Skip to Main Content
Have library access? Log in through your library
No Cover Image

Educational Delusions?: Why Choice Can Deepen Inequality and How to Make Schools Fair

Gary Orfield
Erica Frankenberg
Copyright Date: 2013
Edition: 1
Pages: 330
  • Cite this Item
  • Book Info
    Educational Delusions?
    Book Description:

    The first major battle over school choice came out of struggles over equalizing and integrating schools in the civil rights era, when it became apparent that choice could be either a serious barrier or a significant tool for reaching these goals. The second large and continuing movement for choice was part of the very different anti-government, individualistic, market-based movement of a more conservative period in which many of the lessons of that earlier period were forgotten, though choice was once again presented as the answer to racial inequality. This book brings civil rights back into the center of the debate and tries to move from doctrine to empirical research in exploring the many forms of choice and their very different consequences for equity in U.S. schools. Leading researchers conclude that although helping minority children remains a central justification for choice proponents, ignoring the essential civil rights dimensions of choice plans risks compounding rather than remedying racial inequality.

    eISBN: 978-0-520-95510-3
    Subjects: Education

Table of Contents

Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
  1. Front Matter
    (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    (pp. v-vi)
  3. List of Illustrations
    (pp. vii-viii)
    (pp. ix-xii)
    Gary Orfield and Erica Frankenberg

    • 1 Choice and Civil Rights: Forgetting History, Facing Consequences
      (pp. 3-36)
      Gary Orfield

      The idea of school choice has a tangled history. It is an idea that has taken many shapes, under the banner of the same hopeful word, one that seems to have a simple positive meaning but embodies many contradictory possibilities. Choice has a thousand different faces, some treacherous, some benign. It includes the creation of charter and magnet schools, voluntary transfer programs under state and federal legislation, choice-based desegregation plans, transfer rights under No Child Left Behind (NCLB), and voucher programs. The distinctions and this history are important to understand because forgetting what has been learned about choice systems that...

    • 2 Choice Theories and the Schools
      (pp. 37-66)
      Gary Orfield

      School choice has become so important in American educational policy discussions because it resonates strongly with the basic beliefs of many Americans and with important aspects of American social and political ideology. Wealthy business leaders who insist on data rather than theories in their own businesses pour money into charter schools based on a simple faith that markets relying on individual choice have transformative power and that governmental regulations and unionized work forces are the only basic obstacles to educational equity. Eli Broad, the Los Angeles billionaire whose foundation has had a great impact on current educational policy debates and...


    • 3 The Promise of Choice: Berkeley’s Innovative Integration Plan
      (pp. 69-88)
      Erica Frankenberg

      Since the 1960s, the Berkeley Unified School District (BUSD) in Berkeley, California, has voluntarily committed to integrating its schools. It provided the first major test of a city struggling to find a successful integration strategy that would survive court challenges after the Supreme Court forbade many kinds of voluntary desegregation plans in 2007.¹ In contrast to many other districts, which either let their desegregation standards in choice plans lapse or tried to substitute desegregation based only on socioeconomic status, which has typically not produced a high level of racial desegregation, Berkeley invented a method that used a sophisticated analysis of...

    • 4 Valuing Diversity and Hoping for the Best: Choice in Metro Tampa
      (pp. 89-106)
      Barbara Shircliffe and Jennifer Morley

      Serving Metro Tampa, the Hillsborough County Public Schools (HCPS) district has relied heavily on choice policies for the past two decades, and school leaders still express a significant commitment to using choice to promote school diversity even though the desegregation plan that led to the creation of many of the choice options has ended. After implementing a comprehensive desegregation plan following the Supreme Court’s 1971Swann v. Charlotte-Mecklenburgdecision authorizing the use of busing, this large system had few segregated schools for decades, while continuing to grow rapidly. The district was known for its historically positive leadership in pairing schools...

    • 5 Designing Choice: Magnet School Structures and Racial Diversity
      (pp. 107-126)
      Genevieve Siegel-Hawley and Erica Frankenberg

      Magnet schools represent the first mainstream policy effort to combine school choice with the pursuit of racial diversity.¹ During the 1970s, as urban districts around the country grappled with the implementation ofBrown v. Board of Education’s mandate, pioneering educators in Milwaukee, Cincinnati, Buffalo, and other communities sought to create educationally distinctive schools that would produce significant voluntary desegregation. When magnets first emerged as a major model of choice, almost all were designed as part of desegregation plans. Most of the start-up costs were thus funded through desegregation court orders or special federal desegregation aid money. Today, the unique features...


    • 6 A Segregating Choice? An Overview of Charter School Policy, Enrollment Trends, and Segregation
      (pp. 129-144)
      Erica Frankenberg and Genevieve Siegel-Hawley

      The expansion of charter schools has been championed by every presidential administration since that of George H. W. Bush, under whom the first such schools were founded. These administrations have supported charters by escalating financial allocations for them and using the presidential bully pulpit to promote their virtues.¹ Given such high levels of federal support, it is not surprising that charter school numbers have exploded over the past two decades, although nationally and in every state, charter schools still serve only a small fraction of the public school enrollment.

      In an extraordinary intervention in state education policy making, the Barack...

    • 7 Failed Promises: Assessing Charter Schools in the Twin Cities
      (pp. 145-158)
      Myron Orfield, Baris Gumus-Dawes and Thomas Luce

      Minnesota passed the nation’s first charter school law and has been at the center of a debate over the possible contribution of the surging charter school movement to equalizing opportunity for students of color, who are increasingly isolated in low-performing schools that are segregated by ethnicity and poverty. Unfortunately, data from the Twin Cities, two decades after charters began, shows that these schools are more segregated and unequal than public schools. Policies that produce true access to higher-achieving and more integrated schools, this study concludes, might well rely on more successful Minnesota experiments with regional approaches designed to voluntarily integrate...

    • 8 The State of Public Schools in Post-Katrina New Orleans: The Challenge of Creating Equal Opportunity
      (pp. 159-184)
      Baris Gumus-Dawes, Thomas Luce and Myron Orfield

      Charter schools in New Orleans have been hailed as the silver lining from Hurricane Katrina. The state of Louisiana used the hurricane as an opportunity to rebuild the entire New Orleans public school system, considered among the worst in the country, and launched the nation’s most extensive charter school experiment. These rebuilding efforts focused on charter schools not only as the primary means of expanding school choice in the public school system but also as a way of holding failing traditional public schools accountable at the district level. This chapter evaluates how this experiment has fared in providing quality education...


    • 9 The Story of Meaningful School Choice: Lessons from Interdistrict Transfer Plans
      (pp. 187-218)
      Amy Stuart Wells, Miya Warner and Courtney Grzesikowski

      For the past twenty years, enthusiastic calls for more school choice—from both the political right and left—have eclipsed most other educational reform proposals. Wealthy philanthropists have eagerly poured money into charter schools in urban neighborhoods where regular public schools are struggling to overcome the impact of poverty on too many families’ lives. The popular filmWaiting for “Superman”captured the hope these school choice supporters have placed in charter schools to save poor children from the cruel circumstances of separate and unequal neighborhoods and public schools.

      Lost amid the hype about charter schools and supermen are the increasing...

    • 10 School Information, Parental Decisions, and the Digital Divide: The SmartChoices Project in Hartford, Connecticut
      (pp. 219-237)
      Jack Dougherty, Diane Zannoni, Maham Chowhan, Courteney Coyne, Benjamin Dawson, Tehani Guruge and Begaeta Nukic

      Two rapidly expanding developments—public school choice and the World Wide Web—have dramatically altered U.S. elementary and secondary education during the past two decades. In many cities and states, traditional neighborhood school assignment patterns have given way to an increasing array of public sector options, such as magnet and charter schools. At the same time, we have witnessed a virtual explosion of school-level student achievement data across the internet. Many parents now go shopping for what they believe are the best public schools according to nationally popular websites hosted by Great Schools,Newsweek,andUS News and World Report...

    • 11 Experiencing Integration in Louisville: Attitudes on Choice and Diversity in a Changing Legal Environment
      (pp. 238-254)
      Gary Orfield and Erica Frankenberg

      The Supreme Court has been drawn into the struggles over the use of choice in desegregation plans on several occasions. In 1968 it rejected most choice plans as inadequate to achieve real desegregation inGreen v. New Kent County.¹ It approved limits on choice that were part of almost all desegregation plans, for example prohibiting transfers that would increase segregation. It forbade splitting up districts in ways that would foster segregation. In 2006, however, a group of parents from Louisville came into court claiming that their rights had been violated because the choice system was giving preference to the applications...

  9. Conclusion: A Theory of Choice with Equity
    (pp. 255-270)
    Gary Orfield and Erica Frankenberg

    Choice sounds good but can mean a myriad of very different things. There are choices that produce life-changing gains and bad choices that seem good but lead to disaster. The idea that any kind of choice will produce good results is something no parent or teacher would suggest. Similarly, there are markets that have powerful and creative results, like the computer market, and markets that are profitable but destructive, such as those for cigarettes, gambling, and illegal drugs. Wise choices in good educational markets can increase opportunity, but betting the future of students in devastated communities on the idea that...

    (pp. 271-294)
    (pp. 295-298)
  12. INDEX
    (pp. 299-317)