The Fall of the House of Roosevelt
The Fall of the House of Roosevelt: Brokers of Ideas and Power from FDR to LBJ
MICHAEL JANEWAY
Series: Columbia Studies in Contemporary American History
Copyright Date: 2004
Published by: Columbia University Press
https://doi.org/10.7312/jane13108
Pages: 352
https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7312/jane13108
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
The Fall of the House of Roosevelt
Book Description:

In the 1930s a band of smart and able young men, some still in their twenties, helped Franklin D. Roosevelt transform an American nation in crisis. They were the junior officers of the New Deal. Thomas G. Corcoran, Benjamin V. Cohen, William O. Douglas, Abe Fortas, and James Rowe helped FDR build the modern Democratic Party into a progressive coalition whose command over power and ideas during the next three decades seemed politically invincible.

This is the first book about this group of Rooseveltians and their linkage to Lyndon Johnson's Great Society and the Vietnam War debacle. Michael Janeway grew up inside this world. His father, Eliot Janeway, business editor of Time and a star writer for Fortune and Life magazines, was part of this circle, strategizing and practicing politics as well as reporting on these men. Drawing on his intimate knowledge of events and previously unavailable private letters and other documents, Janeway crafts a riveting account of the exercise of power during the New Deal and its aftermath. He shows how these men were at the nexus of reform impulses at the electoral level with reform thinking in the social sciences and the law and explains how this potent fusion helped build the contemporary American state. Since that time efforts to reinvent government by "brains trust" have largely failed in the U.S. In the last quarter of the twentieth century American politics ceased to function as a blend of broad coalition building and reform agenda setting, rooted in a consensus of belief in the efficacy of modern government.

Can a progressive coalition of ideas and power come together again? The Fall of the House of Roosevelt makes such a prospect both alluring and daunting.

eISBN: 978-0-231-50577-2
Subjects: History, Political Science
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. vii-viii)
  3. PREFACE: PUBLIC AND PRIVATE
    PREFACE: PUBLIC AND PRIVATE (pp. ix-xiv)
  4. THE PARTNERS
    • 1 Government by Brains Trust “GOD BLESS YOU; KEEP SCHEMING”
      1 Government by Brains Trust “GOD BLESS YOU; KEEP SCHEMING” (pp. 3-12)

      In the 1930s a band of smart and able young men, some still in their twenties, gained extraordinary access to the power to shape an American nation in crisis. As “president’s men” in a small, intimate system of government, then suddenly swelling into a vast administrative state, they gained an influence over the direction of the nation’s economy, governance, and social fabric previously enjoyed only by presidents themselves, a few of their cabinet members, plus a congressional potentate or two. Together they formed the first modern, peacetime American effort to fuse expertise, including the scholarly variety, with political power on...

    • 2 Tommy Corcoran and the New Dealers’ Gospel “YOU’RE BEGINNING TO BE AN OPERATOR — HOW DO YOU LIKE THE WATER?”
      2 Tommy Corcoran and the New Dealers’ Gospel “YOU’RE BEGINNING TO BE AN OPERATOR — HOW DO YOU LIKE THE WATER?” (pp. 13-27)

      Thomas G. Corcoran (“Tommy” to friends, enemies, and the press alike) was the most celebrated New Dealer, and the quintessential one. He was “the leader of the group, and we all followed,” one colleague reminisced fully four decades later. Following Felix Frankfurter’s lead, he recruited young lawyers and economists into the new, expanding agencies of government all over Washington.¹

      “There was no bureaucracy, none at all,” recalled Gerhard Gesell, who assisted Douglas at the SEC in sending the former head of the New York Stock Exchange to jail. “We were all people who knew one another. When there was a...

    • 3 Making the New Deal Revolution “THE SENSE OF BEING SPECIAL”
      3 Making the New Deal Revolution “THE SENSE OF BEING SPECIAL” (pp. 28-43)

      The art of political networking from the late 1930s to the 1960s assumed a landscape marked out by much firmer social, economic, and geographic boundaries and party affiliations than we know today. Some of them were already on their way to becoming fluid, but they were still clear-cut enough to be defining: Business, Labor, the Farm vote, the Negroes, the Catholics, the Jews, “the ethnics,” the Democratic South, Republican Midwest, Progressive Northwest, and so forth.

      Upon that landscape the two political parties organized themselves “from the courthouse to the White House,” as Lyndon Johnson used to say. Big city bosses...

    • 4 The Fight for the Rooseveltian Succession “DOUGLAS’S ARMY”
      4 The Fight for the Rooseveltian Succession “DOUGLAS’S ARMY” (pp. 44-66)

      Who was to be Franklin Roosevelt’s designated political legatee? Before 1940 Vice President John Nance Garner and cabinet members Harry Hopkins, James Farley, Cordell Hull, and Henry Wallace all coveted the honor. Succeeding to the vice presidency in 1941, it was Wallace’s to lose, which he did.

      There is little evidence that Roosevelt accepted and understood in the late spring of 1944 how fast his death was approaching, but White House visitors and those close to him were alarmed by his deterioration. And so the fight for the 1944 Democratic vice presidential nomination became a ferocious struggle for the Roosevelt...

    • Illustrations
      Illustrations (pp. None)
    • 5 1945—The New Dealers’ Government-in-Exile “I GOT THE CIRCUIT MOVING”
      5 1945—The New Dealers’ Government-in-Exile “I GOT THE CIRCUIT MOVING” (pp. 67-88)

      The New Dealers involved in regulating the relationship between government and business had run a risk foreseen by two of their political forbears, Woodrow Wilson and his adviser and friend Louis Brandeis. Disputing Teddy Roosevelt’s “New Nationalism” in the 1912 presidential campaign, before he himself became a regulator as president, candidate Wilson articulated a tenet of his “New Freedom”:

      If the government is to tell big business men how to run their business, then don’t you see that big business men have to get closer to the government even than they are now? Don’t you see that they must capture...

  5. IN MY FATHER’S HOUSE
    • 6 Rise of an Insider “WE’RE GOING TO GET HUBERT SOME DOUGH”
      6 Rise of an Insider “WE’RE GOING TO GET HUBERT SOME DOUGH” (pp. 91-111)

      The New Deal elite was a natural group for my father to align himself with as a young man. Like them, he had lofty aspirations and a scrappy personal makeup that linked passion for theory and dissent, instinct for original information—and for political maneuver.

      His story in a thumbnail, as I first learned it, was a blend of early prominence and shrouded mystery. He was the “baby” of three children (his sister and brother were twelve and eight years old when he was born in 1913). Their father, a hard-working doctor, died suddenly in 1937, and their mother was...

    • 7 Ends and Means “BABY, YOU’RE SUPERB!”
      7 Ends and Means “BABY, YOU’RE SUPERB!” (pp. 112-121)

      From his youthful radicalism my father retained profound skepticism of the establishment and a taste for carefully targeted subversion in the service of his goals. Less as a matter of doctrine than contrarian judgment call he would now and again wind up in a radical position on an issue of the moment. The day after the dropping of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima in 1945, for example, he remarked to Corcoran, “We will never live this down.” He held to that view.¹

      Toward the end of his life he recalled an odd encounter with Wendell Willkie, in the wake of...

    • 8 Forbidden Version “CONTINUE JANEWAY INQUIRY”
      8 Forbidden Version “CONTINUE JANEWAY INQUIRY” (pp. 122-142)

      Along with the secret history and glimpses of power in play to which I was exposed, there were also sensitive family matters, hidden away. On the one hand my father reveled in the display of his inside information. On the other hand there were aspects of his own story he’d long ago buried deep.

      I was fifteen when I found out that he was Jewish, born Eliot Jacobstein, and had changed his name—at fifteen.

      At the same moment I learned that my father had had a first wife. Cleaning out some closets for extra allowance, I came upon a...

  6. RECEIVERSHIP
    • 9 Enter LBJ, Stage Center “AVERAGE IN HONESTY, ABOVE AVERAGE IN ABILITY”
      9 Enter LBJ, Stage Center “AVERAGE IN HONESTY, ABOVE AVERAGE IN ABILITY” (pp. 145-163)

      Even in the glow of youth, his career prospects charmed by Franklin Roosevelt’s personal favor, he was a handful for his friends; temperamental as a racehorse. The young Lyndon Johnson operated on fuel that laced breathy aspiration with high-test anxiety.

      A note to my father in 1942, covering a copy of a commencement speech on winning the war while keeping faith with the New Deal:

      Dear Eliot,

      Here is a copy for you and one I want you to get Mr. Luce to read. After that terrible picture in TIME, I want to try to break into LIFE with a...

    • 10 1960—Checkmate “LOOKING BACK, THE RESULT WAS INEVITABLE”
      10 1960—Checkmate “LOOKING BACK, THE RESULT WAS INEVITABLE” (pp. 164-182)

      In the 1950s, associating his own success in leading the Senate out of stalemate with that of his hero, Majority Leader Lyndon Johnson would recall details of Franklin Roosevelt’s rescue of the nation from governmental paralysis in 1933. As a young staffer in the office of Texas Representative Richard Kleberg, he had firsthand recollections of the way Roosevelt matched physical presence to words and actions in the hundred days after he took office.

      One day in March 1958, moving to take advantage of the power vacuum flowing from President Eisenhower’s sloth in responding to the challenges of that year—a...

    • Illustrations
      Illustrations (pp. None)
    • 11 President of All the People “YOU CAN’T DEAL WITH HIM ANY LONGER”
      11 President of All the People “YOU CAN’T DEAL WITH HIM ANY LONGER” (pp. 183-205)

      That there were two Lyndon Johnsons (at least two) had been privately documented, and sometimes noted in the press, for years. Johnson’s friends from New Deal days had long ago learned that his bold, make-things-happen impresario side and his profoundly depressive one were connected; that satisfaction of the furies within Johnson was part of the fuel line driving him to original accomplishment, superb performance.

      Jim Rowe’s blast of a letter of October 1960 made the case that it was not the targets of Johnson’s rages who were at fault; rather, “LBJ is the trouble.” My father had said the same...

    • 12 Last Act “WE GOT YOUR MAN”
      12 Last Act “WE GOT YOUR MAN” (pp. 206-218)

      I had found it odd in the 1960s and seventies that my father had not been more rocked than he seemed to be by the disasters involving financial arrangements with dubious outside benefactors that befell his friends Justices Abe Fortas and Bill Douglas. His comments at first were acerbic, to the effect that his intimates from another time had been both chintzy and foolish.

      With Nixon and John Mitchell at the controls, leaking damaging details to members of Congress and the press, Fortas was driven from the scene in May 1969. Ironically disparate character traits prevailed. In this face-off Douglas,...

  7. Epilogue
    Epilogue (pp. 219-224)

    Perhaps I’ve brought the two sets of memory—one public, the other private, the second blurring with the first—into register. Perhaps not. Perhaps it depends on how you’re inclined to factor the personalities of the powerful into the way you think about how history unfolds—and how much any of us, however privileged (and thus skewed) our perspective, really knows what goes on inside the minds of others.

    There is the issue of outsized personalities, like Johnson’s, Corcoran’s, and my father’s, that fit no molds, and fall into fatal excess or dysfunction. On the other hand, how do we...

  8. NOTES
    NOTES (pp. 225-270)
  9. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
    ACKNOWLEDGMENTS (pp. 271-274)
  10. INDEX
    INDEX (pp. 275-284)
Columbia University Press logo