Planning the Family in Egypt
Planning the Family in Egypt
KAMRAN ASDAR ALI
Copyright Date: 2002
Published by: University of Texas Press
https://doi.org/10.7560/705135
https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7560/705135
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Planning the Family in Egypt
Book Description:

In this ethnographic study, the author examines the policies and practices of family planning programs in Egypt to see how an elitist, Western-informed state attempts to create obliging citizens. The state sees voluntary compliance with the law for the common good as the cornerstone of modernity. Family planning programs are a training ground for the construction of self-disciplined individuals, and thus a rewarding area of study for the fate of social programs in developing countries.

Through a careful examination of state-endorsed family planning practices in urban and rural contexts, the author shows us the pervasive, high-pressure persuasion of women, who are encouraged to think as individual decision makers of their immediate families and their national interests. But what of the other forces at work in these women's lives, binding them to their extended families and to their religious identities? And what of the laws that allow for polygamy and discriminate against women in marriage, inheritance, and as part of the workforce?

These forces operate against the received wisdom of the state. Is the Muslim community thought to end at the borders of Egypt? What about local constructions of masculinity when the state appeals to wives to decide for themselves? How does widespread labor migration to foreign countries affect attitudes toward family planning? How is female contraception viewed by the Islamic Brotherhood and other modern Muslim groups?

This book questions much that we have taken for granted and gives us grounds for reexamining our assumptions about family planning and the individual and state in developing countries such as Egypt.

eISBN: 978-0-292-79818-2
Subjects: Sociology
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-vi)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. vii-viii)
  3. Acknowledgments
    Acknowledgments (pp. ix-xii)
  4. Note on Transliteration
    Note on Transliteration (pp. xiii-xvi)
  5. Introduction
    Introduction (pp. 1-20)

    This text discusses how development initiatives in general and family planning in particular help train and produce new bodies and selves in the wider context of capital expansion and accumulation as we enter the twenty-first century.² I argue that family planning programs do not just reduce the number of children and regulate reproduction. Rather, they also introduce or foster notions of individual choice and responsibility, risk aversion, and personal independence. In short, they help to construct a new kind of individuality, guided by legal constructs of citizenship rather than by communitarian and familial control.

    Taking the Egyptian family planning program...

  6. Part 1
    • Chapter 1 History of Family Planning
      Chapter 1 History of Family Planning (pp. 23-39)

      In a work of fiction from late-nineteenth-century Egypt, the main protagonist is a writer who goes to the tombs outside Cairo for inspiration. One day he encounters an elderly noble who steps out from one of the graves. After a brief introduction the grave dweller asks the writer to go to his house and fetch him his horse and some clothes. The author respectfully replies that he does not know where the nobleman lives. The infuriated elder curses and says:

      “Tell me which country you are from, for heavens sake? It’s clear that you are not an Egyptian. There is...

    • Chapter 2 Changing Behavior
      Chapter 2 Changing Behavior (pp. 40-60)

      A promotional video on counseling techniques that is shown in Egyptian family planning clinics tells the story of Fatima. Fatima lives in a workingclass neighborhood in a large city. She is shown to be frustrated by her daily chores and by the burden of caring for her children alone while her husband is away at work. One day a neighbor explains to her the benefits of family planning. The neighbor then accompanies Fatima to the clinic where she is received with extreme courtesy and is counseled on the pros and cons of a range of contraceptive choices. The neighbor, although...

  7. Part 2
    • Chapter 3 Spatial Context
      Chapter 3 Spatial Context (pp. 63-79)

      As I discussed in my analysis of the Egypt Male Survey in the preceding chapter, demographic studies on Egypt tend to be constructed in terms of the rural-urban divide. In this formulation the rural is defined as the traditional space, and the urban pertains to the modern and the progressive. Egyptian health- and population-related surveys are generally designed to capture the negative impact of rural living and peasant behavior on contraceptive prevalence and acceptance. Arguably there are social distinctions that need to be recognized within a population group on the basis of where people live. In this chapter I use...

    • Chapter 4 Women’s Bodies
      Chapter 4 Women’s Bodies (pp. 80-101)

      My introduction into Qaramoos, the Delta village community in which I did part of my fieldwork,¹ was through a local family health center, staffed primarily by doctors from a medical research university in Cairo. The doctors provided services and conducted research in the area for their postgraduate degrees. At this stage of my research, I was interested in becoming familiar with the people who used the clinic.

      One of the doctors, a senior gynecologist and obstetrician attending to the clinic, suggested that conducting focus groups would aid in the process ofmy introduction. To broaden the research agenda, the focus groups...

    • Chapter 5 Women’s Choices
      Chapter 5 Women’s Choices (pp. 102-119)

      “Ihna rabish” (we are rubbish) was how Rasha responded when I asked her whether she had any opinion on the family planning program in Egypt. She was a high-school-educated clerk employed by the family planning clinic near Qaramoos. Her disgust, expressed partly in English, was directed at the kinds of contraceptive pills available at the clinic. Women she knew had suffered multiple medical problems while on the pill and could not afford the luxury of a healthy diet that could counter their harmful effects.

      While the Egyptian state implements its population management policy under the guidance of international donors and...

    • Chapter 6 Men and Family Planning
      Chapter 6 Men and Family Planning (pp. 120-136)

      The Lacoutures continue by emphasizing that “the population increase in Egypt, from a social point of view, is linked to ignorance, superstition, ill health, poverty and the Islamic customs themselves (polygamy and divorce)” (1958: 358). Like many authors of the colonial and contemporary eras, the Lacoutures argue that these demographic and social problems could be corrected only through education and social development and by “restoring women to a sense of their human dignity and men to the sense of their responsibility” (360).¹

      Leila Ahmed (1992) reminds us that arguments that linked Islam and its traditions with the subjugation of women,...

  8. Part 3
    • Chapter 7 Constructing New Selves
      Chapter 7 Constructing New Selves (pp. 139-152)

      The population debate in Egypt has many actors. As much as it is a site of dialogue between the Egyptian state and international donors such as USAID, it is also an arena of discussion and confrontation between the state and other social forces in contemporary Egypt. Among them are the women’s groups, who criticize the state’s population policy from a secular women’s/feminist perspective,¹ and the Islamists, who take a religious perspective.² These political and social groups compete with the Egyptian state on the terms on which modern domestic spaces should be incorporated into a future nation.

      Through ethnographic examples and...

    • Chapter 8 Islamist Futures
      Chapter 8 Islamist Futures (pp. 153-162)

      It is important to note that some Egyptian scholars opposed the late-nineteenth-century liberal agenda of scientific progress and domestic change. Many Egyptian male intellectuals of that time took a critical stance against the advocacy of unveiling and female education by female writers and liberals like Qasim Amin.¹ Their opposition to women’s public education and participation in the workforce indicates a different response to colonial cultural pressures by some within the educated class. Omnia Shakry (1998), in an important essay on domesticity in latenineteenth-century Egypt, argues that the changes in the domestic sphere arose out of a dialogue with colonial discourse,...

  9. Conclusion
    Conclusion (pp. 163-168)

    International development agencies view the nuclearization of families as positively influencing contraceptive use by Egyptian women. In the last several decades Western social science has also portrayed the nuclear family as linked to progress and democratic norms and essential for the spread and consolidation of capitalism (Stacey 1996). The process of nuclearization of households may, however, have less to do with the desires of the international agencies or with academic fashion than with changes in social and economic parameters of living. These changes are more pronounced in urban areas, where the poor around the globe increasingly face a dismantling of...

  10. Notes
    Notes (pp. 169-198)
  11. Bibliography
    Bibliography (pp. 199-222)
  12. Index
    Index (pp. 223-234)
University of Texas Press logo