No Cover Image

The Rise of Baptist Republicanism

Oran P. Smith
Copyright Date: 1997
Published by: NYU Press
Pages: 334
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt9qg8g4
  • Cite this Item
  • Book Info
    The Rise of Baptist Republicanism
    Book Description:

    A Choice Outstanding Academic Book By championing the ideals of independence, evangelism, and conservism, the Southern Baptist Covention (SBC) has grown into the largest Protestant denomination in the country. The Convention's mass democratic form of church government, its influential annual meetings, and its sheer size have made it a barometer for Southern political and cultural shift. Its most recent shift has been starboard-toward fundamentalism and Republicanism. While the Convention once ofered a happy home to Harry Truman, Jimmy Carter, and church-state separationists, in the past two decades the SBC has become an uncomfortable institution for Democrats, progressive theologians, and other moderate voices. Current SBC member-heroes include Senators Trent Lott and Jesse Helms. Despite this seeming marginalization, Southern Baptist politicians have grown from political obscurity to occupying the four highest positions in the constitutional order of succesion to the presidency. President Bill Clinton, Vice President Al Gore, Senate President pro-tempore Strom Thurmond, and House Speaker Newt Gingrich are all Southern Baptists. In its emerging Republicanism, the SBC has taken on characteristics of its more active fellow travelers in the Christian Right, forging alliances with former enemies (African Americans amd Roman Catholics), playing presidential politics, establishing a Washington lobbying presence, working the political grassroots, and declaring war on Walt Disney. Each of these missions has been accomplished with calculating political precision. The Rise of Baptist Republicanism traces the Republicanization of the SBC's Republicanism in the context of the rise of the Fundamentalist Right and the emergence of a Republican majority in the South. Describing the SBC's political roots, Oran P. Smith contrasts Baptist Republicans with the rest of the Christian Right while revealing the theological, cultural, and historical factors which have made Southern Baptists receptive to Republican/Fundamentalist Right influences. The book is a must read for anyone wishing to understand the intersection of religion and politics in America today.

    eISBN: 978-0-8147-3976-1
    Subjects: Religion

Table of Contents

  1. Front Matter
    (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    (pp. vii-vii)
  3. LIST OF FIGURES
    (pp. viii-viii)
  4. LIST OF TABLES
    (pp. ix-ix)
  5. LIST OF APPENDICES
    (pp. x-x)
  6. Acknowledgments
    (pp. xi-xiv)
  7. 1 Introduction: Baptist Republicanism’s Cultural Antecedents
    (pp. 1-27)

    The story is told of a little boy selling puppies by the road in the rural South. An elderly gentleman passing by in a wagon, unsure of his failing eyesight, asks the lad what kind of puppies he has. “Methodistpuppies,” the boy quickly replies.

    The driver, amused by the boy’s apparent religious sensitivity, grins and drives on. A short time later the same commuter again sees the boy with his puppies. Sensing an opportunity to rib the child a bit, the man again asks the boy what kind of puppies he has. But just as quickly as before, the...

  8. 2 Backlash: Baptist Republicanism as Fundamentalist Reaction
    (pp. 28-67)

    About 150 years ago the Mormons began moving West. They traveled by horse and wagon in parties of 30 to 40 families, leaving at intervals of two or three weeks. The first party left in early spring. At the end of every day they stopped to make camp. But before they rested, some of the men unhitched their horses from the wagons, re-hitched them to plows, and began plowing together in the prairie. They did this again the next evening and the next, and the next, until they reached Utah, leaving a chain of little fields across the prairie. Later...

  9. 3 Culture War: Baptist Republicanism as Cultural Defense
    (pp. 68-97)

    As shown in the last chapter, both theological and political aspects contribute to Southern Baptist political change. These changes have come to the denomination through internal political struggles between organized factions of the middle and the right. But internal squabbling aside, what about factors external to the Convention? Is the rise of Baptist Republicanism not also due to external pressures as well? Do these pressures not spring from a changing religious and political culture?

    This chapter will, using social movement theory, explore the changing politics of the Southern Baptist Convention as brought on by the changing relation of the SBC...

  10. 4 Fundamental Differences: Baptist Republicanism’s Political Partners
    (pp. 98-112)

    The building blocks of any party system are issues and structures, or more formally, the platform of the political party and the people who organize around it under the party label. In some European countries, the meaning ofparty, as defined by the core agenda and voter groups associated with it, has changed little in the space of one hundred years.

    In Great Britain, laborers are Labour, and conservatives are Conservative, as it has always been. When I quizzed a mechanic from Warwickshire about his affiliation, he said, “I’m a working man, so I must be for Labour, you see.”...

  11. 5 Bible Belt: Baptist Republicanism in the Palmetto State
    (pp. 113-152)

    “Tip” O’Neill once explained that “all politics is local.” He was right. But had the Speaker been a member of the fundamentalist right (quite a stretch), he might have further explained that “all religious politics is local too, but not monolithic.” At least that is what South Carolina governor Carroll Campbell told me.

    In the three branches of the fundamentalist right we gain a unique understanding of politics and its varying tactics. No grasp of Baptist Republicanism can be achieved without understanding these simple distinctions. Our “local” setting is South Carolina. Our conclusion is that Southern Baptists are neither Bob...

  12. An insert of photographs
    (pp. None)
  13. 6 The Pew and the Pulpit: Baptist Republican Mass and Elite Politics
    (pp. 153-178)

    The SBC schism, though possessing its own unique characteristics, is a part of a general split within American Christendom. Reacting to changes in the culture, the Convention and the country, a conservative faction has arisen within the SBC bent on controlling the affairs of the fifteen-million-member organization, aligning its elites informally with the fundamentalist right political agenda and working Christian conservative politics down to the rank and file. Moreover, in terms of its preacher elite, the SBC is the embodiment of one side of what one Southern Baptist scholar has called a “‘two-party’ mobilization in American Protestantism between ‛modernist this-worldly...

  14. 7 United We Survive: Baptist Republican Alliances
    (pp. 179-190)

    In the last six chapters, we have traced the unique formation of an attraction between Southern Baptists and the Republican party through that attraction’s many antecedents. Along the way, we have found that Southern Baptists embody American Religion. It is in the United States that Baptists have grown so phenomenally. Their church government is historically so democratic that they have earned the label “hyper-Americans.”¹ If Southern Baptists are hyper-American, then, to coin another term, they must be “hyper-Southerners” as well.

    In their rigidness and conservatism, Southern Baptists have taken a path opposite to that of their northern brethren, preaching to...

  15. 8 Conclusion: Baptist Republicanism, Southern Conservatism, and American Politics
    (pp. 191-212)

    Is there a link between Bapticity and Republicanism inAmericanpolitics? That is not a simple question to answer, but there are a number of religious forces at work inSouthernpolitics that have national ramifications, and Southern religion is inevitably Baptist influenced.

    As table 8.1 shows, the first Clinton-Gore ticket was unpopular among white Southerners in general. Given the percentage the Democratic candidates received in each Southern state and voter registration statistics by race, white support can be calculated by state. This is determined by multiplyingcompositionbycohesion. If percentage of those voting who are black is multiplied...

  16. Appendices
    (pp. 213-236)
  17. Notes
    (pp. 237-280)
  18. Bibliography
    (pp. 281-312)
  19. Index
    (pp. 313-320)
  20. Back Matter
    (pp. 321-321)