practices of their Catholic faith. The “teachings”—which included the teachings of the scholars (what we now call “Confucianism”), teaching of the Dao (which we now call Daoism), and the teachings the Buddha (which we now call Buddhism)—were not necessarily about supernatural...

  5. CHAPTER THREE Thing in Their Entanglements
    CHAPTER THREE Thing in Their Entanglements (pp. 43-76)
    Courtney Bender

    Few aspects of social life seem more entangled within the project of moder­nity than religion. This is evident, if nowhere else, in the current far-rang­ing discussions about religions, the secular, and the post-secular within the social sciences and humanities. But while such entanglements now seem self-evident, this was not the case even fifteen years ago.¹ What has trans­pired to make religion such a lodestone, and such an interesting problematic for the social sciences once more? What, furthermore, might sociology con­tribute to these renewed discussions?² Dewey’s phrases encourage us to con­sider answering this question with an approach that takes religion’s entan­glements...

  6. CHAPTER FOUR Recovered Goods: Durkheimian Sociology as Virtue Ethics
    CHAPTER FOUR Recovered Goods: Durkheimian Sociology as Virtue Ethics (pp. 77-104)
    Philip S. Gorski

    Émile Durkheim envisioned sociology as a “moral science.” Today, this phrase jars the ear. Among sociologists, at least, it is apt to elicit bewilderment, bemusement, denial, or dismissal. “What could Durkheim have possibly meant by it?” “Durkheim was a little woolly-headed, wasn’t he?” “Aren’t ethics and science two quite different enterprises?” “Frankly, what use do we postmoderns have for ‘morality’ anyway?” “What nonsense! You can’t derive an ought from an is!” Yet that is precisely what Durkheim proposed to do—at least sometimes. His goal was not just to study morality scientifically—a goal that at least some contemporary sociologists...

  7. CHAPTER FIVE “Simple Ideas, small Miracles”: The Obama Phenomenon
    CHAPTER FIVE “Simple Ideas, small Miracles”: The Obama Phenomenon (pp. 105-134)
    Hent de Vries

    It needs no proof that the 2008 election of Barack Obama as the forty-fourth president of the United States represented in the eyes of many “a magical transformative moment . . . the symbolic culmination of the black freedom struggle, the grand achievement of a great collective dream,” in other words, seismic event.”¹ And what, mostly in Europe, was called the “Obama effect”—including its, perhaps, inevitable disappointments—has not ceased cause wonder as to the fate of the political in what is not just a post-9/11 of global politics but, in the eyes of many, also the dreamlike, if...

  8. CHAPTER SIX Post-Secular Society: Consumerism and the Democratization of Religion
    CHAPTER SIX Post-Secular Society: Consumerism and the Democratization of Religion (pp. 135-158)
    Bryan S. Turner

    In this chapter I develop a number of critical reflections on the analysis of in both contemporary sociology and social philosophy. This argument has several interconnected components. Sociologists and more especially philosophers have focused too much on religious belief and too little on In this respect, I return to a defense of Émile Durkheim, who can interpreted as saying that belief is always embedded in collective practices that they become problematic and uncertain only when there are major in practice. I set this contrast between philosophical understanding belief and sociological analysis of practice in the context of developing a that...

  9. CHAPTER SEVEN Secular Liturgies and the Prospects for a “Post Secular” Sociology of Religion
    CHAPTER SEVEN Secular Liturgies and the Prospects for a “Post Secular” Sociology of Religion (pp. 159-184)
    James K. A Smith

    In this landmark workIdeas Pertaining to a Pure Phenomenology,Edmund undertook a thought experiment intended as a kind of limit case that elucidate the nature of consciousness. While I have no investment particular claims, the strategy is suggestive. Imagine, Husserl (rather suggested, the complete annihilation of the world. Imagine the utter of materiality: not just buildings and trees, but animals and planets. the obliteration of the earth, the eradication of material stuff, annihilation of our bodies. What would be left? Could consciousness such a catastrophe? Oddly enough, Husserl answered “yes” to such “while the being of consciousness, of any...

  10. CHAPTER EIGHT Secular by Default? Religion and the University bofore the Post-Secular Age
    CHAPTER EIGHT Secular by Default? Religion and the University bofore the Post-Secular Age (pp. 185-214)
    Tomoko Masuzawa

    The questions I explore in this essay stem from an inquiry concerning the advent of the academic secular. While it may seem utterly obvious that the modern research university is secular in its constitution and in its ethos, seldom is this constitution expressly reasoned, nor is its logic clearly articulated. In fact, there is much obscurity surrounding the historical and theoretical grounding of the secularity of the academy. This obscurity could be partly, perhaps greatly, responsible for the present state of loquacious confusion manifest in our generally erratic handling of the subject of religion. For, in the last few decades,...

  11. CHAPTER NINE Religion and Knowledge in the Post-Secular Academy
    CHAPTER NINE Religion and Knowledge in the Post-Secular Academy (pp. 215-248)
    John Schmalzbauer and Kathleen Mahoney

    The university has long been perceived as one of the most secular precincts American society. In the academy and the media, the secularization narrative dominates accounts of religion’s place in higher education.¹ Yet recent suggests that the secularization narrative may have overstated extent to which universities have marginalized the teaching and practice religion. Such scholarship points to the survival and growth of the study of religion as well as the vitality of campus religious life. It what historian Martin Marty dubs “complaints and whimpers” about went wrong with Christian scholarship.”²

    Yet there is strong evidence that something close to the...

  12. CHAPTER TEN Jürgen Habermas and the Post-Secular Appropriation of Religion: A sociological Critique
    CHAPTER TEN Jürgen Habermas and the Post-Secular Appropriation of Religion: A sociological Critique (pp. 249-278)
    Michele Dillon

    Jürgen Habermas is undoubtedly the leading social theorist currently alive. body of work is probably more familiar to philosophers than sociologists, especially in the United States, where there is a long tradition of deep toward abstract theorizing. His writings, nonetheless, along with of the late Pierre Bourdieu and Michel Foucault have provided a tremendous amount of intellectual energy to new generations of sociologists. Frankfurt School tradition of critical theory, Habermas has tackled questions focusing on the nature of, and complications to, participatory in an increasingly bureaucratic and consumer society in which the of capitalism typically push back against and triumph...

  13. CHAPTER ELEVEN Religion and Secularization in the United States and Western Europe
    CHAPTER ELEVEN Religion and Secularization in the United States and Western Europe (pp. 279-306)
    John Torpey

    Largely as a result of the attacks of September 11, 2001, the subject of religion to the Western social science agenda with considerable force. In immediate aftermath of (and obviously prompted by) the attacks, Jürgen argued that we have entered into a “post-secular” age,¹ in which of religion have to be addressed by liberal democracies in a more manner than had been the case theretofore. Meanwhile, Charles has insisted in his celebrated recent bookA Secular Agethat we live in which the intrinsically secularizing “immanent frame” has become reasonable option and perhaps even the “default setting” for many in...

  14. CHAPTER TWELVE Spiritual Politics and Post-Secular Authenticity: Foucault and Habermas on Post-Metaphysical Religion
    CHAPTER TWELVE Spiritual Politics and Post-Secular Authenticity: Foucault and Habermas on Post-Metaphysical Religion (pp. 307-334)
    Eduardo Mendieta

    One of the virtues of Charles Taylor’s work has been to show that we have become secular notagainstreligion butbecauseof religion. Already in his numerous essays, collected in two volumes, Taylor had written about what he called the “expressivist tradition” and the Romantic tradition of valorizing the subjective and inwardness.¹ In his 1989Sources of the Self,Augustine plays a pivotal role in the emergence of this expressivist and Romantic tradition that then gives way to the culture of authenticity.² For Taylor, expressivism and authenticity are inextricably linked to the “moral topography” of inwardness that he claims...

  15. CHAPTER THIRTEEN Time, World, and Secularism
    CHAPTER THIRTEEN Time, World, and Secularism (pp. 335-364)
    Craig Calboun

    Secularism is often treated as a sort of absence. It’s what’s left if religion fades. It’s the exclusion of religion from the public sphere. But then it is seen as somehow in itself neutral. This is misleading. We need to see secularism as a presence. It is something, and therefore not entirely neutral, and in need of elaboration and understanding. It shapes not only religion but also culture more broadly. Whether we see it as an ideology, as a worldview, as a stance toward religion, as a constitutional approach, or as simply an aspect of some other project—of science...

  16. About the Contributors
    About the Contributors (pp. 365-368)
  17. Index
    Index (pp. 369-375)