Skip to Main Content
Have library access? Log in through your library
The shame of it

The shame of it: Global perspectives on anti-poverty policies

Erika K. Gubrium
Sony Pellissery
Ivar Lødemel
https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt9qgx0w
  • Cite this Item
  • Book Info
    The shame of it
    Book Description:

    The shame experienced by people living in poverty has long been recognised. Nobel laureate and economist, Amartya Sen, has described shame as the irreducible core of poverty. However, little attention has been paid to the implications of this connection in the making and implementation of anti-poverty policies. This important volume rectifies this critical omission and demonstrates the need to take account of the psychological consequences of poverty for policy to be effective. Drawing on pioneering empirical research in countries as diverse as Britain, Uganda, Norway, Pakistan, India, South Korea and China, it outlines core principles that can aid policy makers in policy development. In so doing, it provides the foundation for a shift in policy learning on a global scale and bridges the traditional distinctions between North and South, and high-, middle- and low-income countries. This will help students, academics and policy makers better understand the reasons for the varying effectiveness of anti-poverty policies.

    eISBN: 978-1-4473-0872-0
    Subjects: Political Science, Sociology

Table of Contents

  1. ONE Resetting the stage
    (pp. 1-16)
    Erika K. Gubrium

    In 1971, sociologist Robert Pinker made a frank observation about the field of social policy: ‘We know much more about the sentiments of philosophers and social scientists than those of ordinary people in everyday life’ (1971, p 135). The statement is as relevant today as it was then. Whether focused in the global South on intensive development and reconstruction, or in the global North on moving the long-term unemployed into the labour market, public social policy approaches all too frequently ‘take for granted the subjective perceptions of ordinary people’ (1971, p 136) rather than subjecting them to empirical investigation. This...

  2. TWO New urban poverty and new welfare provision: China’s dibao system
    (pp. 17-36)
    Ming Yan

    As the most populous country and carrying the oldest continuous civilisation, China has undergone drastic political and social changes in modern times. Its dynastic system that had lasted centuries was ended and replaced by the Republic in 1911, ending the Imperial rule of over 2,000 years. Following a series of civil wars, the Sino-Japanese War and revolution, the country regained peace and unity as the Communist Party established the People’s Republic in 1949. For the past six decades, the development of the Chinese economy can broadly be divided into two phases: the planned economy or socialist period until 1979, and...

  3. THREE Thick poverty, thicker society and thin state: policy spaces for human dignity in India
    (pp. 37-60)
    Sony Pellissery and Leemamol Mathew

    India is home to the largest number of poor people in the world. Of 1.13 billion people, 27.8 per cent live below the conservative income-based poverty line set by the Indian government and can thus be said to live in absolute poverty (Planning Commission, 2012). The face of this deep and persistent poverty is observable in minimal health expenditure, in the fact that more than 50 per cent of the population lives without sanitation facilities, in the presence of undignified ageing, as well as in poor educational standards, malnourished bodies, inferior housing, poor infrastructure resulting in deterioration in the quality...

  4. FOUR Self-sufficiency, social assistance and the shaming of poverty in South Korea
    (pp. 61-84)
    Yongmie Nicola Jo and Robert Walker

    South Korea was re-established in 1948 as an independent democratic nation after being annexed by Japan in 1910 for 35 years and experiencing three years of militaristic rule by the US between 1945 and 1948. However, the Korean War (1950-53) subsequently led to its partition into the Republic of Korea, better known as South Korea, and North Korea, the Democratic People’s Republic. Since the end of the war, South Korea has experienced a dramatic transformation in virtually every aspect of its social and economic life. From a country characterised by abject poverty, it has become the world’s 15th largest economy,...

  5. FIVE ‘Not good enough’: social assistance and shaming in Norway
    (pp. 85-110)
    Erika K. Gubrium and Ivar Lødemel

    Norway is a thin, stretched country with a population of just over 5 million. It is one of the world’s richest countries, and its residents possess among the lowest variability in living standards (The World Bank, 2011). There is a long-standing consensus among all political parties that the quality of health, education and social services should be equalised as much as possible throughout the nation. Hence, the Norwegian welfare state is built on the ‘citizenship’ principle, with schemes, for the most part, financed through general taxes and a tax system that is redistributive in nature (Kuhnle, 1994a, p 81). This...

  6. SIX Pakistan: a journey of poverty-induced shame
    (pp. 111-132)
    Sohail Choudhry

    A federal parliamentary republic of over 180 million people, Pakistan has the sixth largest population and 27th largest gross domestic product (GDP) purchasing power parity (PPP) in the world (IMF, 2012). However, its multidimensional poverty headcount stands at 49.4 per cent and it ranks 145th on the Human Development Index (OPHI, 2011; UN, 2011). Although the responsibility for policy theoretically rests with the Cabinet and individual ministers, because of a feeble and erratic democracy, it is often senior civil servants who assume the central roles in the conception, framing and delivery of policies.

    This chapter begins by tracing the evolution...

  7. SEVEN Separating the sheep from the goats: tackling poverty in Britain for over four centuries
    (pp. 133-156)
    Robert Walker and Elaine Chase

    The UK is a comparatively small, highly centralised state that operates a first past the post-electoral system.¹ This, combined with strong party loyalty, typically provides ministers with largely unfettered authority to reform policy while in government. The electoral system has also delivered comparatively long spells of government, often lasting two or three five-year terms. This means that it is not unheard of for substantive policy programmes to be implemented and then radically reversed by opposition parties subsequently entering government with a mission and mandate for reform. This said, the potential for inchoate and reactive policy-making is partially mitigated by a...

  8. EIGHT ‘Food that cannot be eaten’: the shame of Uganda’s anti-poverty policies
    (pp. 157-178)
    Grace Bantebya Kyomuhendo and Amon Mwiine

    Over the past 25 years, the varying approaches encompassed within Uganda’s anti-poverty effort have been touted as a best case model in the developing world (Hickey, 2011). Uganda is a land-locked country lying astride the equator in east central Africa. It is closely linked by economic and colonial history to Kenya in the east, Tanzania in the south, South Sudan and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) to the north and west respectively, and Rwanda in the southwest. Agriculture is the mainstay of the economy, contributing 31 per cent of the gross domestic product (GDP), 85 per cent of exports...

  9. NINE Shame and shaming in policy processes
    (pp. 179-198)
    Sony Pellissery, Ivar Lødemel and Erika K. Gubrium

    In the first chapter of this volume, Erika Gubrium showed how novel concerns in the current global stage have inspired our research on the relationship between shame and anti-poverty policy. As the volume by Chase and Bantebya (2014) demonstrates, shame is closely linked to poverty regardless of the existence and nature of anti-poverty policies. And where such programmes are in place, an encounter with officialdom is only one of many arenas where a poor person is reminded of his or her inferior status. Still, as the preceding chapters have demonstrated, and as we summarise here, policies and programmes have the...

  10. TEN Towards global principles for dignity-based anti-poverty policies
    (pp. 199-220)
    Erika K. Gubrium and Ivar Lødemel

    The context in which policy-making and delivery occurs is important when analysing the impact of policy. A brief example illustrates this point. One of the low-income respondents in rural Uganda invited us to her homestead. Her home was a hut made of dried mud with no windows. She hoped to be able to mend the thatch roof before the next rainy season. The empty dirt floor was just big enough for the floor mats that were rolled out at bedtime. Her family of five spent most of the time outside in front of the hut, where they prepared meals, washed...