Ancient Jewish Sciences and the History of Knowledge in Second Temple Literature
Ancient Jewish Sciences and the History of Knowledge in Second Temple Literature
Jonathan Ben-Dov
Seth Sanders
Copyright Date: 2014
Published by: NYU Press
Pages: 275
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt9qfxhq
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Ancient Jewish Sciences and the History of Knowledge in Second Temple Literature
Book Description:

Until very recently, the idea of ancient Jewish sciences would have been considered unacceptable. Since the 1990's, Early Modern and Medieval Science in Jewish sources has been actively studied, but the consensus was that no real scientific themes could be found in earlier Judaism. This work points them out in detail, and posits a new field of research: the scientific activity evident in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Early Jewish Pseudepigrapha. The publication of new texts and new analyses of older ones reveals crucial elements that are best illuminated by the history of science, and may have interesting consequences for it. The contributors evaluate these texts in relation to astronomy, astrology and physiognomy, marking the first comprehensive attempt to account for scientific themes in Second Temple Judaism. They investigate the meaning and purpose of scientific explorations in an apocalyptic setting. An appreciation of these topics paves the way to a renewed understanding of the scientific fragments scattered throughout rabbinic literature. The book first places the Jewish material in the ancient context of the Near Eastern and Hellenistic worlds. While the Jewish texts were not on the cutting edge of scientific discovery, they find a meaningful place in the history of science, between Babylonia and Egypt, in the time period between Hipparchus and Ptolemy. The book uses recent advances in method to examine the contacts and networks of Jewish scholars in their ancient setting. Second, the essays here tackle the problematic concept of a national scientific tradition. Although science is nowadays often conceived as universal, the historiography of ancient Jewish sciences demonstrates the importance of seeing the development of science in a local context. The book explores the tension between the hegemony of central scientific traditions and local scientific enterprises, showing the relevance of ancient data to contemporary postcolonial historiography of science. Finally, philosophical questions of the demarcation of science are addressed in a way that can advance the discussion of related ancient materials.

eISBN: 978-1-4798-7397-5
Subjects: History
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. 1-4)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. 5-6)
  3. Acknowledgments
    Acknowledgments (pp. 7-8)
    Jonathan Ben-Dov and Seth L. Sanders
  4. 1. Introduction
    1. Introduction (pp. 9-24)
    Jonathan Ben-Dov and Seth L. Sanders

    Sometime after the end of the Judahite monarchy, Jewish writers opened their eyes to the universe in an unprecedented way.¹ A new interest in the cosmos and its patterns appears in late-Persian and Hellenistic apocalyptic literature. For the first time in Jewish literature, we find astronomy and cosmic geography—secrets lying beyond the traditionally understood and immediately visible world—in theAstronomical Bookof Enoch and theBook of Watchers. Texts like the Aramaic Levi document and the Qumran physiognomies extend these interests from the stars to the measurement of materials and the human body. In these sources we find...

  5. 2. Enoch and the Beginnings of Jewish Interest in Natural Science
    2. Enoch and the Beginnings of Jewish Interest in Natural Science (pp. 25-50)
    Philip S. Alexander

    In his 1995 monographJewish Thought and Scientific Discovery in Early Modern EuropeDavid Ruderman discusses the question of Jewish attitudes towards and involvement in science.¹ There is, as has long been noted, an intriguing problem here. Jews in modern times have made a massive contribution to the advancement of the natural sciences, a contribution out of all proportion to their numbers. How is this striking fact to be explained? Are Jews genetically predisposed to be good at science, as some have seriously but implausibly argued. Or does the explanation lie in cultural factors, such as the nature of traditional...

  6. 3. Enoch’s Science
    3. Enoch’s Science (pp. 51-68)
    James VanderKam

    Enoch, so far as we know, was the first hero in the Jewish tradition with whom scientific material was associated. His area of scientific research and writing was astronomy, and an entire booklet containing his teachings on the subject has been preserved. TheAstronomical Bookof Enoch or theBook of the Luminariessurvives on a series of fragments from four manuscripts found in Qumran cave 4 (4Q208-211)¹ and to a greater extent though in a different form in a large number of Ethiopic copies. The Aramaic fragments preserve text in the original language of the composition; the Ethiopic version...

  7. 4. “I Was Shown Another Calculation” (אחזית חשבון אחרן): The Language of Knowledge in Aramaic Enoch and Priestly Hebrew
    4. “I Was Shown Another Calculation” (אחזית חשבון אחרן): The Language of Knowledge in Aramaic Enoch and Priestly Hebrew (pp. 69-102)
    Seth L. Sanders

    The earliest known Jewish scientific work is, probably not coincidentally, also the first known scientific work in Aramaic. This is theAstronomical Bookof Enoch, found at Qumran, the oldest manuscripts of which date to the 3rd century BCE The text is written in the cosmopolitan, high-cultural register of thelingua francaof the Babylonian and Persian empires known as Standard Literary Aramaic.³

    Its contents consist of a series of rules for the movement of the heavenly bodies and the increase and decrease of hours of light over the course of the year, presented as visions seen by the antediluvian...

  8. 5. Philological and Epistemological Remarks on Enoch’s Science: Response to Papers by Seth L. Sanders and James VanderKam
    5. Philological and Epistemological Remarks on Enoch’s Science: Response to Papers by Seth L. Sanders and James VanderKam (pp. 103-108)
    Loren T. Stuckenbruck

    The papers presented here both offer fine introductions that identify and problematize our understanding of the EnochicAstronomical Bookas a product of emerging Jewish tradition that drew upon and departed from received traditions found in the Bible, Ancient Near East and Hellenistic ideas. To a considerable degree, these papers, despite their common focus on theAstronomical Bookand interaction with the definitions of “science” by Philip Alexander, complement one another.

    The paper by Sanders is concerned with the interplay between etic and emic notions of “science” as it attempts to draw attention to helpful heuristic categories for analysis such...

  9. 6. Ideals of Science: The Infrastructure of Scientific Activity in Apocalyptic Literature and in the Yahad
    6. Ideals of Science: The Infrastructure of Scientific Activity in Apocalyptic Literature and in the Yahad (pp. 109-152)
    Jonathan Ben-Dov

    The fragments of scientific literature discovered among the Dead Sea Scrolls justify the title of the present book as a field of study. While previous studies in the field of the history of science pointed to systematic scientific activity among Jews only as early as the Islamic period,² it is now clear that science existed earlier in Jewish history. After the recent publication and discussion of the scientific material in the Dead Sea Scrolls, it is now time to access this corpus by means of more general questions: why is it that scientific activity existed in the Dead Sea Scrolls...

  10. 7. Networks of Scholars: The Transmission of Astronomical and Astrological Learning between Babylonians, Greeks and Jews
    7. Networks of Scholars: The Transmission of Astronomical and Astrological Learning between Babylonians, Greeks and Jews (pp. 153-194)
    Mladen Popović

    What do we know about what ancient Jewish scholars knew about what Babylonian scholars knew?¹ In order to answer this question we can analyse the different scholarly texts at our disposal, Babylonian and Jewish, and look for similarities and differences. We can then explain which Babylonian elements were familiar to Jewish scholars and how they appropriated, used and reworked these. Such analyses usually work from specific Jewish texts and then look for Babylonian elements, retracing these in specific cuneiform texts.

    The issue of tracking influences and cultural encounters between Babylonia and Jewish Palestine has another side to it, one not...

  11. 8. “Ancient Jewish Sciences” and the Historiography of Judaism
    8. “Ancient Jewish Sciences” and the Historiography of Judaism (pp. 195-254)
    Annette Yoshiko Reed

    Even a decade or so ago, it might have been difficult to imagine an entire conference and volume devoted to “ancient Jewish sciences.” InJewish Thought and Scientific Discovery in Early Modern Europe, for instance, David Ruderman noted how he had “originally intended to begin … with an overview of attitudes towards the natural world in ancient Judaism,” only to encounter “a vast body of material in an area that has not been fully studied.”¹ Such was the dearth of research that it warranted its own Appendix—a bibliographical essay sketching possible paths ahead.² Similarly, in 2002, when Y. Tzvi...

  12. A Bibliography for Ancient Jewish Sciences
    A Bibliography for Ancient Jewish Sciences (pp. 255-270)
  13. Index
    Index (pp. 271-275)