No Cover Image
Gabriel García Moreno and Conservative State Formation in the Andes
Peter V. N. Henderson
Copyright Date: 2008
Published by: University of Texas Press
https://doi.org/10.7560/719033
https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7560/719033
Search for reviews of this book
Book Info
Gabriel García Moreno and Conservative State Formation in the Andes
Book Description:

This book explores the life and times of Ecuador's most controversial politician within the broader context of the new political history, addressing five major themes of nineteenth-century Latin American history: the creation of political networks, the divisiveness of regionalism, the bitterness of the liberal-conservative ideological divide, the complicating problem ofcaudillismo, and the quest for progress and modernization.

Two myths traditionally associated with García Moreno's rule are debunked. The first is that he created a theocracy in Ecuador. Instead, the book argues that he negotiated a concordat with the Papacy giving the national government control over the church's secular responsibilities, and subordinated the clergy, many of whom were highly critical of García Moreno, to the conservative state. A second, frequently repeated generalization is that he created a conservative dictatorship out of touch with the liberal age in which he lived. Instead, the book argues that moderates held sway during the first nine years of García Moreno's period of influence, and only during his final term did he achieve the type of conservative state he thought necessary to advance his progressive nation-building agenda.

In sum, this book enriches our understanding of many of the notions of state formation by suggesting that conservatives like García Moreno envisioned a program of material progress and promoting national unity under a very different formula from that of nineteenth-century liberals.

eISBN: 978-0-292-79414-6
Subjects: History
You do not have access to this book on JSTOR. Try logging in through your institution for access.
Log in to your personal account or through your institution.
Table of Contents
Export Selected Citations Export to NoodleTools Export to RefWorks Export to EasyBib Export a RIS file (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...) Export a Text file (For BibTex)
Select / Unselect all
  1. Front Matter
    Front Matter (pp. i-iv)
  2. Table of Contents
    Table of Contents (pp. v-vi)
  3. List of Illustrations
    List of Illustrations (pp. vii-viii)
  4. Acknowledgments
    Acknowledgments (pp. ix-x)
  5. Introduction
    Introduction (pp. xi-xv)

    Well beyond a century and a quarter following his death, Gabriel García Moreno remains “the most argued about personality in the history of Ecuador.”¹ His importance as Ecuador’s leading political figure from 1859 to 1875, however, extended far beyond the borders of this small (about the size of Colorado) Andean nation, as his actions and ideas resonated throughout Latin America and Europe. Not surprisingly, then, writers in multiple languages have penned more than thirty full-length biographies of the man, although none in English since 1914.

    Not only Ecuadorian intellectuals but also average citizens still hold strong opinions about García Moreno,...

  6. [Maps]
    [Maps] (pp. xvi-xviii)
  7. Chapter One Preparing for National Leadership, 1821–1859
    Chapter One Preparing for National Leadership, 1821–1859 (pp. 1-30)

    Although it was the morning of Christmas Eve, one of the holiest days of the religious calendar, Doña Mercedes Moreno de García decided not to attend Mass. She felt a stirring in her womb and, having given birth ten times previously (with eight children still living), she knew her time was near. A joyful mood filled the household, even though the family fortunes had declined recently. The new arrival’s imminent birth would coincide with the holiday season, a good omen for the very devout family. And that evening—December 24, 1821—Gabriel García Moreno made his appearance.¹

    The father, Gabriel...

  8. Chapter Two Regionalism and Civil War, 1859–1860
    Chapter Two Regionalism and Civil War, 1859–1860 (pp. 31-61)

    When Gabriel García Moreno was courting his future bride in 1846, one of his good friends from Quito wrote him: “Now we have the good fortune of seeing you completely established inour country[nuestro país,meaning Quito and the northern and central sierra] and united with one of the most distinguished señoritas we have.”¹ Certainly as of the 1860s, most Ecuadorians conceived of “my country” as the region in which they had been born and were living. Very few Ecuadorians traveled—García Moreno being a clear exception. The state of the country’s roads was abysmal, but additionally most people...

  9. Chapter Three A Presidency Constrained I: Federalism and Domestic Policy, 1861–1865
    Chapter Three A Presidency Constrained I: Federalism and Domestic Policy, 1861–1865 (pp. 62-91)

    Having victoriously concluded the bitterly contested civil war, García Moreno faced the future with both hope and misgivings. On one hand, with General Franco and the liberal militarists exiled, García Moreno could begin to fashion his nation-building project. Years of traveling and observing the European world had provided him with ideas that he believed would transform Ecuador into a modern progressive state. On the other hand, García Moreno knew that his reforms, some of which contravened the more popular and commonplace ideas of liberal state formation, would provoke resistance and conflict. Malcontents and exiles clamored for a resumption of the...

  10. Chapter Four A Presidency Constrained II: Foreign Entanglements, 1861–1865
    Chapter Four A Presidency Constrained II: Foreign Entanglements, 1861–1865 (pp. 92-116)

    As much as the federalist Constitution of 1861 and the shaky state of Ecuador’s finances complicated García Moreno’s desire to create a modern Catholic state, foreign policy difficulties and wars hampered progress even more. Many critical biographers have attributed Ecuador’s foreign policy woes in the early 1860s to García Moreno’s irascible and impetuous temperament, and rightly so. Whether slapping a minister who had insulted his brother-in-law or chiding a close friend who had not fully credited him for his mountain-climbing efforts, García Moreno had been long famous for his short temper. In addition García Moreno lacked patience, an important attribute...

  11. Chapter Five Becoming the Indispensable Man, 1865–1869
    Chapter Five Becoming the Indispensable Man, 1865–1869 (pp. 117-144)

    Regionalism and state-formation projects were not the only difficult issues facing Latin Americans in the nineteenth century. Additionally they had to contend with the phenomenon ofcaudillismo, the rule of the “indispensable leader” or military boss, who alone (at least in the leader’s mind) could rule a nation. During the years between 1865 and 1869, this chapter will argue, García Moreno emerged as a caudillo, although an unusual variant of the stereotype. Scholars have long debated the nature and origins of the caudillo. Some writers have viewedcaudillismoas part of the heritage of colonial culture, which included an authoritarian...

  12. Chapter Six Forging the National Soul: The Coming of the Catholic Nation
    Chapter Six Forging the National Soul: The Coming of the Catholic Nation (pp. 145-176)

    As city after city capitulated peacefully to the coup of January 17, 1869, Gabriel García Moreno relished the opportunity to impose his vision of a modernizing Catholic state on Ecuador.¹ Not unreasonably, García Moreno interpreted the country’s acquiescence as a mandate for his ideas, or at the very least a recognition of his newfound popularity in the wake of the reconstruction of Imbabura. Regardless of the reasons for his victory, García Moreno knew he could not fulfill his dream of the Catholic nation under the old constitution. As he had reiterated many times, the Constitution of 1861 had frustrated his...

  13. Chapter Seven Caring for Earthly Needs: The Program for Economic Development
    Chapter Seven Caring for Earthly Needs: The Program for Economic Development (pp. 177-208)

    Gabriel García Moreno was in many ways an unusual conservative politician. On one hand, he believed in conservative Catholic values as a means of unifying the country, as explained in the last chapter, while on the other hand, he strongly advocated economic and technical modernization. This chapter will focus on that second facet, the one that dwelled on the realm of the practical. Like nearly every nineteenth-century Latin American leader, he embraced the notion of progress—or in twenty-first-century nomenclature, economic development. Having lived in Paris, traveled extensively throughout Western Europe, and visited the eastern seaboard of the United States...

  14. Chapter Eight Death and the Hereafter
    Chapter Eight Death and the Hereafter (pp. 209-237)

    The previous chapters have examined García Moreno’s life and times chronologically while exploring themes of nineteenth-century Andean history, especially state formation. In contrast, this final chapter will focus on the events of a single day—August 6—during the remarkable year of 1875, in which Alexander Graham Bell made the first telephone call, Georges Bizet’s operaCarmenopened to rave reviews, and the initial Kentucky Derby was run. A drama of Shakespearean proportions was about to be played out on the grand stage of this country straddling the equator. The upcoming play brilliantly juxtaposed characters straight from Stratford-on-Avon. We will...

  15. Conclusion
    Conclusion (pp. 238-244)

    The heated debate between liberals and conservatives about García Moreno and his role in the formation of the Ecuadorian state continues to the present. Perhaps the best evidence of the bitterness of this quarrel can be encapsulated in the controversies over whether statues of García Moreno ought to be placed in public spaces in Quito and Guayaquil. Given his troubled relationship with many influentialguayaquileños,a frosty reception to the idea of a monument there should have been anticipated. Nevertheless, during the 1950s friends of the fallen dictator hired a sculptor to carve a bust of García Moreno for display...

  16. Notes
    Notes (pp. 245-288)
  17. Bibliography
    Bibliography (pp. 289-302)
  18. Index
    Index (pp. 303-310)
University of Texas Press logo